Do I actually need a buyer’s agent on the Big Island, or can I just work with the listing agent?

You don't actually need a buyer's agent on the Big Island, and you can work with the listing agent instead. Just know the listing agent represents the seller, and Hawaiʻi's real estate commission says a seller's agent can't negotiate the terms for you. If one agent represents both sides, Hawaiʻi requires written consent from you and the seller.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • You can go without one: Hawaiʻi's real estate commission says a buyer may decide they don't need their own broker.
  • The listing agent works for the seller: their first loyalty is to the seller, and they can't negotiate the terms for you.
  • Guard what you share: a seller's agent has to pass along things like how soon you need to move.
  • Both sides consent in writing: one agent can't represent you and the seller without written consent from each of you.
  • Expect a written agreement: under Realtor rules, an agent working with you needs one before you tour a home together.

What does a buyer’s agent do on the Big Island that a listing agent can’t?

A buyer’s agent on the Big Island negotiates the price and terms for you, and a listing agent can’t. Hawaiʻi’s real estate commission says a listing agent’s primary loyalty is to the seller (Hawaiʻi Real Estate Commission). That agent can still help you in real ways:

What you get Listing agent Your own buyer’s agent
Whose interests come first The seller’s Yours
Facts on the home, similar sales and financing Yes Yes
Help writing and presenting your offer Yes Yes
Negotiating the terms for you No Yes

Be careful what you tell a listing agent. Things like how soon you need to move, or that you’d pay more, have to go to the seller. Your own agent can also search out other homes for you and help you settle on an offer price, the first step toward an offer that wins without overpaying.

What does Hawaiʻi law require when one agent represents both the buyer and the seller?

Hawaiʻi law requires written consent from both the buyer and the seller before one agent represents both of them in a sale, which is called dual agency. A general line in the consent saying the agent represents both sides isn’t enough (Hawaiʻi Administrative Rules §16-99-3.1). The real estate commission’s consumer guide says the agent must:

  • Tell both of you about the dual representation
  • Briefly describe the kind of representation each of you will get
  • Share the facts that matter to each of you, including any possible conflict of interest
  • Get your written consent, and the seller’s

You don’t have to agree to dual representation. Knowing the facts, the commission says, will help you decide how much personal information to share with that agent (Hawaiʻi Real Estate Commission).

When does a Big Island agent have to tell me who they represent?

A Big Island agent has to tell you who they represent before any purchase contract is prepared, either out loud or in writing (HAR §16-99-3.1). The rule requires disclosure at several points. Four of them involve you as the buyer:

Before a contract is written
The agent helping you says whether they represent you or the seller.
Before negotiating starts
Your own agent tells the seller’s side they represent you. An agent buying for themselves has to say so too.
In the purchase contract
A paragraph titled “AGENCY DISCLOSURE” confirms in writing who represents whom.
When something changes
The agent promptly gives you a revised disclosure.

Who pays an agent doesn’t by itself decide who they represent, and the rule says so directly. So ask early, and ask again if anything about the arrangement changes.

Do I have to sign an agreement with a buyer’s agent before touring Big Island homes?

You’ll usually have to sign a written agreement with a buyer’s agent before touring Big Island homes together. Since August 17, 2024, National Association of Realtors rules have required agents in a multiple listing service to sign one before touring a home with a buyer (National Association of Realtors). That covers live video tours too.

The agreement has to state the agent’s pay, or how it’s worked out, and the amount can’t be open-ended. It also has to say that fees aren’t set by law and are fully negotiable. Before you sign one:

  1. Read how long it lasts, and ask for a shorter term if you’d like one
  2. Check whether it covers one home, one area or your whole search
  3. Find the line that says how your agent is paid
  4. Look for the services the agent will provide, spelled out clearly
  5. Read how either of you can end it, and what still applies after it ends

Next, see how a Big Island agent represents you from a distance and where each step sits in the Big Island buying process.

Sources

  1. Hawaiʻi Real Estate Commission, Working with a Real Estate Broker (consumer guide, linked from the DCCA Real Estate Branch's consumer resources)
  2. Hawaiʻi Administrative Rules, Title 16, Chapter 99, Real Estate Brokers and Salespersons, §16-99-3.1 Disclosure of agency (DCCA)
  3. National Association of Realtors, Written Buyer Agreements 101

Frequently asked questions

Can I call the listing agent about a Big Island home I found online?

You can call the listing agent about a Big Island home you found online, and they can answer your questions about it. They represent the seller, though. Keep your top price and your deadlines to yourself on that call, because a seller's agent has to pass that kind of information to the seller.

Will I pay less for a Big Island home if I don't have my own agent?

Going without your own agent doesn't guarantee you'll pay less for a Big Island home. The seller still decides what to accept, and the listing agent's first loyalty is to the seller. Agents' fees aren't set by law and are negotiable, so ask how the fees would change before you decide.

Does the seller paying my agent mean my agent works for the seller?

In Hawaiʻi, your agent can work for you even when the seller pays your agent. The state's rule says who pays a broker doesn't by itself decide who the broker represents. Your written agreement and the agency disclosure in your contract show whose side your agent is on.

Can an agent from the listing agent's own brokerage represent me?

An agent from the listing agent's own brokerage can represent you only if you and the seller both consent in writing. Hawaiʻi's sample agency disclosure speaks for the whole brokerage and every agent in it, so that firm would be on both sides of the sale. Ask how they'd handle that before you share your budget.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields