Long read
Bill 47, property values and the Big Island buyer: what the regulations actually mean for you
Bill 47 only asks rentals to register and Bill 147 is still pending, so protect value by pricing a home as a home and paying for rental use only once it's proven.
The short version
Bill 47 is the Big Island's registration law for vacation rentals, so it asks almost nothing of a buyer who never rents. The rules that move value are about where rentals are allowed. Bill 147, which would rewrite them, passed first reading and faces a final council vote on November 18, 2026. Start from what the home is worth without rental use. Pay extra for rental use only once you've proven it's legal, it'll last and your next buyer will pay for it too.
Key takeaways
- Bill 47 is a registration law: it's Ordinance 25-50, and it doesn't change zoning or where rentals are allowed.
- Bill 147 is the one with value attached: it would rewrite where each kind of vacation rental is allowed on the Big Island.
- Bill 147 isn't law yet: it passed first reading on October 21, 2026, was amended on November 6 and faces a final vote on November 18.
- No phase-out is in the draft: as of November 13, 2026, Bill 147 sets no deadline for ending rentals that operate legally today.
- The footing sets the value: zoning stays with the land, while a county certificate needs yearly renewal and steady rental use.
- Never-renters should pay little: eligibility is worth only what your next buyer will pay, less the risk the rules change first.
- Check before you pay: confirm the zoning, the certificate, the permits and the association's rules before your contingencies end.
In this guide
- What does Bill 47 actually do to a Big Island home buyer or owner?
- Where does Bill 147 stand on the Big Island as of November 13, 2026?
- What would Bill 147 change for Big Island buyers and owners if it passes?
- What does a Big Island property’s rental use rest on, and why does that set its value?
- How do vacation rental rules move Big Island property values?
- What should a Big Island buyer who never plans to rent pay for rental eligibility?
- Which checks keep a Big Island buyer from paying for rental use that isn’t there?
- How should a Big Island owner plan a sale while Bill 147 is still pending?
What does Bill 47 actually do to a Big Island home buyer or owner?
Bill 47 actually does very little to a Big Island home buyer or owner who never rents to guests. It’s the county’s vacation rental registration law, adopted as Ordinance 25-50, and registration has been required since September 1, 2026.
Under that law, a vacation rental is a home, or part of one, rented to a guest for less than 180 consecutive days. Maybe you’ll live in the home or use it yourself. Maybe you’ll lease it to a tenant for 180 days or more in a row. Either way, there’s nothing to register (what Bill 47 means for a home buyer).
Every short stay rental has to be registered before the first guest arrives, and the registration names a contact who can answer a neighbor’s call within an hour.
What registration leaves alone: it isn’t a permit, it doesn’t change the zoning, it doesn’t change where rentals are allowed, and it doesn’t cap how many rentals the island has. Registering also can’t make a rental legal where the zoning doesn’t allow it.
Two parts of Bill 47 do reach a sale, and both are about paperwork:
- The registration belongs to the owner. It ends 90 days after the home changes hands, so a buyer who wants to keep renting registers in their own name
- A registration says nothing about whether the rental use itself is allowed on that parcel, so a buyer still has to check that separately
Both points are covered for sellers in how to time a sale around Bill 47.
So the question a buyer or owner should be asking sits somewhere else. What moves a property’s value is what its rental use legally rests on, and the zoning bill the County Council is still deciding. That second bill is Bill 147. The two numbers look alike, and they’re easy to mix up. Bill 47 asked rentals to register. Bill 147 would change where each kind of rental is allowed at all, and that’s the one with value attached.
Where does Bill 147 stand on the Big Island as of November 13, 2026?
As of November 13, 2026, Bill 147 has passed its first reading on the Big Island and is waiting on its final vote, which the County Council has scheduled for November 18. It isn’t law yet. If it passes, it would rewrite the part of the county’s zoning code that decides where each kind of vacation rental is allowed (Bill 147, Draft 4).
Here’s the path it has taken through the council this fall, from the county’s own records:
-
October 6, 2026: the planning committee
The council’s planning committee amended the bill and sent it on with a negative recommendation, voting 4 to 5 (Draft 2 record; October 21 actions).
-
October 21, 2026: first reading
The full council amended it to its third draft and passed it on first reading, 7 to 0, with two members absent.
-
November 6, 2026: final reading put off
At what was set to be its final reading, the council amended it to a fourth draft. It then held the bill over to November 18, under one of its own rules (council actions, November 6).
-
November 18, 2026: final reading scheduled
Draft 4 is on the council’s agenda for second or final reading, with a motion to pass it already on the table (council agenda, November 18).
The November 6 change was narrow. Outside the resort areas, a whole-home rental in a multifamily zone would qualify if the building’s plans were approved, or its building permit was issued, before the law takes effect. The third draft asked for plan approval only.
A few things about this calendar are worth keeping in mind. A bill that passes its final reading still goes to the mayor, and Draft 4 says it takes effect when it’s approved. Agendas move, and the council can amend or hold a bill again on the day. So treat November 18 as the next date to check, and nothing more certain than that.
If you’re in the middle of a purchase, ask your attorney to check the bill’s status again right before your contingencies end. Anything that changes after you close, you’ll have to live with.
What would Bill 147 change for Big Island buyers and owners if it passes?
If it passes, Bill 147 would change four things that matter to Big Island buyers and owners. They’re what counts as a short stay, which areas allow whole-home rentals, how a rental outside those areas can keep going, and the bedroom limit inside resort areas. It also adds operating rules, fines and an enforcement fund, which matter more to people running rentals. Here’s the draft set against today’s code (Bill 147, Draft 4):
| The rule | Today’s zoning code | Bill 147, Draft 4 |
|---|---|---|
| A short stay, for zoning | A whole-home rental of 30 days or less | Any rental of less than 180 consecutive days |
| Bedrooms you can rent | No more than five on a building site | Still five, except any number inside a General Plan resort or resort node area |
| Whole-home rentals with no host | Allowed in certain zones and areas | Allowed in the resort-hotel zone, three commercial zones, resort areas, some multifamily buildings and a few other areas |
| A rental holding a certificate | Keeps going if it’s renewed every year | Keeps going, but the certificate ends if the county cancels the registration |
| A whole-home rental elsewhere with no certificate | Not allowed for stays of 30 days or less | Only with a use permit, for stays of 31 to 179 days, and only for sites rented that way at some point since April 1, 2019 |
| A phase-out deadline | None | None |
Very few rentals would qualify for the use permit in that table. It’s open only to a site that, at some point between April 1, 2019 and the day the law takes effect, was rented only for stays of more than 30 and less than 180 days. On state farm land, the lot also has to have been created before June 4, 1976. A site with that permit could never rent for 30 days or less.
The draft has one narrow delay built in. If it’s needed, the planning director may hold off enforcing the law until no later than December 31, 2027. That delay covers only a rental in a dwelling that lacks the permits the county’s construction codes require, such as building, electrical or plumbing permits. Everything else takes effect when the law is approved.
For value, the most important line is the last one in the table. Bill 147 as drafted sets no date for ending rentals that operate legally today. That’s the opposite direction from Maui, and it’s why a buyer here should read the draft before reading the headlines. Every line of it can still change before the final vote, so ask a real estate attorney how the version that passes applies to the exact parcel you’re buying.
What does a Big Island property’s rental use rest on, and why does that set its value?
For a whole-home rental, a Big Island property’s rental use rests on one of a few things: its zoning, a county certificate, or, under Bill 147, a use permit. Private rules can still take it away. Which one it rests on sets its value, because each one passes to a buyer on different terms and can be lost in a different way. A buyer is really paying for how sturdy that footing is.
Zoning
Where the zoning allows whole-home rentals, the right comes with the land. It stays with the property at a sale, whoever owns it. Only a change to the zoning code, or private rules, can take it away.
A nonconforming use certificate
A sale doesn’t end it, and the new owner notifies the planning director. It has to be renewed every year, and it ends if the rental use stops for 12 months in a row. The window to apply for one closed in 2019, and no new ones are issued.
Private rules
A condo’s declaration can limit rentals, and owners holding 67% of the common interest can amend it unless it asks for more. Some private communities don’t allow short-term rentals at all. Kūkiʻo is one (selling in a private community).
The registration
This is the owner’s paperwork under Bill 47. It shows the county knows about the rental, and it ends 90 days after a sale. It adds no rental right of its own.
Put those side by side and the order is clear. Zoning is the sturdiest footing, because it doesn’t depend on the owner doing anything. A certificate is real, but it’s only as good as its renewals and the rental history behind it. A use permit under Bill 147 would come with limits written in. A registration is a record, and it gives no right to rent.
That’s why two homes on the same street can be worth different amounts to a buyer who wants to rent, even when both have hosted guests. One might sit in a resort node, and the other might be running on a certificate that lapses the first year nobody rents it.
A seller’s listing won’t usually tell you which is which. The checks for that come later in this guide, and they’re the same ones laid out in what to check before paying more for rental eligibility.
“What initially looked like a solid investment may not be the cash flow you were hoping for.”
Dan Polimino
How do vacation rental rules move Big Island property values?
Vacation rental rules move Big Island property values through the buyers who’d pay more for rental use, and through what happens to that extra price when the rules tighten. A home is worth more for its rental use only where enough buyers will pay for it, and only for as long as the use is safe.
The first figure shows what’s at stake when a county ends rentals. UHERO’s study came out before Maui’s final law passed, and it modeled a faster phase-out than the one Maui adopted. It still expected lower prices to reach people who live in their homes, since it treated Maui’s condos as one market (could the Big Island follow Maui). State law lets every county phase out vacation rental uses. As of November 13, 2026, the Big Island’s pending bill doesn’t.
The other two figures show how eligibility can be lost one property at a time, with no new county law at all. It takes only an owners’ vote in a condo building, or a year without renting under a certificate.
Rules also move value through the costs that come with rental use. These land on any owner who rents short-term, and on the price a later buyer will pay:
- Taxes on the rent: stays under 180 days add the state’s 11% transient accommodations tax and the county’s 3%, on top of the general excise tax.
- Financing: Fannie Mae won’t buy loans in a condo project run like a hotel, which narrows the pool of buyers who can borrow there (eligibility as an investment).
- Property tax: a home rented for terms shorter than six months can’t get the homeowner rate (property taxes for out-of-state owners).
Rental use can still add value, but only on conditions. A buyer who pays extra for it is betting that the footing holds, that the costs stay worth carrying and that the next buyer pays for it too.
What should a Big Island buyer who never plans to rent pay for rental eligibility?
A Big Island buyer who never plans to rent should pay for rental eligibility only up to what the next buyer is likely to pay for it, and less if the rules could change first. You’d only get the value of eligibility when you sell. So start from what the home is worth without it, then decide what to add, if anything.
That sounds simple, but it leads to three things a never-renter needs to weigh.
- A certificate may not survive you: if the home’s rental use rests on a nonconforming use certificate, it ends after 12 months in a row without rental use. An owner who never rents could let it lapse in the first year, and the premium paid for it goes with it.
- Zoning keeps, but it isn’t free: eligibility that comes from the zoning stays with the land, so it can still be worth something when you sell. You’ll carry the cost of it every year until then.
- The rules can move before you sell: Bill 147 would rewrite where rentals are allowed, and state law lets the county go further later.
The yearly cost is easy to miss. The county assesses property at market value, so if eligible homes sell for more, your assessment can follow. For 2026 to 2027, each extra $100,000 of assessed value on a second home in the residential class adds $1,110 to $1,700 a year in property tax, depending on the tier. If you paid the premium in cash, that money isn’t earning anything elsewhere. If you borrowed it, you pay interest on it every year.
To put a number on the premium, compare recent sales of similar homes in the same area, some eligible and some not, and look at the gap. Have each home’s status confirmed by the county, since a listing can be wrong. If there aren’t enough sales of both kinds to compare, you can’t measure the premium, and that’s a good reason to be careful about paying one. The full method is in what a never-renter should pay.
Which checks keep a Big Island buyer from paying for rental use that isn’t there?
The checks that keep a Big Island buyer from paying for rental use that isn’t there cover six things. They’re the parcel’s zoning, any certificate and its renewals, and the permits for every rented space. Then come the association’s documents, any changes the owners are discussing, and the county’s pending bill. Do them before your contingencies end. Here’s who answers each one:
| What to check | Who can confirm it |
|---|---|
| Whether the zoning allows a whole-home rental on that parcel | The county Planning Department |
| Whether a certificate exists and was renewed on time | The seller has the receipts; the Planning Department confirms |
| Permits for every space that’s been rented | The seller and the county’s permit records |
| Rental limits in the condo or community documents | The association, and your attorney |
| Changes the owners are discussing | The association’s board and recent minutes |
| Where Bill 147 stands on the day you close | The County Council’s agenda, and your attorney |
The permits matter more than most buyers expect, since the county asks for them when anyone registers a rental. If a rented space has no permit, ask your attorney what that means for the purchase before you go further.
The association documents deserve a slow read. Rental limits can sit in any of the association’s documents. Owners can also vote to change the declaration after you buy. Ask the board whether a change is being discussed. Read them in the order laid out in how to read HOA and CC&R documents.
Then ask the seller one plain question: how has the home been used, and for how long was each stay? The answer tells you whether the home has only been rented, or is allowed to rent. Pay extra only for the second.
If a listing or a seller’s projection assumes rental income, keep it out of your price until every check above is done. A projection can tell you what nearby rentals earn. It can’t tell you whether this one is allowed to rent. How a property would actually perform as a rental is a question for a property manager who manages rentals in that area.
How should a Big Island owner plan a sale while Bill 147 is still pending?
A Big Island owner should plan a sale while Bill 147 is still pending around their own reasons for selling, and use the wait to get the rental paperwork in order. Nobody can tell you how the vote ends, and timing a sale around a guess about it is a weak plan.
Start with whether you’d sell anyway. Owners sell for all kinds of reasons that have nothing to do with a county bill. They don’t use the home as much as they thought, it costs more to hold than they planned, or it’s hard to manage from the mainland. If one of those is your reason, the bill is a detail. Weigh it with the reasons owners sell or hold.
Then think about who your buyer is. If your home’s price leans on rental use, the buyers it attracts will ask the same questions this guide does. Have the answers ready before you list:
- Your registration number, and a note that it ends 90 days after the sale
- The zoning, or the certificate with every renewal receipt
- The permits for every space you’ve rented
- The association’s rental rules, and any change being discussed
An owner whose rental rests on zoning has the easiest story to tell. An owner running on a certificate should show it’s current and that the use hasn’t stopped. If your home was never rented, list it on its value as a home and say so plainly.
Finally, know your number. Rental rules are one input. Your payoff, the commission, the conveyance tax and any tax on the gain decide what you walk away with, so work through what you’ll net when you sell before you choose a date. Ask your attorney what Bill 147 could change for your parcel, so your listing says only what’s true on the day it goes live.
The Bottom Line
Why should a Big Island buyer price a home before pricing its rental use?
A Big Island buyer should price a home before pricing its rental use because the home is the part you can count on. Bill 47 asks rentals to register. Bill 147 would decide where they're allowed, and it's still before the County Council as of November 13, 2026. A buyer who pays only for what's proven is protected whichever way that vote goes.
So start with what similar homes sold for. Then find out what the rental use rests on, how it passes to you and how it could be lost. Add something for it only when the answers hold up, and only as much as your next buyer would pay.
If you already own, the same thinking works in reverse. Gather the paperwork, know your net and sell for your own reasons, on your own timeline.
Pay for the home you can count on, and pay for rental use only once it's proven.
Sources
- Hawaiʻi County Council, Bill 147, Draft 4, relating to transient accommodations (amended November 6, 2026)
- Hawaiʻi County Council, actions taken at the November 6, 2026 meeting
- Hawaiʻi County Council, agenda for November 18, 2026 (Bill 147, Draft 4, second or final reading)
- Hawaiʻi County Council, actions taken at the October 21, 2026 meeting
- Hawaiʻi County Council, Bill 147, Draft 2 record (forwarded to Council with a negative recommendation, October 6, 2026)
Regulatory information changes. Hawaiʻi County rules, state tax law, and federal withholding requirements described here reflect the last-reviewed date above; confirm current requirements with the relevant agency or your advisor before acting.
This guide is general information, not legal, tax, or investment advice. Talk to your attorney, CPA, or advisor about your specific situation.
More questions about this
Is Bill 47 the same as Bill 147 on the Big Island?
Bill 47 and Bill 147 are two separate Big Island bills. Bill 47 became Ordinance 25-50, the county's vacation rental registration law, and registration has been required since September 1, 2026. Bill 147 is a zoning bill that would change where each kind of vacation rental is allowed. As of November 13, 2026, it wasn't law yet.
Did the Hawaiʻi County Council pass Bill 147 on November 6, 2026?
The Hawaiʻi County Council didn't pass Bill 147 on November 6, 2026. It amended the bill to a fourth draft and held it over to its November 18 meeting, where the bill is on the agenda for its final reading. The bill passed its first reading on October 21, 2026.
Would Bill 147 shut down Big Island vacation rentals that operate legally today?
Bill 147's fourth draft doesn't set a deadline for shutting down Big Island vacation rentals that operate legally today. Rentals in the zones it allows keep going, and rentals with a nonconforming use certificate can too. A certificate would end if the county cancels the rental's registration. A whole-home rental outside the allowed zones that rents for 31 to 179 days would need a use permit once the law takes effect. The draft can still change before the final vote.
Does a Big Island vacation rental registration pass to the buyer?
A Big Island vacation rental registration doesn't pass to the buyer for good. It ends 90 days after the property changes hands, so a buyer who wants to keep renting has to register in their own name. The registration is a record of the rental, and the rental use itself still has to be allowed on that parcel.
Can every Big Island resort home be rented to short-stay guests?
Not every Big Island resort home can be rented to short-stay guests. The zoning or a certificate has to allow it, the rental has to be registered, and the community's own rules can still forbid it. Kūkiʻo, for one, doesn't allow short-term rentals. Read the declaration and community rules for that specific home before you count on rental use.
How long would Big Island owners have to comply if Bill 147 passes?
If Bill 147 passes as drafted, Big Island owners would have to comply once it takes effect on approval. The draft lets the planning director, if needed, delay enforcement until no later than December 31, 2027 against rentals in a dwelling that lacks its building, electrical or plumbing permits. Ask a real estate attorney how the final version applies to your parcel.
Who can confirm whether a Big Island parcel can be used as a vacation rental?
The County of Hawaiʻi Planning Department can confirm whether a Big Island parcel's zoning or certificate allows vacation rental use. The association can tell you what its documents allow. A real estate attorney can tell you what both mean for your purchase, and how a pending bill could change the answer.