Should I sell my Big Island home as-is, or invest in improvements first?

The right move for most Big Island homes sits between selling as-is and investing in big improvements first. Fix what a buyer would notice before you stage and deep clean. A full remodel is hard to justify before a sale here, because skilled labor is short and the work costs far more than it would on the mainland.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • Fix and refresh first: small repairs and fresh paint change what buyers feel when they walk in.
  • Skip the big remodel: skilled labor is short here, which makes a remodel cost more and take longer than on the mainland.
  • As-is still means disclosing: Hawaiʻi's seller disclosure law covers most home sales, including as-is sales.
  • Buyers get time to review: they have 15 calendar days after receiving your disclosure to decide whether to cancel.
  • Get it ready before photos: staging and cleaning should be done before the photographer arrives.

“When people walk into our listings, they go, wow, I get all of this for X, and that's because we've taken the time to prepare the property.”

Dan Polimino

When should a Big Island home be sold as-is?

A Big Island home should be sold as-is when the work it needs is more than you can take on, in money or in time. That’s often the case when:

  • The home needs a major remodel, and you’d rather price it as a project
  • You live off-island and can’t oversee contractors
  • You need to sell on a tight timeline
  • An estate or trust is selling, and nobody wants to manage a project

Even then, a little effort helps. Clearing out the clutter and fixing small things will make the photos better. If the home needs real work, price it for that work. Getting the price right for a luxury home matters even more when the buyer is taking on a project.

Why do big remodels before a sale cost so much on the Big Island?

Big remodels before a sale cost so much on the Big Island because skilled labor is short. Good contractors are often booked far ahead and juggling too many projects. That raises the price and stretches the timeline.

Fix and refresh Full remodel
Who does it Painters and handymen Licensed contractors
Timing Shorter, and easier to schedule Longer, and hard to schedule here
Risk before a sale Low Delays and cost overruns
What buyers see A home that’s been cared for Your choices, which they may not share

A buyer who wants to remodel will usually do it their own way. Your job is to show them a clean, working home at a fair price for what it is.

What should I fix before listing my Big Island home?

Before listing your Big Island home, fix what a buyer would notice in a showing or an inspection, then refresh how it looks. Work through it in this order:

  1. Walk through the home and yard the way a buyer would
  2. Fix anything that’s broken or leaking
  3. Touch up or repaint scuffed and dated walls
  4. Stage the main rooms so buyers can picture living there
  5. Deep clean, windows included, before the photos

How the home shows is one of the things that decides how fast a luxury home sells, along with the price and the marketing.

What does Hawaiʻi law require a seller to disclose when selling as-is?

Hawaiʻi law requires a seller to disclose material facts even when selling as-is. That’s because the state’s seller disclosure law covers home sales except for a short list of exemptions, such as sales to a co-owner or close family and foreclosures (HRS §508D-3). Selling as-is isn’t on that list, so it doesn’t get you out of disclosing.

What counts
Any fact, defect or condition, past or present, that would be expected to measurably affect the home’s value to a reasonable person (HRS §508D-1).
When it’s due
No later than 10 calendar days after the purchase contract is accepted (HRS §508D-5).
The buyer’s window
15 calendar days to review it and decide whether to cancel, with their deposits returned if they do (HRS §508D-5).

The two sides can agree in writing to shorten or extend those periods. This isn’t legal advice, so ask a Hawaiʻi real estate attorney how it applies to your sale.

Sources

  1. Hawaii Revised Statutes §508D-1, Definitions (Hawaii State Legislature)
  2. Hawaii Revised Statutes §508D-3, Exemptions (Hawaii State Legislature)
  3. Hawaii Revised Statutes §508D-5, Delivery of disclosure statement to buyer; procedures (Hawaii State Legislature)

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to fix problems an inspector finds when selling a Big Island home?

You don't automatically have to fix problems an inspector finds when selling a Big Island home. The buyer may ask for repairs or a credit, and you'll get to decide how to answer. Whatever you know about the home's condition still belongs in your disclosure statement.

Is staging worth the cost for a vacant Big Island home?

Staging is often worth the cost for a vacant Big Island home, because furniture helps buyers see the size of each room and how the spaces connect. Empty rooms can feel smaller in photos. If you can't stage the whole home, start with the living room and the main bedroom.

Can I sell my Big Island home as-is and still get a good price?

You can sell your Big Island home as-is and still get a good price if it's priced for its condition. Buyers subtract what they think the work will cost, and they often assume the worst. Clean it up and fix the small things. Then disclose what you know, so buyers don't have as many unknowns to price in.

Does a pre-listing inspection help when selling a Big Island home?

A pre-listing inspection can help when selling a Big Island home, because you find problems before a buyer does. You can fix them, price for them or disclose them up front. Keep in mind that what the report tells you becomes something you know, and Hawaiʻi's disclosure law covers facts within your knowledge or control, plus what can be observed from visible, accessible areas.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields