Why would I buy on the Big Island instead of Maui, where everyone seems to want to be?

You'd buy on the Big Island instead of Maui mainly for value, and because far more houses sell here. In September 2026, the typical Big Island listing asked about $400,000 less than the typical Maui County listing. About four of every five Big Island sales over the past year were single-family homes. Compare similar homes on both islands.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • The Big Island costs less: its typical listing asked about $400,000 less than Maui County's in September 2026.
  • Houses lead the market here: about four of every five Big Island sales over the past year were single-family homes.
  • Maui County leans toward condos: fewer than half of its sales over the same 12 months were single-family homes.
  • Rental rules are changing on Maui: its council voted to phase out vacation rentals in apartment-zoned buildings, starting in 2029.
  • Compare like with like: line up recent sales of the same kind of home on each island.

How do Big Island home prices compare with Maui home prices?

Big Island home prices run well below Maui home prices. In September 2026, the median asking price was $599,000 in Hawaiʻi County and $995,000 in Maui County (Realtor.com data, published by the St. Louis Fed). That’s about $400,000 less for the typical Big Island listing.

  • Maui County’s median asking price was $1,150,000 a year earlier, so it has come down
  • Both numbers cover every listing in the county, from small homes to estates
  • Neither one tells you what a luxury home costs on either island

Luxury homes have their own price ranges here, so see what luxury actually costs on the Big Island. To compare what a square foot costs in each county, read whether the Big Island is the undervalued island.

What kinds of homes sell on the Big Island compared with Maui?

Mostly single-family homes sell on the Big Island, compared with Maui County, where condos make up more than half of sales. Here’s what sold in the 12 months from October 2025 through September 2026, from Title Guaranty’s monthly counts:

Homes sold Big Island Maui County
Single-family homes 1,966 717
Condos 515 810
Share that were single-family About 79% About 47%

So on the Big Island, far more houses change hands in a year. In Maui County, more of what sells is in condo buildings. If a house with a yard is what you’re after, you’ll find many more of them selling here.

How should I choose between buying on the Big Island and buying on Maui?

To choose between buying on the Big Island and buying on Maui, start with how you want to live, then compare the same kind of home on each island. Take it one step at a time:

  1. Write down the life you want, such as sun and golf, a resort club or a quiet street
  2. Pick the areas on each island that fit that life
  3. Compare recent sales of similar homes in those areas, and set the county medians aside
  4. Add up the yearly costs, starting with property taxes, which each county sets on its own
  5. If you’ll ever rent the home out, check whether that exact home can be rented before you make an offer

Rules can change, too. Maui County’s council voted in December 2025 to phase out vacation rentals in apartment-zoned buildings, starting in 2029 in West Maui and 2031 elsewhere (Maui County Council). Here’s whether the Big Island could do the same.

Sources

  1. Realtor.com, Housing Inventory Core Metrics: Inventory Metrics by Geography, Hawaii (Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, FRED)
  2. Title Guaranty Hawaii, Residential Sales Report: Hawaii, September 2026
  3. Maui County Council, Final reading brings approval to Bill 9 (December 15, 2025)

Frequently asked questions

Is the Big Island cheaper than Maui for a luxury home?

Whether the Big Island is cheaper than Maui for a luxury home depends on the community, because the county-wide numbers mix every kind of home together. For a fair comparison, look at recent sales of similar homes in the resort or neighborhood you'd actually buy in on each island.

Is it easier to find a single-family home on the Big Island than on Maui?

Finding a single-family home is easier on the Big Island than in Maui County, because far more of them sell here. Title Guaranty's monthly counts add up to 1,966 single-family sales on the Big Island in the 12 months through September 2026, against 717 in Maui County. Condos run the other way, with more sales in Maui County.

Do Big Island property taxes work the same way as Maui property taxes?

Big Island and Maui property taxes are set separately, because each county in Hawaiʻi runs its own real property tax. Rates, classes and exemptions can differ. Before you compare two homes, get the current tax for each one from its county, and ask your CPA how it fits your plans.

Should I visit both the Big Island and Maui before I buy?

Visiting both the Big Island and Maui before you buy is worth it if you're torn between them. Spend your time in the areas you'd actually live, and go at the time of year you'd use the home most.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields