Is now actually a good time to buy luxury real estate on the Big Island, or should I wait?

Now is a good time to buy luxury real estate on the Big Island if your plans are settled: where you want to be, how you'll use it and how long you'll keep it. If they aren't, wait. If you can choose when to buy, the slow season, May through September, often brings more homes and more price cuts.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • Your plans come first: know your area and how long you'll keep the home before the market's timing matters.
  • Plan to stay a few years: buying and selling are expensive, so a short stay rarely makes those costs worth it.
  • Summer often favors buyers: in my experience, May through September brings fewer people to the island, more homes for sale and more price cuts.
  • Budget past the price: the yearly costs of owning keep coming in the months you're away.
  • Let the market shape the offer: current prices and inventory tell you how hard to negotiate on a home you've chosen.

“When buyers ask me when the best time to buy a home is, I tell them it's during the slow season from May through September.”

Dan Polimino

When is the best time of year to buy a luxury home on the Big Island?

The best time of year to buy a luxury home on the Big Island is usually the slow season, from May through September. In my experience, that’s when the island is quiet and more homes sit for sale. Sellers who listed for the busy winter and didn’t sell start cutting their prices.

Season Months What a buyer finds
Selling season Just before Thanksgiving through the end of April The most people on the island, and the most foot traffic at showings
Slow season May through September Fewer people on the island, more homes for sale and more price cuts

Keep an eye on how many homes are coming up for sale in the months you plan to look.

What should decide whether I buy a Big Island luxury home now or wait?

Your own plans should decide whether you buy a Big Island luxury home now or wait. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says buying can make sense if you’re willing to stay put for a few years. Buying and selling a home are expensive, so you need time to make those costs worth it. You’re ready to buy when:

  • You know which side of the island, and which communities, you want
  • You know how you’ll use it, and whether you’ll ever rent it out
  • You expect to keep it for at least a few years
  • You can carry the yearly costs, from the property tax to insurance and upkeep

If all four are true, buy when the right home comes up, and let the market shape your offer. If they aren’t settled yet, take the time to narrow your search before you buy.

What do current market conditions mean for a Big Island luxury buyer?

Current market conditions mean Big Island buyers have more room to compare and negotiate than a few years ago, though a luxury buyer’s room varies by area and price. Three questions tell you how much room you have:

Where prices are headed
Forecasts are thin, so weigh where Big Island home prices may go from here before you count on a drop.
Whether buyers have the edge
The newest sales show whether the Big Island is in a down market at your price.
How much choice you have
New listings and homes under contract show whether you’re at risk of overpaying.

These conditions change from month to month, so ask your agent for a monthly update on all three in the community you want.

How should I get ready to buy a Big Island luxury home in the slow season?

To get ready to buy a Big Island luxury home in the slow season, settle your plans and your budget in the spring, then shop from May through September. Take these steps in order:

  1. Pick your side of the island and two or three communities to focus on
  2. Set a yearly budget for owning the home, with insurance and upkeep in it
  3. Line up your loan approval or proof of funds before you fly over
  4. Check each home’s flood and weather risks before you choose it
  5. Book your visits for the summer, and ask your agent to flag new listings and price cuts

The CFPB’s step-by-step guide to home loans warns that weather risks are growing, so your insurance costs could go up. Get an insurance quote on any home you’re serious about before you make an offer.

Sources

  1. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, What are some of the financial considerations of buying a home?
  2. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Your home loan toolkit: A step-by-step guide (August 2026)

Frequently asked questions

Should I wait for Big Island home prices to drop before I buy?

Waiting for Big Island home prices to drop before you buy is a guess, and it can cost you the right home. Prices can soften in one area and hold in another. If your plans are settled and a home fits them, base your offer on recent sales of similar homes. That protects you better than trying to time the market.

How long should I plan to keep a home I buy on the Big Island?

Plan to keep a home you buy on the Big Island for at least a few years. Buying and selling are expensive, and a home's value can dip in the short run. A longer stay gives you time to cover those costs. If you may leave within a year or two, renting first could be the better move.

Do Big Island sellers cut prices more often in the summer?

In my experience, Big Island sellers do cut prices more often from May through September. Many listed for the busy winter season and didn't sell, and there are far fewer people on the island in those months. Every home is different, so check its own listing history before you make an offer.

Is the busy winter season a bad time to buy a Big Island home?

The busy winter season can still be a good time to buy a Big Island home. You'll have more buyers to compete with, because in my experience that's when the island has the most people on it and when sellers want to be on the market. Be ready to move on a home that fits.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields