If I sell my Big Island home, what will I actually net after commissions, taxes, and fees?
When you sell a Big Island home, what you actually net is the sale price minus your mortgage payoff, the commission, taxes and fees. The state's conveyance tax and your share of the year's property tax come out at closing. If you're not a Hawaiʻi resident, the state holds back 7.25% of the price and credits it when you file.
Key takeaways
- Start with the sale price: your payoff, costs and any withholding are all subtracted from it.
- The conveyance tax rises with the price: on a $3 million home it's $15,000 or $18,000, depending on the buyer.
- Property tax gets split: you pay your share of the year's bill up to the day you close.
- Nonresidents see a 7.25% holdback: it's an advance on your Hawaiʻi income tax, credited when you file.
- Capital gains tax comes later: you report the gain on your tax return, so have your CPA estimate it before you list.
What comes out of the sale price when I sell a Big Island home?
When you sell a Big Island home, your mortgage payoff, the commission, the conveyance tax, your share of the property tax and the title fees come out of the sale price. Your closing statement lists each one, along with any withholding:
- Your mortgage payoff, if you have a loan
- The real estate commission, from your listing agreement
- The state conveyance tax, which the seller generally pays (Hawaiʻi Department of Taxation)
- Your share of this year’s property tax
- Title and escrow fees
- Hawaiʻi’s 7.25% withholding, if you’re not a Hawaiʻi resident
- Federal FIRPTA withholding, if you’re a foreign owner
The two withholdings work differently from the other lines. They’re advance payments toward income tax, so you get credit for them when you file. Your capital gains tax comes later, on your tax return. Some of these are costs mainland sellers often don’t expect.
What does a net estimate look like on a $3 million Big Island sale?
A net estimate on a $3 million Big Island sale shows $15,000 or $18,000 in conveyance tax and, for a seller who doesn’t live in Hawaiʻi, $217,500 held back at closing. The other lines come from your own papers:
| Line | Example: $3,000,000 sale | Where the number comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Sale price | $3,000,000 | Your purchase contract |
| Mortgage payoff | Your balance | Your lender’s payoff letter |
| Commission | Your agreed amount | Your listing agreement |
| Conveyance tax | $15,000 or $18,000 | 50 or 60 cents per $100 |
| Property tax share | Your share of the year | Your county tax bill |
| Title and escrow fees | Their estimate | Your escrow company |
| Hawaiʻi withholding, nonresidents only | $217,500 held back | 7.25% of the price |
On a single-family home or condo, the conveyance tax uses the higher rate when the buyer won’t qualify for the county’s homeowner exemption on property tax (Form P-64A instructions). The $217,500 is an estimated tax payment in your name, applied to what you owe when you file your Hawaiʻi return (Tax Facts 2010-1).
How is the net different for a seller who doesn’t live in Hawaiʻi?
The net is different for a seller who doesn’t live in Hawaiʻi because part of the price is held back at closing. The buyer withholds 7.25% of the amount realized and sends it to the state (Hawaiʻi Department of Taxation).
Two kinds of withholding
- Hawaiʻi withholding: 7.25% for sellers who aren’t Hawaiʻi residents
- Federal FIRPTA withholding: generally 15% for foreign owners (IRS)
A foreign owner who isn’t a Hawaiʻi resident can have both taken from one sale. On $3 million, that’s $667,500 held at closing. You get credit for both when you file, and anything over your actual tax is refunded. A foreign seller can sometimes get less withheld before closing.
How do I get an accurate net estimate before listing my Big Island home?
To get an accurate net estimate before listing your Big Island home, gather your own numbers first. Then work through them in this order:
- Request a payoff figure from your lender
- Ask the agents you’re interviewing to show their fee in dollars
- Ask an escrow or title company for an estimate of its fees
- Check your county tax bill for this year’s amount
- If you’re not a Hawaiʻi resident, plan for the 7.25% held back at closing
- Have your CPA estimate the capital gains tax on your sale
Put all of it next to a realistic price, based on what your home is actually worth today.
Sources
Frequently asked questions
Does my buyer's plan for the home change what I net on a Big Island sale?
Your buyer's plan for the home can change what you net on a Big Island sale, through the conveyance tax. On a single-family home or condo, the rate is higher when the buyer won't qualify for the county's homeowner exemption on property tax. On a $3 million sale, that's 60 cents per $100 instead of 50, or $18,000 instead of $15,000.
Do selling costs lower the taxable gain on a Big Island home sale?
Selling costs do lower the taxable gain on a Big Island home sale. The IRS lets you subtract selling expenses, such as the commission and legal fees, when you figure your gain. Keep your final closing statement for your CPA. Hawaiʻi's 7.25% withholding doesn't count as a selling expense, because it's a tax payment in your name.
Does paying off a mortgage at closing change the tax on a Big Island sale?
Paying off a mortgage at closing doesn't change the tax on a Big Island sale. Tax is figured on your gain, which is the sale price less selling costs and your adjusted basis. Equity is what's left after the loans are paid. Hawaiʻi's Department of Taxation notes that you can owe tax on a gain even with no equity left.
What's the difference between my home equity and what I'll net from a Big Island sale?
The difference between your home equity and what you'll net from a Big Island sale is the selling costs, taxes and any withholding. Equity is the home's value minus what you owe on it. What you net is your equity minus the commission, the conveyance tax, your property tax share, title fees and any amount held back for income tax.