Long read

The Big Island luxury real estate market: what the numbers show and what the listings won’t tell you

The island-wide numbers mostly describe homes far from the resorts, so a luxury buyer or seller who reads them by community, by closed sale and by what each listing leaves out gets the price right.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Last reviewed November 16, 2026 · 13 minute read

The short version

The Big Island's market numbers are public and current, but most of them describe homes that aren't anywhere near the resorts. As of October 2026, the island's median single-family sale was $514,500, and only seven sales of homes, condos and land reached $3 million or more, all on the west side. Prices are roughly flat and more homes are for sale. A luxury buyer or seller gets the price right by reading closed sales in one community and adding what the listing leaves out.

Key takeaways

  • The island median isn't a luxury number: 79 of the island's 170 single-family sales in October 2026 were in Puna, where the month's median was $342,000.
  • The luxury market is thin and on the west side: in October 2026, seven sales of homes, condos and land reached $3 million or more, all on the west side.
  • Prices are roughly flat: the year-to-date median single-family sale through October 2026 was $550,000, down 1.6% from a year earlier.
  • Buyers have more choice: Hawaiʻi County had 1,359 active listings and 356 with a price cut in October 2026, both up from a year earlier.
  • Homes that sell still sell near asking: single-family homes that sold in October 2026 got 97.81% of list price on average.
  • County comparisons are loose: the Big Island has the lowest median listing price per square foot of Hawaiʻi's four main counties, partly because of its east side.
  • The listing leaves out the big swings: the shoreline alone can put two similar Kohala Coast homes millions apart, and land tenure, rental eligibility and holding costs matter too.
In this guide
  1. Why does the Big Island’s headline home price say so little about luxury homes?
  2. Where on the Big Island does the luxury market actually trade?
  3. Are Big Island home prices rising or falling as of late 2026?
  4. How close to asking price are Big Island homes selling, and how many are sitting?
  5. What does a Big Island listing leave out that changes a home’s value?
  6. How does the Big Island market compare with Maui, Oʻahu, Kauaʻi and the mainland?
  7. How should a Big Island buyer or seller read market numbers before making a move?

Why does the Big Island’s headline home price say so little about luxury homes?

The Big Island’s headline home price says little about luxury because most of the sales behind it are a long way from the resorts. In October 2026, the island’s median single-family sale was $514,500, up 3.5% from a year earlier, in Title Guaranty’s monthly report (Title Guaranty, October 2026). That number describes a different market from the one a Kohala Coast buyer is shopping.

$514,500 median single-family sale, October 2026
79 of 170 single-family sales that month were in Puna
7 of 294 sales of homes, condos and land were $3 million or more

Of the 170 single-family homes that sold on the island in October 2026, 79 were in Puna, where the median that month was $342,000. North Kona had 32 sales, at a median of $1.0 million, and South Kohala had 11, at $913,800. When nearly half the sales come from one lower-priced district, the island median is pulled toward that district’s prices. Counting condos too, Puna held 38% of the month’s 208 home and condo sales.

At the top, the market is thin. Title Guaranty counted 294 sales of homes, condos and land on the island that month. Seven of them were $3 million or more, and all seven were on the west side: five in North Kona, one in South Kohala and one in North Kohala.

Why the average and the median tell two stories

Asking prices show the same split. Realtor.com’s data on FRED put Hawaiʻi County’s median listing price at $599,000 in October 2026, and its average listing price at $1,101,472 (FRED, October 2026). A median is the middle listing. An average gets pulled up by a few very expensive ones, and on this island the most expensive sales are on the Kona and Kohala side.

That’s mostly down to the island’s two sides. The sunny west side holds the resorts and most of the second homes, and the rainier east side is where homes cost far less. Knowing what each side of the Big Island offers tells you which numbers apply to you.

So here’s the first rule for reading this market. Before you trust a number, ask what it’s measuring: which part of the island, which kind of property and which months.

Where on the Big Island does the luxury market actually trade?

The Big Island’s luxury market trades almost entirely on the west side, in North Kona, South Kohala and North Kohala, where the district medians run two to four times Puna’s. Title Guaranty’s year-to-date figures through October 2026 show the spread district by district (Title Guaranty, October 2026).

District Median single-family sale, Jan. to Oct. 2026
North Kohala $1.6 million
North Kona $1.2 million
South Kohala $1.0 million
North Hilo $855,000
South Kona $788,000
Hāmākua $700,000
South Hilo $594,500
Puna $396,500
Kaʻū $324,000

The luxury line is higher still. The island’s median over the same months was $550,000, and even the top district medians sit below the luxury line.

On the Kona side, I put an average home, three bedrooms and two baths on about 1,800 square feet, at about $1.3 million to $1.4 million. Luxury starts at about $2 million to $2.5 million. Oceanfront homes on the Kona side generally start around $5 million, and ultra luxury begins around $15 million to $18 million. The full map of what luxury costs on the Big Island, tier by tier, sets out what each price buys.

Why a district median can mislead you

A district median mixes everything that sold there: a small house mauka of the highway and an oceanfront estate count the same. North Kohala’s $1.6 million comes from a small number of sales, so one or two big ones can move it a long way. And every west-side district blends resort communities with ordinary neighborhoods, so its median sits between the two.

That’s why the luxury market here is really a set of small markets. Each resort community, and often each section inside one, has its own buyers and its own price per square foot. Two homes a mile apart can share a district and have almost nothing else in common.

For a buyer or seller, the useful number is narrower than anything you’ll see in a table. It’s the closed sales of homes like yours, in the same community, over the last six to twelve months.

“So it varies widely here on the big island, and it varies depending on where you are, north, south, east, or west.”

Dan Polimino

Are Big Island home prices rising or falling as of late 2026?

Big Island home prices are roughly flat as of late 2026: the year-to-date median is slightly down, while October’s was slightly up. Through October, the island’s median single-family sale was $550,000, down 1.6% from the same months of 2025, on 1,639 sales, down 3.7% (Title Guaranty, October 2026). The total dollars spent on single-family homes rose 6.9%, so the average sale was larger than a year before.

  • Asking prices are softer: Hawaiʻi County’s median listing price was $599,000 in October 2026, against $618,000 in October 2025 (FRED).
  • October’s top end was thinner: single-family sales fell 9.6% from October 2025, while total dollars fell 37.7%, so the average October sale was far smaller than a year earlier.
  • Borrowing costs more: Freddie Mac’s 30-year fixed rate averaged 7.11% as of November 12, 2026, against 6.24% a year earlier (Freddie Mac).
  • Condos are softer too: the year-to-date condo median was $616,500, down 2.5%, on 416 sales, down 5.9%.

One month is a small sample at the top. A single large sale can move a month’s dollar total on its own. The 37.7% drop tells you October’s mix of sales ran cheaper that month.

What history and forecasts add

Over a longer stretch, the picture’s stronger. From 2019 to 2025, the island’s median single-family sale rose about 45%, with the biggest jump in 2021 and almost no gain in 2025. No public index tracks luxury homes alone, so be careful when someone quotes you one. That’s the record behind how much Big Island homes have appreciated, year by year.

Looking ahead, UHERO, the University of Hawaiʻi’s economic research group, expects Hawaiʻi home price gains to run below inflation, with mortgage rates staying above 6.5%. It doesn’t publish a price forecast for Hawaiʻi County itself. That forecast is the best public guide to whether Big Island prices will keep climbing, and it isn’t a promise either way.

Put together, the numbers say it’s a slow, flat market. That’s useful to a buyer who has time to compare. It’s also useful to a seller, because in a flat market the homes that sell are the ones priced to the recent sales.

How close to asking price are Big Island homes selling, and how many are sitting?

Big Island homes that sold in October 2026 went for close to asking: single-family homes got 97.81% of list price on average, and condos 96.48% (Title Guaranty, October 2026). The average single-family home listed at $721,500 and sold for $705,700. On those averages, buyers paid about 2% under asking.

Read the percentage carefully. It counts only homes that sold. A home that sat, was cut twice and then sold may show up as close to its final list price. Homes priced too high and never sold aren’t in the number at all.

The listings that haven’t sold tell the other half. Realtor.com’s figures for Hawaiʻi County in October 2026, on FRED, show a market with more choice than a year before (FRED, October 2026).

Hawaiʻi County Oct. 2025 Oct. 2026
Active listings 1,088 1,359
Listings with a price cut 278 356
Listings under contract 305 244
Median days on market 88 95

The data fits a market holding two groups of homes at once. New listings kept coming, too: 328 in October 2026, against 312 a year earlier. One group is priced near what buyers will pay, and it sells close to asking. The other is priced above that, and it sits, collects price cuts and shows up in the days-on-market count.

What that means for luxury homes

Title Guaranty doesn’t report sale-to-list for luxury homes on their own, and a few percent means more as the price rises. On a $3 million home, every 1% is $30,000. The figure is also a ratio of two averages, so the gap between asking and sale price on any single home can run well above or below it.

For a buyer, the listing history is part of the price. A home that’s sat for months with cuts is a different negotiation from one that just came on. For a seller, the table above is the warning: the homes priced past the recent sales are the ones that haven’t sold.

What does a Big Island listing leave out that changes a home’s value?

A Big Island listing usually leaves out what moves a home’s value most: the real shoreline, whether you’ll own the land, whether rentals are allowed, and the cost to hold it. Two homes with the same bedrooms and the same view can be millions apart once you’ve looked at these.

Ocean front or beach front

Much of the Kona coast is rocky lava. A home can be on the ocean and still sit on a cliff above it. Very few homes let you walk from the lawn onto sand, which is one reason similar Kohala Coast homes can be priced millions apart.

Fee simple or leasehold

With a leasehold, you’re buying the right to use the property for the term of a lease, and the landowner keeps the land. Hawaiʻi’s real estate rules require a leasehold property’s advertising to say so, so look for the word in the listing.

Rental eligibility

Whether you can rent a home short term depends on its zoning, any nonconforming use certificate and its association’s rules. The listing might suggest it can. Don’t take that on trust: confirm it, then decide what rental eligibility should add to your price.

The cost to hold it

A second home pays the county’s residential rate. For July 2026 to June 2027, that’s $11.10 per $1,000 of value on the first $2 million, $14.50 on the next $2 million and $17.00 above that. The homeowner exemption and lower rate apply only to a principal residence, so an out-of-state owner’s property taxes run higher. Add the association dues on top.

The county’s rental rules belong in the same check. Bill 147 is a separate county bill on where vacation rentals are allowed. As of November 13, 2026, it had passed first reading and was still before the County Council, which amended it on November 6 and set its final vote for November 18, 2026. What both county bills mean for Big Island property values is a story of its own.

The checks no photo shows

  • The home’s listing and price history, including how long it has been for sale.
  • Its lava hazard zone on the US Geological Survey map, and what that means for insurance.
  • Its water source: county service, a well or a catchment tank.
  • The association’s budget, reserves and any planned special assessments.
  • Club membership, if the community has one: whether it comes with the home and what it costs to join.

A listing is written to sell the home, and these are the details that slow a sale down. They’re also the details that decide whether a price is fair.

How does the Big Island market compare with Maui, Oʻahu, Kauaʻi and the mainland?

Compared with Maui, Oʻahu, Kauaʻi and the mainland, the Big Island market is the least expensive of Hawaiʻi’s four main counties on asking price, per home and per square foot. Its listings also spend less time on the market than Maui’s or Kauaʻi’s. Realtor.com’s October 2026 county figures on FRED show the gap (FRED, October 2026).

County Median asking price Per sq. ft. Days listed (median)
Hawaiʻi (Big Island) $599,000 $488 95
Honolulu (Oʻahu) $670,150 $704 78
Maui $975,000 $885 121
Kauaʻi $1,475,000 $955 122

These are county-wide numbers, and that’s important. They also move at different speeds. From October 2025 to October 2026, Maui County’s median asking price fell from $1,105,000 to $975,000, the Big Island’s from $618,000 to $599,000, while Kauaʻi’s rose from $1,398,250 to $1,475,000.

Listings differ in size, too: Honolulu’s median listing in October 2026 was 912 square feet, against 1,344 on the Big Island. A county median won’t tell you anything about a Wailea home against a Mauna Lani home.

Why the Big Island’s lower numbers don’t make it cheap

Some of that gap comes from the east side. Puna and the Hilo side pull the Big Island’s medians down, and they hold a large share of its sales. On the Kona and Kohala side, you’re paying resort prices. A fair comparison sets one resort community against another, home for home. It’s slower, and it’s the comparison that holds up.

Maui also differs on rules. Its county has voted to end vacation rentals in apartment districts after 2028 in West Maui and after 2030 elsewhere, which changes how its condos are valued. It also raises the question of whether the Big Island could phase out vacation rentals too, and what that would do to values here.

The mainland comparison is looser still. The public figures for Aspen, Scottsdale and Montecito are medians for whole counties or ZIP codes, and a county median isn’t a luxury price. Keep that in mind when you weigh the Big Island against mainland luxury markets.

What the comparison does show is useful: on the Big Island, the same money buys more square feet than on the other islands, county-wide and at asking prices. Whether it buys the setting you want depends on the community, and that’s where your own comparison has to end up.

How should a Big Island buyer or seller read market numbers before making a move?

A Big Island buyer or seller should read market numbers from the narrowest set of sales that matches the home: the same community, the same kind of property, closed recently. Every number above is a frame for that comparison.

  1. Name the market you’re in

    Write down the community, the property type and the price range you’re after. A Mauna Lani condo and a Hualālai home aren’t the same market, even in the same month.

  2. Use closed sales, not listings

    Asking prices show what sellers want. Recorded sales show what buyers actually paid, and that’s the number you need. Start with the closed sales of similar homes over the last six to twelve months, and don’t stop at one.

  3. Count the sales behind each number

    A median from five sales can swing a long way in a month, and it won’t tell you much on its own. If a figure rests on a handful of sales, treat it as a range.

  4. Check the dates and the window

    A year-to-date figure, a single month and a five-year change can all be true and still point different ways. Ask which months a number covers before you compare two of them.

  5. Price in what the listing leaves out

    Adjust for shoreline, land tenure, rental eligibility, club membership and the yearly cost to hold the home, since the listing won’t.

  6. Recheck every month or two

    Title Guaranty publishes a new island report each month, and the county figures on FRED update monthly too.

Sellers face the same test from the other side. An online estimate can’t see an ocean frontage, a leasehold or a remodel, and the buyers who matter will compare your home with the last few that closed nearby. That comparison, built from closed sales, is what sets a realistic list price.

If you ask an agent for numbers, ask for the list, not a summary. You’ll want each closed sale’s address or community, its size, its sale price, its list price and how long it was for sale. With that list in hand, you can see for yourself which homes are like the one you’re weighing, and which ones only share a ZIP code.

When the numbers disagree

They’ll often disagree. In October 2026 the island’s median rose while its total sales dollars fell. Both were right. They measure different things. When two figures point different ways, go back to step one and ask which of them covers the homes you actually care about.

The Bottom Line

The Big Island luxury market is a set of small markets, and the closest closed sales set the price

The Big Island's luxury market is a handful of small markets, mostly on the west side, sitting inside an island-wide market of mid-priced homes. The public numbers are good and they're current: Title Guaranty's monthly reports, the county listing data on FRED and Freddie Mac's rate survey all tell you something true about the island. The price of a particular home comes from the closed sales in its own community.

As of late 2026, the frame is a flat market with more homes for sale, more price cuts and higher borrowing costs than a year ago. The data fits a market where homes priced near recent sales still sell close to asking, and homes priced above them sit. That's a market where a careful buyer has room to compare, and a seller who prices to the recent sales still does well.

Use the island numbers to understand the season you're in. Then narrow down to the closed sales in your community, and add what the listing left out before you decide what a home is worth.

Before you price a Big Island luxury home, find the closed sales of homes like it in the same community.

Sources

  1. Title Guaranty Hawaii, Hawaii Residential Sales Report, October 2026 (information effective November 2, 2026)
  2. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (FRED), Inventory Metrics by Geography: Hawaii, Realtor.com Housing Inventory data, October 2026
  3. Freddie Mac, Primary Mortgage Market Survey, rates as of November 12, 2026

Regulatory information changes. Hawaiʻi County rules, state tax law, and federal withholding requirements described here reflect the last-reviewed date above; confirm current requirements with the relevant agency or your advisor before acting.

This guide is general information, not legal, tax, or investment advice. Talk to your attorney, CPA, or advisor about your specific situation.

More questions about this

What is the median home price on the Big Island in late 2026?

The Big Island's median single-family sale was $514,500 in October 2026, and $550,000 for January through October 2026, per Title Guaranty's island report. The median asking price in Hawaiʻi County was $599,000 in October 2026, per Realtor.com data on FRED. Those are island-wide figures. Resort-area homes on the Kona and Kohala side sell for far more.

How many Big Island homes sell for $3 million or more?

Very few. In October 2026, Title Guaranty counted seven sales of $3 million or more among 294 sales of homes, condos and land on the island. At least one was vacant land, and all seven were on the west side. Its report doesn't break out homes alone at that price.

Is the Big Island a buyer's market or a seller's market right now?

The Big Island's market leans toward buyers as of late 2026. In October 2026, Hawaiʻi County had 1,359 active listings against 1,088 a year earlier, more listings with price cuts, fewer under contract and a longer median time on the market. Homes priced near recent sales still sold close to asking, so buyers gain room mainly on homes priced too high.

Which Big Island district has the highest median home price?

The Big Island district with the highest median home price is North Kohala, at $1.6 million for single-family sales through October 2026, per Title Guaranty, but from a small number of sales. North Kona followed at $1.2 million and South Kohala at $1.0 million. The island's median over the same months was $550,000.

Where can I find current Big Island home sales data?

You'll find current Big Island home sales data in Title Guaranty's monthly residential sales report for Hawaiʻi Island, on its market page, with sales counts and medians by district, and island-wide sale-to-list figures. The Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis's FRED site carries Realtor.com's monthly county listing data for Hawaiʻi County, including listings, price cuts and days on market.

Why do Big Island average prices run so much higher than the median?

Big Island average prices run much higher than the median because a few very expensive homes pull the average up, while the median stays at the middle sale or listing. In October 2026, Hawaiʻi County's average listing price was $1,101,472 against a median of $599,000, per Realtor.com data on FRED. Most expensive listings are on the Kona and Kohala side.

Do higher mortgage rates affect Big Island luxury home prices?

Yes, higher mortgage rates affect Big Island luxury home prices, mostly by slowing the market. UHERO expects rates above 6.5% to keep holding back Hawaiʻi's housing market, with home price gains below inflation. Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed rate averaged 7.11% as of November 12, 2026, against 6.24% a year earlier. Buyers who pay cash feel rates less than buyers who borrow.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields