Everyone says buy in a down market. Is the Big Island in one right now, or not?

The Big Island is in a mild down market right now. In September 2026, single-family home sales were down 21.5% from a year earlier, and the median sale price was down 15%. Over 2026 so far, the median is down only about 2%. Homes that did sell still went for close to asking.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • Sales have slowed: Big Island single-family sales fell 21.5% in September 2026 from a year earlier.
  • Prices have slipped: the single-family median for 2026 so far is $555,000, down 1.8% from the same months of 2025.
  • One month can mislead: monthly medians swing a lot, so the year-to-date numbers are the steadier guide.
  • Condos softened too: condo sales for the year are down 6.2%, and the condo median is down 2.3%.
  • Your price range decides it: a buyer's market at one price level can be a balanced market at another.

What do the newest Big Island home sales numbers show?

The newest Big Island home sales numbers show fewer sales and lower prices than a year ago. Here’s Title Guaranty’s September 2026 report for the island, where 2026 so far means January through September:

Measure September 2026 Change from a year earlier 2026 so far Change from a year earlier
Single-family sales 135 Down 21.5% 1,466 Down 3.2%
Single-family median price $499,000 Down 15.0% $555,000 Down 1.8%
Condo sales 32 Down 34.7% 378 Down 6.2%
Condo median price $604,500 Down 5.5% $625,000 Down 2.3%

The year-to-date numbers are the steadier guide, because a single month’s median can swing a lot. A year earlier it ran the other way: in the September 2025 report, the single-family median was up 12.2% from the year before. Homes are still selling close to their asking prices; for the numbers, see how close sales come to asking.

Does a Big Island down market hit every area and price the same?

A Big Island down market doesn’t hit every area and price the same, because each part of the market moves on its own. Three things split it:

  • Home type: condos and single-family homes move separately, as the table above shows
  • District: a district’s median can rise while the island’s falls, so look at what each part of the island costs
  • Price level: at the top of the market, sales are few, so a handful of them can move any number

Before you decide you’ve got the edge as a buyer, check recent sales at your own price level and in the community you want.

How can a buyer use a softer Big Island market?

A buyer can use a softer Big Island market by asking for things a seller might turn down in a busier one. These are worth asking for:

  1. A lower price on a home that has sat for months or already had a price cut
  2. Help from the seller with your closing costs
  3. Repairs, or a credit for them, when the inspection turns something up
  4. More time for inspections, or a closing date that suits you

Every one of those asks still needs a fair price behind it, and you can set one with the steps for avoiding overpaying. If you’re holding out for a deeper drop, weigh where Big Island prices may go from here first.

Sources

  1. Title Guaranty Hawaii, Residential Sales Report: Hawaii, September 2026
  2. Title Guaranty Hawaii, Residential Sales Report: Hawaii, September 2025

Frequently asked questions

What counts as a down market in real estate?

A down market in real estate usually means fewer sales and falling prices, with buyers holding more bargaining power than sellers. There's no single number that marks one. On the Big Island, look at sales and median prices across several months, and at how long homes are taking to sell, rather than at one month's results.

Are Big Island luxury homes losing value right now?

The island-wide numbers can't tell you whether Big Island luxury homes are losing value right now, because Title Guaranty's medians cover homes at every price. For 2026 so far, the single-family median is down 1.8%, but the dollar total of single-family sales is up 12.9% on 3.2% fewer sales, so the average sale ran higher. Recent sales in your own community and price range show your part of the market.

Is it smart to buy on the Big Island while sales are slow?

Buying on the Big Island while sales are slow can be smart if the home fits your plans and you'll keep it for years. Slow sales usually mean more homes to choose from and sellers who are open to offers. A home that has sat for months gives you the most room.

Do Big Island condos and houses move together in a down market?

Big Island condos and houses don't always move together in a down market. In September 2026, condo sales fell 34.7% from a year earlier, a bigger drop than the 21.5% for single-family homes. For 2026 so far, both medians are down about 2%. So you'll want to watch the numbers for the kind of home you're after.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields