Why are two seemingly similar Kohala Coast homes priced millions apart?

Two seemingly similar Kohala Coast homes can be priced millions apart because of the ocean: whether the home sits on it, and whether that means sand or rock. Shoreline rules, whether you own the land, and the community the home is in can widen the gap.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • Sand is scarce: the Kona side is a very rocky coast with a lot of lava, so few homes sit right on a beach.
  • Shoreline lots carry a setback: on the Big Island, lots that touch the shoreline have a minimum shoreline setback of 40 feet.
  • Coastal building needs a county permit: development in the Special Management Area along the shore needs its own permit.
  • Leasehold means you don't own the land: the state's condominium disclosure says you buy the right to use the property for the lease term, and lease rent can rise.
  • The listing has to say so: state rules require a leasehold property advertised for sale to be labeled leasehold.

“Beach front is rare. Ocean front is not.”

Dan Polimino

What makes two similar Kohala Coast homes sell for millions apart?

Two similar Kohala Coast homes can sell for millions apart when one sits on the ocean and the other doesn’t, or when one has sand at the water and the other has rock. Shoreline rules, land ownership and the community can widen the gap. Line these up first:

What to compare Why it matters
On the ocean or not Oceanfront homes generally start around $5 million (see what each price level buys)
Sand or rock at the water Few homes on this coast sit right on a beach
The shoreline rules They limit how close to the water anything can be built
Fee simple or leasehold It decides whether you own the land under the home
The community Its rules, dues and any club come with the home
The view How much ocean you see from the main rooms is worth checking in person or on video

What’s the difference between beach front and ocean front on the Big Island?

The difference between beach front and ocean front on the Big Island is whether you can walk onto sand. Ocean front only means the lot meets the water, often on rock.

Ocean front
The lot meets the ocean. On the west side that usually means rock or lava, and many homes sit above the water, looking down on it.
Beach front
You can walk from your yard onto sand and into the water. On this coast, that’s very rare.

Don’t rely on a listing’s description alone. Look at the shoreline yourself or on video, since a home described as on the water may sit on a rocky point.

What county rules apply to an oceanfront lot on the Big Island?

County rules for an oceanfront lot on the Big Island include a 40-foot minimum shoreline setback and a permit for development near the shore (County of Hawaiʻi Planning Department). Here’s how the county describes them:

  • The Special Management Area is the land close to the shoreline, and how far inland it reaches varies by place
  • Any development there needs a Special Management Area use permit, minor or major
  • Every lot that abuts the shoreline has a minimum shoreline setback of 40 feet
  • Building closer than that takes a shoreline setback variance, which the county’s planning commissions decide

So two oceanfront homes can differ in what’s already permitted and in what could ever be added. Ask the seller for the permits on file. Don’t count on any changes until you’ve asked the Planning Department.

What’s the difference between fee simple and leasehold on the Big Island?

The difference between fee simple and leasehold on the Big Island is who owns the land. With fee simple, you own it outright. With leasehold, you only have the right to use the property for the time stated in the lease (the state’s leasehold disclosure for condominiums).

Fee simple Leasehold
The land Yours Owned by the landowner, called the lessor
Rent for the land No lease rent Lease rent, fixed for set periods and then renegotiated, sometimes much higher
When the lease ends There’s no lease The property can go back to the landowner without compensation

State rules require a leasehold property advertised for sale to be identified by the word leasehold (Hawaiʻi Administrative Rules §16-99-11). If a home you like is leasehold, read the lease and have a Hawaiʻi real estate attorney review it.

How do I compare two Kohala Coast homes before I make an offer?

To compare two Kohala Coast homes before you make an offer, start with whether each lot meets the ocean and whether there’s sand or rock at the water. Check these five things for each one:

  1. Look at each shoreline yourself or on video
  2. Ask for each home’s permits, and where the shoreline setback falls
  3. Check whether each is fee simple or leasehold, and read any lease
  4. Get each community’s rules and dues, and ask about any club, using the papers a private community’s seller hands over
  5. Compare recent sales of homes most like each one, the way a real valuation gets done

Then put the two prices side by side, with what you’ve found next to each one.

Sources

  1. County of Hawaiʻi Planning Department, Special Management Area (SMA)
  2. Hawaiʻi Real Estate Commission, leasehold exhibit for condominium public reports (Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs, Real Estate Branch)
  3. Hawaiʻi Administrative Rules, Title 16, Chapter 99, Real Estate Brokers and Salespersons (§16-99-11, Advertisement)

Frequently asked questions

How do I find out if a Big Island home is leasehold?

To find out if a Big Island home is leasehold, start with the listing, because state rules require a leasehold property advertised for sale to say so. Then ask for the lease itself. Read when it ends, how the lease rent is set and when it gets renegotiated. Have a Hawaiʻi real estate attorney review it before you make an offer.

Who certifies the shoreline on a Big Island oceanfront lot?

The State of Hawaiʻi certifies the shoreline on a Big Island oceanfront lot, through the Department of Land and Natural Resources' Land Division. The county's Planning Department lists that application among its shoreline resources. Ask the seller whether a certified shoreline is already on file for the lot.

Do Kohala Coast resort homes come with a club membership?

Whether a Kohala Coast resort home comes with a club membership depends on the community. Ask whether membership comes with the home or is bought separately, whether there's a wait, and what the dues are. Get the answer in writing for each home you're comparing, because it changes what the home costs you.

Can I buy the land under a leasehold home on the Big Island later?

You may be able to buy the land under a leasehold home on the Big Island later, but nothing guarantees it. For leasehold condominiums, the state's disclosure says no law requires the landowner to sell, and there's no promise one will pass. Ask whether the landowner will sell, and on what terms, before you buy.

Communities where this comes up

Mauna Lani

An established Kohala Coast resort with two hotels, golf, condos and oceanfront neighborhoods such as Pauoa Beach and 49 Black Sand Beach.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields