I’m a foreign owner selling a Big Island home. What’s FIRPTA, and how much will be withheld?
If you're a foreign owner selling a Big Island home, FIRPTA has the buyer withhold 15% of the price for the IRS. The rate drops to 10% when the buyer plans to live in a home priced at $1 million or less. If you're not a Hawaiʻi resident, another 7.25% is withheld for the state. Both count toward your tax.
Key takeaways
- The usual FIRPTA rate is 15%: the buyer withholds it from the price and sends it to the IRS.
- Some homes get a lower rate: it's 10% when the buyer plans to live in a home priced at $1 million or less.
- Hawaiʻi adds its own: sellers who aren't Hawaiʻi residents have another 7.25% withheld.
- Withholding counts as a payment: you claim it on your US and Hawaiʻi returns, and any extra is refunded.
- Get your records ready before you list: if you qualify, Hawaiʻi's waiver form has to be filed at least 10 working days before closing.
What is FIRPTA, and how much is withheld from a foreign owner’s sale?
FIRPTA is the federal law under which 15% is usually withheld from a foreign owner’s sale. Its full name is the Foreign Investment in Real Property Tax Act of 1980. The buyer is the withholding agent and can be held liable if it isn’t done. The rate depends on the sale (Form 8288 instructions):
| Your sale | FIRPTA withholding |
|---|---|
| Most sales | 15% of the amount realized |
| Buyer plans to live there, price $1 million or less | 10% |
| Buyer plans to live there, price $300,000 or less | None |
The amount realized is mostly the price, plus any debt the buyer takes over. The buyer sends the money to the IRS by the 20th day after closing. On a $3 million Big Island home, 15% is $450,000.
Does Hawaiʻi also withhold when a foreign owner sells a Big Island home?
Hawaiʻi also withholds when a foreign owner sells a Big Island home, as long as the owner isn’t a Hawaiʻi resident. Under the state’s rule, often called HARPTA, the buyer withholds 7.25% of the amount realized (Tax Facts 2010-1). It’s an estimated payment toward your Hawaiʻi income tax.
What both can add up to
- A $3 million sale: $450,000 federal plus $217,500 state, or $667,500
- A $1.5 million sale: $225,000 federal plus $108,750 state, or $333,750
The state skips its withholding in a few cases. One is when no gain is recognized, as in a qualifying 1031 exchange. Another is a home used as your principal residence for the year before the sale and sold for $300,000 or less. Either way, you give the buyer Form N-289. You’ll also pay Hawaiʻi’s other selling costs, like the conveyance tax.
How can a foreign seller get less withheld at a Big Island closing?
A foreign seller can get less withheld at a Big Island closing by applying ahead of time. The two governments use different forms and rules:
- File IRS Form 8288-B for a withholding certificate if 15% is more than your maximum tax on the gain from the sale. The IRS normally acts within 90 days of a complete application.
- Tell the buyer in writing that you’ve applied, on the day of closing or the day before (IRS).
- Expect the withholding to be held at closing anyway. The buyer doesn’t send it until 20 days after the IRS mails its answer (Form 8288 instructions).
- For Hawaiʻi, file Form N-288B at least 10 working days before closing. It only works if you’ll have no gain, or not enough proceeds to cover the withholding (Tax Facts 2010-1).
How does a foreign seller get withheld money back after a Big Island sale?
A foreign seller gets withheld money back after a Big Island sale by filing tax returns that report the sale. Each withholding is applied to your actual tax, and any extra is refunded.
- Federal
- File a US return, such as Form 1040-NR, with the stamped Copy B of Form 8288-A that the IRS sends you (Form 8288 instructions).
- Hawaiʻi
- File a Hawaiʻi return after the year ends, or apply sooner with Form N-288C if that year’s return isn’t available yet (Tax Facts 2010-1).
- Tax ID
- The IRS won’t send the stamped copy until it has your US taxpayer ID number.
Once there’s a binding sales contract, a foreign seller can apply for an ITIN with Form W-7. Your tax advisor can tell you which returns you’ll file and when. If you’re weighing a 1031 exchange instead of a sale, the withholding steps change too.
Sources
Frequently asked questions
Who counts as a foreign owner under FIRPTA?
A foreign owner under FIRPTA is a foreign person, which the IRS defines as a nonresident alien individual or a foreign corporation, partnership, trust or estate. A resident alien isn't included, so citizenship alone doesn't decide it. Your tax advisor can confirm which you are.
Is the FIRPTA amount withheld the same as the tax I'll owe?
The FIRPTA amount withheld can be more or less than the tax you'll owe, because it's figured on the price and the tax is figured on your gain. When you file, the withholding is applied to your tax. Any extra is refunded, and if it falls short, you pay the rest.
Can I exchange my Big Island home for property in my home country?
You can't exchange a Big Island home for property in your home country under the 1031 rules. The IRS says real property in the United States and real property outside it aren't like-kind. An exchange into other US investment property may work if the Big Island home was held for investment.
Who handles FIRPTA paperwork at a Big Island closing?
The buyer handles FIRPTA paperwork at a Big Island closing, as the withholding agent. The IRS says settlement officers and certain buyer's agents can also be required to withhold. If you live overseas, the IRS suggests putting your escrow company's address on Form 8288-B, so its letters reach the closing in time.