Should I pay cash for a Big Island luxury home or finance it, and what do most buyers at this level actually do?

Whether to pay cash or finance a Big Island luxury home depends on what you'd rather keep: cash free for other uses, or a purchase with no loan. Buyers at this level do both, and loan records can't show which is more common. In 2025, lenders reported 66 purchase loans on Big Island homes valued at $2 million or more.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • Buyers here do both: lenders reported 66 purchase loans on Big Island homes valued at $2 million or more in 2025.
  • Cash keeps it simple: there's no loan approval, lender appraisal or monthly payment to deal with.
  • A loan keeps cash free: your money can stay invested, or on hand for what the home costs to own.
  • The interest deduction has a cap: on 2025 returns, it covers interest on up to $750,000 of mortgage debt.
  • You can borrow later: Fannie Mae's rules allow a loan within six months of a cash purchase, within limits.

Do Big Island luxury buyers pay cash or take out a mortgage?

Big Island luxury buyers do both: some pay cash and some take out a mortgage. Federal loan records show the ones who borrowed. In 2025, lenders reported 66 first mortgages for buying Hawaiʻi County homes valued at $2 million or more (HMDA data). Here’s what those buyers planned to do with the homes:

How the buyer planned to use the home Loans in 2025
A second home 27
Their main home 24
An investment property 15

Cash buyers don’t appear in those records, so the records can’t tell you which group is bigger. They do show that 56 of the 66 loans were too large for Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac to buy, which makes them jumbo loans. If you’ll borrow at this price, start with a lender that makes jumbo loans.

Why would a buyer pay cash for a Big Island luxury home?

A buyer would pay cash for a Big Island luxury home to buy with fewer steps and no loan to carry afterward. Paying cash takes these off your list:

  • A loan application, income checks and a lender’s approval
  • A lender’s appraisal of the home
  • Interest, and a monthly payment
  • A stack of loan papers to sign, which helps if you’re buying from the mainland

Paying cash also ties up more of your money in one home. You’ll still owe the yearly costs of owning it, starting with Big Island property tax, so keep enough on hand to run the home after you buy it.

Why would a buyer finance a Big Island luxury home they could pay for in cash?

A buyer would finance a Big Island luxury home they could pay for in cash to keep that cash free for other uses. Two things decide whether that’s worth it.

The loan rate against what your cash earns

If your money earns more where it is than the loan costs you, borrowing can make sense. Check where mortgage rates stand now before you compare the two.

The cap on deducting mortgage interest

On 2025 returns, the IRS lets you deduct interest on up to $750,000 of mortgage debt on your main home and a second home, if you itemize (IRS Publication 936). That’s $375,000 if you’re married and filing separately. Interest on debt above the cap isn’t deductible, so ask your CPA what the deduction is worth to you.

Can I pay cash for a Big Island home now and get a mortgage later?

You can pay cash for a Big Island home now and get a mortgage later. Fannie Mae’s rules allow a cash-out loan within six months of a cash purchase, under what it calls the delayed financing exception (Fannie Mae Selling Guide). The main conditions:

  • Your purchase closing statement shows no mortgage was used
  • The title report shows no liens on the home
  • You document where the purchase money came from
  • The new loan is no more than what you put in, plus the new loan’s closing costs, fees and points

That rule covers loans Fannie Mae buys, and in Hawaiʻi County those top out at $1,249,125 for a one-unit home in 2026. For a larger loan, ask a jumbo lender whether it offers the same thing.

How do I decide between paying cash and financing a Big Island luxury home?

To decide between paying cash and financing a Big Island luxury home, compare what each one costs you over the years you’ll own it. Take these steps in order:

  1. Decide how much cash you want left after closing, for the home’s yearly costs and anything unexpected
  2. Ask a lender what a loan at your price would cost each year, fees included
  3. Ask your CPA what the interest deduction would be worth to you, given the $750,000 cap
  4. Compare the loan’s cost after taxes with what your cash earns where it sits now
  5. Settle on your plan before you write an offer, so the contract matches how you’ll pay

If you’ll borrow, add the closing costs a loan brings to your numbers. If you’re borrowing against a cash buyer, read how a financed buyer can compete.

Sources

  1. Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council, HMDA Data Browser: 2025 home purchase loans originated, Hawaii County, HI
  2. IRS Publication 936 (2025), Home Mortgage Interest Deduction
  3. Fannie Mae Selling Guide B2-1.3-03, Cash-Out Refinance Transactions (Delayed Financing Exception)

Frequently asked questions

Is it smart to pay cash for a Big Island home while mortgage rates are high?

Paying cash for a Big Island home while mortgage rates are high saves you the interest, though your cash stops earning whatever it earned before. Compare the loan's rate after any tax deduction with what that money earns now. If rates fall later, a cash buyer can still borrow, within six months under Fannie Mae's delayed financing rule or with a regular cash-out loan after that.

Can I use a home equity line on my mainland house to pay cash for a Big Island home?

You can use a home equity line on your mainland house to pay cash for a Big Island home, and still take a loan on the new home within six months. Fannie Mae's delayed financing rule allows it if the new loan's cash pays that line off or down. Your lender will count any balance left on the line in your monthly debts.

Can I get a loan later if I buy a Big Island home in a trust or an LLC?

Getting a loan later on a Big Island home bought in a trust or an LLC can work under Fannie Mae's delayed financing rule. It covers a revocable trust you set up and benefit from, and an LLC or partnership you own 100%. Other setups may not qualify, so ask the lender before you decide how to buy.

How many Big Island buyers took out jumbo loans in 2025?

Big Island buyers took out 92 jumbo loans in 2025, out of 1,747 first mortgages lenders reported for buying a home in Hawaiʻi County. A jumbo loan is one too large for Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac to buy.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields