What kind of person actually thrives living on the Big Island, and who ends up moving back to the mainland?

The person who actually thrives living on the Big Island has room in the budget, patience with fewer choices and ease with being far from family. Cost of living is the reason people give most often for leaving Hawaiʻi. Test yourself against both before you buy.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • People leave Hawaiʻi every year: about 53,000 moved from Hawaiʻi to another state in 2024, by the Census Bureau's estimate.
  • About as many arrive: a similar number moved to Hawaiʻi from other states that same year.
  • Cost is the reason given most: university researchers say cost of living is the most commonly cited reason for leaving.
  • Some traits make island life easier: room in the budget, patience with waits and ease with distance from family.
  • Test yourself before you buy: answer the six questions below before you make an offer.

How many people move away from Hawaiʻi, and why do they leave?

About 53,000 people moved away from Hawaiʻi to another state in 2024, and the reason people give most often for leaving is the cost of living. The Census Bureau’s estimates for that year (American Community Survey):

  • Moved from Hawaiʻi to another state: about 53,200, give or take about 7,900
  • Moved to Hawaiʻi from another state: about 53,700, give or take about 5,800

These cover the whole state and every kind of mover, with 90% margins of error. They don’t say who left after retiring here or buying a home.

Over a longer stretch, more residents left Hawaiʻi for the continent than arrived in 23 of the past 25 years. That’s from a March 2026 post by two researchers at UHERO, the University of Hawaiʻi’s economic research organization, and it names cost of living as the most commonly cited reason for leaving (UHERO). Their analysis points to high prices and modest incomes together.

What kind of person thrives living on the Big Island?

The kind of person who thrives living on the Big Island is comfortable with fewer choices, self-reliant, respectful of the place, at ease with distance and has room in the budget. Here’s what each looks like:

Comfort with fewer choices
Fewer stores and longer waits for repairs don’t wear you down.
Self-reliance
You plan ahead for what you can’t get quickly, and you can handle small problems yourself.
Respect for the place
You want to learn about Hawaiian culture, and to learn the place names and say them right.
Ease with distance
You’re at peace with seeing mainland family less often, or you’ve planned how you’ll get to them.
Room in the budget
You can absorb higher everyday costs without the move depending on everything going right.

You’ll also want a plan for making friends as a newcomer, because a new place takes effort.

How can I tell if I’d end up moving back to the mainland from the Big Island?

You can tell if you’d end up moving back to the mainland from the Big Island by testing your plan against the money, the distance and the pace of life here, before you buy. Answer these honestly:

  1. Would my budget still work if everyday costs ran higher than I expect?
  2. Will my income hold up here, or does it depend on finding work locally?
  3. How often do I need to see family on the mainland, and can I afford those trips?
  4. Can I live with waiting longer for repairs and appointments?
  5. Have I lived an ordinary month here, outside a resort?
  6. Does everyone moving with me want this as much as I do?

Every no is a part of the plan to fix before you buy. If several answers are unsure, wait to buy until you can answer them.

Sources

  1. U.S. Census Bureau, State-to-State Migration Flows, 2024 American Community Survey 1-Year Estimates (Table 1 and supplemental tables)
  2. UHERO (University of Hawaiʻi Economic Research Organization), Are People Leaving Hawaiʻi Because of High Prices, or Low Incomes? (Bond-Smith and Schwartz, March 19, 2026)

Frequently asked questions

Do more people leave Hawaiʻi than move there?

In 2024, about as many people moved to Hawaiʻi from other states as left for them, by the Census Bureau's estimates, which carry wide margins of error. Over a longer stretch, UHERO found that more residents left Hawaiʻi for the continent than arrived in 23 of the past 25 years.

Where do people go when they leave Hawaiʻi?

California was the most common destination for people leaving Hawaiʻi in 2024, at about 9,900 movers, give or take about 2,600, by the Census Bureau's estimate. Texas, Florida and Virginia came next in the estimates, at around 4,000 each, with wide margins of error.

Is the cost of living the main reason people leave Hawaiʻi?

Cost of living is the reason people cite most often for leaving Hawaiʻi, according to UHERO. Its March 2026 research adds that Hawaiʻi combines high prices with modest incomes, and that it's hard to separate the two. If you're buying here, the price side is the one to plan for.

Should my spouse or partner spend time on the Big Island before we decide to move?

Your spouse or partner should spend real time on the Big Island before you decide to move, because the move goes better when everyone in the house wants it. Visit together. Afterward, talk honestly about what each of you would miss.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields