What will I owe in capital gains tax when I sell my Big Island property, and can I reduce it?
What you'll owe in capital gains tax when you sell a Big Island property depends on your gain, how long you owned it and your income, and there are legal ways to reduce it. Federal long-term rates are 0%, 15% or 20%. Hawaiʻi taxes long-term gains at up to 7.25%.
Key takeaways
- The tax is on your gain: that's the sale price less selling costs and your adjusted basis, which is what you paid plus improvements, minus any depreciation.
- Holding time matters: owning the property more than one year usually means lower long-term rates.
- Hawaiʻi taxes the gain too: owners who live elsewhere still owe Hawaiʻi tax on a gain from a sale here.
- Your main home may be excluded: up to $250,000 of gain, or $500,000 for a married couple filing jointly.
- Rentals add a layer: the part of your gain from depreciation is taxed at up to 25% federally.
How is the gain figured when I sell a Big Island property?
The gain when you sell a Big Island property is figured by subtracting your adjusted basis from your net sale price (IRS Publication 523). Three terms matter:
- Net sale price
- The price, less selling costs such as the commission and the state’s transfer tax
- Adjusted basis
- What you paid, plus capital improvements, minus any depreciation you took or could have taken
- Gain
- The net sale price minus the adjusted basis
Capital improvements add value or extend the home’s life, like a new bathroom, a deck or a water heater. Repairs don’t count, and an improvement has to still be in place when you sell. Selling costs include Hawaiʻi’s conveyance tax, one of the Big Island costs that surprise mainland sellers. Keep the receipts for all of it.
What capital gains rates apply to a Big Island sale?
The capital gains rates that apply to a Big Island sale are 0%, 15% or 20% federally on property owned more than a year (IRS Topic 409). Hawaiʻi’s long-term rate goes up to 7.25% (Form N-15 instructions):
| Tax | Rate | When it applies |
|---|---|---|
| Federal, long-term | 0%, 15% or 20% | Owned more than one year; the rate depends on taxable income |
| Federal, short-term | Ordinary income rates | Owned one year or less |
| Federal, depreciation part | Up to 25% | Gain from depreciation on rental or business property |
| Hawaiʻi, long-term | Up to 7.25% | Hawaiʻi’s capital gains rate on 2025 returns |
| Hawaiʻi, short-term | Ordinary income rates | Owned one year or less |
Higher earners may also owe the federal net investment income tax. Nonresidents report the sale on Hawaiʻi Form N-15, because a gain from selling Hawaiʻi real estate is Hawaiʻi income (Form N-15 instructions).
How can I reduce capital gains tax on a Big Island sale?
You can reduce capital gains tax on a Big Island sale through the home sale exclusion, good records, holding past one year or a 1031 exchange, and each one has rules:
- The home sale exclusion: it covers a main home you owned and lived in for at least two of the last five years. Up to $250,000 of gain is excluded, or $500,000 for a married couple filing jointly who meet the tests (IRS Publication 523)
- Good records: documented improvements and selling costs both shrink the gain
- Holding past one year: long-term rates are lower than short-term rates
- A 1031 exchange: on investment property, it can put the tax off when you buy another property
A second home or rental usually won’t qualify for the exclusion, because only a main home does. Gain from depreciation can’t be excluded either. Which of these fit your sale is a question for your CPA.
How does Hawaiʻi’s withholding at closing relate to the capital gains tax I owe?
Hawaiʻi’s withholding at closing is an advance payment toward the Hawaiʻi income tax you owe, including the tax on your gain. If you’re not a Hawaiʻi resident, the buyer withholds 7.25% of the price. When you file your Hawaiʻi return, that payment is credited against your actual tax (Form N-15 instructions). Any extra comes back as a refund.
The withholding is figured on the price, and the tax is figured on the gain, so the two are rarely the same number. Here’s the order to work in:
- Find your purchase closing statement and improvement records
- Pull any depreciation schedules if the property was ever rented
- Have your CPA estimate the federal and Hawaiʻi tax before you list
- Compare that with what you’ll net at closing
Sources
Frequently asked questions
Does Hawaiʻi tax a mainland resident who sells a Big Island property?
Hawaiʻi does tax a mainland resident who sells a Big Island property. Nonresidents are taxed on income from Hawaiʻi sources, and gains from selling Hawaiʻi real estate count. You report the sale on Form N-15. Ask your CPA how it fits with your home state's return.
Can I exclude the gain on a Big Island second home?
You generally can't exclude the gain on a Big Island second home. The exclusion is only for your main home, and you have one main home at a time. If the Big Island home was your main home for two of the last five years, part of the gain may qualify. Your CPA can check the rules for the years it wasn't.
What happens to the tax if I sell my Big Island property for less than I paid?
If you sell your Big Island property for less than your adjusted basis, there's no gain to tax. On a rental, depreciation lowers that basis, so a sale below what you paid can still show a gain. A loss on a home you used yourself isn't deductible, the IRS says. Hawaiʻi's 7.25% withholding still applies to nonresidents unless you apply for a waiver ahead of time.
Do I have to pay the IRS during the year I sell my Big Island property?
You may have to pay the IRS during the year you sell your Big Island property. The gain is reported on your return for the year of the sale. If you have a taxable gain, you may need to make estimated tax payments during the year, the IRS says. Your CPA can tell you whether that applies to you.