What’s the difference between asking price and what Big Island luxury homes actually sell for?
The difference between asking price and what Big Island homes actually sell for was about 3% for single-family homes in September 2026, when sellers received 96.98% of list price. Luxury homes aren't tracked on their own, so the gap on any one home depends on its price, its community and how it was priced to begin with.
Key takeaways
- The gap is a few percent: Big Island single-family sellers received 96.98% of list price in September 2026.
- Condos were close too: condo sellers received 96.18% of list price that month.
- It moves month to month: single-family sellers received 93.66% of list price in August 2026.
- The biggest sales count the most: the 96.98% matches an average sale of $777,500 against an average list price of $801,700.
- Luxury needs its own read: the island numbers mix every price range, so ask for sales at your level.
How close to asking price do Big Island homes actually sell?
Big Island single-family homes sold for about 97% of asking price in September 2026, and condos for about 96%. Single-family sellers received 96.98% of their list price that month, and condo sellers received 96.18% (Title Guaranty’s Hawaiʻi Island report).
| Month | Single-family homes | Condos |
|---|---|---|
| September 2025 | 96.22% | 97.30% |
| August 2026 | 93.66% | 95.74% |
| September 2026 | 96.98% | 96.18% |
The September 2025 and August 2026 figures come from Title Guaranty’s reports for those months. On a $3 million asking price, 97% of list is about $2.91 million. Ask for the same figure for recent sales in the community you’re watching. For an earlier month, see how far apart asking and sale prices were in March 2026.
What does the Big Island’s percentage of list price actually measure?
The Big Island’s percentage of list price measures how much of the asking price sellers received, across every home of one type that sold that month. Title Guaranty reports one figure for single-family homes and one for condos.
Why the biggest sales count the most
In September 2026, the average single-family home that sold had listed at $801,700 and sold for $777,500 (Title Guaranty). The 96.98% matches the average sale price divided by the average list price, so the biggest sales weigh the most.
A price cut before the sale can also hide in the figure, depending on which list price is used. Ask for a home’s original list price as well as its last one. If your own home is the one sitting, read what happens when a home lists too high.
Do Big Island luxury homes sell further below asking than other homes?
No public number shows whether Big Island luxury homes sell further below asking than other homes, because the island’s figures aren’t split by price. Luxury sales are a small slice of each month. In September 2026, the most expensive single-family home that sold went for $5.4 million (Title Guaranty).
Where to find a luxury figure
Your agent can pull recent sales from the MLS for one community and one price range, with each home’s list price and sale price. That’s the number to use for a luxury home. A handful of sales won’t make a steady average, so look at each sale on its own too.
How should I use asking and sale prices when I buy or sell a Big Island luxury home?
When you buy or sell a Big Island luxury home, use recent sale prices to judge value, and use the gap from asking to see how much negotiating went on. Take these steps:
- Get the recent sales of homes most like this one, in the same community
- For each one, note the original list price, the last list price and the sale price
- Note how long each one took to sell
- If you’re buying, weigh the asking price against those sales before you offer, and read whether tight inventory means you’ll overpay
- If you’re selling, start from those sales when you set your price
Sources
Frequently asked questions
Is it reasonable to offer below asking on a Big Island luxury home?
Offering below asking on a Big Island luxury home is reasonable, since homes here have recently sold for about 94% to 97% of list price. How far below depends on the home. One priced in line with recent sales may not leave much room. Look at how close similar homes sold to their list price before you decide.
Does a high percentage of list price mean a Big Island home was a good deal?
A high percentage of list price shows how close a Big Island sale came to asking, and that alone can't tell you whether the home was a good deal. A home listed too low can sell at full price and still sell for less than it's worth. Judge the deal against what similar homes nearby sold for.
Should a Big Island seller accept an offer below asking price?
Whether a Big Island seller should accept an offer below asking price depends on what similar homes sold for, how long the home has been listed and the terms of the offer. If recent sales support a number close to the offer, it may be a fair price. Weigh what you'd net after costs before you answer.
Can a Big Island home sell for more than its asking price?
A Big Island home can sell for more than its asking price when buyers compete for it, though the island's recent figures have stayed below 100%. Ask for the list and sale prices of recent sales in the community you're watching to see whether any sold above asking.