Maui phased out short-term rentals. Could the Big Island do the same, and how would that hit my property’s value?

The Big Island could do the same as Maui under state law, and a phase-out could hit your property's value: economists projected Maui's proposal would cut condo prices 20 to 40%. Maui hasn't phased short-term rentals out yet, though. Its 2025 law ends them in apartment districts after 2028 in West Maui and after 2030 elsewhere.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • Maui's phase-out is law, with deadlines ahead: apartment-district rentals end after December 31, 2028 in West Maui and December 31, 2030 elsewhere.
  • Some Maui owners can rezone: two hotel districts created in 2026 give some properties a way to keep renting to guests.
  • State law gives every county the power: Act 17, signed May 3, 2024, says counties may phase out vacation rental uses.
  • The Big Island bill goes another way: as of November 13, 2026, Bill 147's draft lets rentals with a nonconforming use certificate keep operating.
  • Values were expected to fall on Maui: a 2025 University of Hawaiʻi study of Maui's original, faster proposal projected condo prices dropping 20 to 40%.

What did Maui County pass on short-term rentals, and has it taken effect?

Maui County passed a law in December 2025 that phases out short-term rentals in its apartment districts, and its deadlines haven’t arrived yet. The council adopted it as Ordinance 5909 on December 15, 2025 (Maui County records).

Maui’s phase-out What the county’s records show
Where it applies Short-term rentals in apartment zoning districts
West Maui deadline December 31, 2028
Deadline for the rest of Maui County December 31, 2030
What’s exempt Existing time share units, uses under a variance, and uses otherwise permitted by law

The county built in a wind-down period, so the affected rentals have until those dates. Some may rezone instead.

Could the Big Island phase out short-term rentals the way Maui is doing?

The Big Island could phase out short-term rentals the way Maui is doing, because a 2024 state law gives every county that power. Act 17 says uses that include lodging for visitors aren’t residential uses, and counties may phase them out (Act 17).

As of November 13, 2026, the rental bill before the Hawaiʻi County Council goes another way. Bill 147’s fourth draft, set for its final reading on November 18, would do the following (Bill 147, Draft 4):

  • Let whole-home rentals that hold a valid certificate keep running
  • Outside resort areas, allow whole-home rentals in multifamily zones only in buildings approved or permitted before the bill takes effect
  • Take away a rental’s certificate if the county cancels its registration
  • Outside the areas that allow whole-home rentals, let a rental without a certificate run only with a use permit, and only for stays of 31 to 179 days
  • Offer that permit only to a site that, at some point between April 1, 2019 and the day the bill takes effect, was rented only for stays of 31 to 179 days
  • Bar a site with that permit from renting for 30 days or less

The draft sets no phase-out deadline like Maui’s. Details can still change before the vote (status and timing), so ask a real estate attorney how it would apply to your parcel.

How did economists expect Maui’s phase-out to affect property values?

Economists expected Maui’s proposed phase-out to lower property values, with condo prices falling 20 to 40%. The estimate came from UHERO, a research group at the University of Hawaiʻi (UHERO). A few things to know about it:

  • It was published March 31, 2025, before Maui’s final law passed
  • It modeled 6,127 units leaving short-term use in two phases, in June 2025 and January 2026, faster than the deadlines Maui adopted
  • Its three scenarios ran from a drop of less than 20% to more than 40% in Maui’s median condo price
  • Most owners who’d lose rental use had out-of-state addresses, but the authors expected lower prices to hit people who live in their homes too

It’s a projection for Maui, made before the details were final. What the Big Island’s values would do depends on what, if anything, the county passes.

How can I protect my Big Island property’s value if rental rules change?

You can protect your Big Island property’s value if rental rules change by knowing how much of its price depends on short-term rental use. Work through these steps:

  1. Ask what the home would be worth to a buyer who’d never rent it
  2. Find out what its rental use rests on: zoning, a certificate or a permit, using the checks for rental eligibility
  3. Read your condo or HOA papers for limits on rentals
  4. Watch the Hawaiʻi County Council’s agendas for rental bills
  5. Ask a real estate attorney what a change could mean for your parcel

If you’re choosing between islands, compare buying on the Big Island against Maui. If you just want a home, read what Bill 47 means for a home buyer.

Sources

  1. County of Maui Department of Planning, memorandum to the Maui Planning Commission on Resolutions 26-110 and 26-111 (background on Ordinance 5909 and Ordinance 6008), September 22, 2026
  2. Hawaiʻi State Legislature, SB 2919 (2024), Relating to Property, Act 17
  3. Hawaiʻi County Council, Bill 147, Draft 4, relating to transient accommodations (amended November 6, 2026)
  4. University of Hawaiʻi Economic Research Organization (UHERO), An Economic Analysis of the Proposal to Phase Out Transient Vacation Rentals in Maui County Apartment Districts, March 31, 2025

Frequently asked questions

Does Maui's phase-out apply to single-family homes outside apartment districts?

Maui's phase-out covers short-term rentals in apartment zones, so it doesn't reach single-family homes in other zones. Maui County says about 6,500 vacation rental parcels, along with hotels, time shares and bed and breakfasts, will keep operating.

Can Maui owners keep renting to guests by rezoning their property?

Some Maui owners can keep renting to guests by rezoning their property into one of two new hotel districts, H-3 and H-4, which took effect June 22, 2026. Council resolutions would move properties holding 3,823 units into them. The planning commission aims to finish its review by November 24, 2026, and the council decides after that.

How many Maui units were renting to guests when the phase-out was proposed?

Maui had 6,208 units renting to guests in apartment districts as of May 29, 2024, the month the phase-out was proposed, according to the county's finance department. Maui County expects the phase-out to return more than 6,000 units to long-term residential use.

Would a Big Island phase-out lower prices for homes that were never rented?

A Big Island phase-out could lower prices even for homes that were never rented, if Maui's condo projections are any guide. The UHERO study treated all Maui condos as one market and expected price declines to reach owners who live in their homes. As of November 13, 2026, Bill 147's draft sets no phase-out deadline.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields