These equity club memberships at Hualālai, Kūkiʻo, and Kohanaiki: am I buying the house or buying into the club, and what does that really cost?
When you're buying at resorts with equity clubs, like Hualālai, Kūkiʻo and Kohanaiki, the house and the club membership are separate agreements, even when one comes with the other. What the membership really costs is the club's price to join plus its yearly dues. Each club sets both in its own papers, along with how a membership transfers.
Key takeaways
- The club has its own papers: a membership is an agreement with the club, separate from the home itself.
- The association comes with the home: in a Hawaiʻi planned community, owning a home there makes you a member of its association.
- The club sets the terms: its own documents decide who gets in and whether any of the price comes back.
- Dues can change: one Big Island club's 2003 terms had its board set the dues again every year.
- Check the transfer early: a seller's membership may pass to you. If not, you may need to apply and pay the club's price.
“Their amenities are off the hook.”
Dan Polimino
Is a resort club membership part of the house, or a separate purchase?
A resort club membership is a separate purchase from the house, even where the two are offered together. The home is real estate you take title to. The membership is an agreement with the club, and the club’s own papers decide who can join and on what terms.
That’s different from the homeowners association. In a Hawaiʻi planned community, owning a home there makes you a member of the association, and you owe its assessments (HRS §421J-2).
| Homeowners association | Resort club | |
|---|---|---|
| How you join | Automatically, by owning a home there | By the club’s own rules, sometimes after an approval |
| What you pay | Assessments the association sets | A price to join, plus dues the club sets |
| What governs it | The declaration and bylaws, plus any rules | The club’s membership papers |
Kūkiʻo’s club, for instance, vets everyone who wants in, and that shapes who buys in a private community.
What does an equity club membership on the Big Island really cost?
An equity club membership on the Big Island really costs the club’s price to join, plus yearly dues and any assessments, less whatever part of that price comes back when you leave. Each club sets those terms in its own membership documents. Ask about each one:
- The price to join, which a club may call a membership contribution, a deposit or an initiation fee
- Yearly dues, and how often they’ve gone up
- Assessments, if the club runs short or needs major repairs
- What happens to the price you paid when you sell the home or leave the club
- The transfer terms, including any fee or approval when a home sells
- The homeowners association’s dues, which are separate (see how to read the association’s papers)
One golf club at Mauna Lani described its terms in a 2003 letter to the SEC (Securities and Exchange Commission). Its board set the price to join and decided the dues every year. Members were assessed for any operating shortfall. Capital assessments needed a majority vote of members, but the board could charge for extraordinary repairs without one.
Those were one club’s terms more than 20 years ago. Ask for the current ones at the club you’re buying into.
What happens to the seller’s club membership when I buy a Big Island resort home?
When you buy a Big Island resort home, the seller’s club membership may pass to you or go back to the club, and that club’s transfer rules decide which. In the same 2003 letter, the Mauna Lani club’s rules worked like this:
- Members couldn’t sell a membership on the open market, only through the club
- A resigned membership went on a waiting list and was reissued in turn
- A member selling a home could have the membership moved to the buyer, once the buyer was approved and paid the club’s current price
- A member who resigned got back 80% of the club’s current price once the membership was reissued, less anything owed to the club
The steps below cover what to ask.
What should I verify about a club membership before making an offer on a Big Island home?
Before making an offer on a Big Island home with a club, verify what the membership costs and how it transfers. Work through these steps:
- Ask whether membership is required or optional, and whether there’s a wait
- Get the club’s membership plan and bylaws in writing. Get its current price and dues too
- Ask how the seller’s membership transfers, and who keeps any refund
- Ask whether a dues increase or an assessment is planned or under discussion
- Find out how long approval takes, so it fits your contract’s deadlines
- Ask your attorney to review the club’s papers together with the association’s
Hawaiʻi’s seller disclosure law lists the association’s papers a seller hands over, but it doesn’t name a club (HRS §508D-3.5). Ask for the club’s papers too.
Sources
- Hawaii Revised Statutes §421J-2, Definitions (planned community associations; Hawaii State Legislature)
- U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Olohana Golf Club, Inc., no-action letter and incoming letter, July 31, 2003
- Hawaii Revised Statutes §508D-3.5, Disclosure of documents; required documentation (Hawaii State Legislature)
Frequently asked questions
Is an equity club membership on the Big Island a good investment?
An equity club membership on the Big Island is best judged as part of the cost of living there. One Mauna Lani club's 2003 letter to the SEC said buyers would be told that memberships shouldn't be viewed or acquired as investments. Each membership was an ownership interest, but members got no income or dividends from the club.
What's the difference between an equity and a non-equity club membership?
The difference between an equity and a non-equity club membership is ownership. In a Mauna Lani club's 2003 letter to the SEC, each equity membership was an ownership interest with a vote. The same club's non-equity memberships carried no vote and no refund. Ask which kind you're being offered, since it changes what you'd get back.
Can a Big Island resort club change its membership terms after I join?
A Big Island resort club can change its membership terms after you join if its papers allow it. In the 2003 Mauna Lani letter, once members took over the board, a change needed a majority of the board, a majority of the equity members' votes and the management company's approval. Read how your club's papers can change before you buy.
Can I deduct Big Island resort club dues as a business expense?
You generally can't deduct Big Island resort club dues as a business expense. IRS Publication 463 says you can't deduct dues, including initiation fees, for any club organized for business, pleasure, recreation or other social purposes, and it names country clubs and golf clubs. Ask your CPA how the rules apply to you.
Communities where this comes up
Hualālai
Hualālai is the Four Seasons resort community at Kaʻūpūlehu on the Kona coast, where owners can join a private club that's open only to residents.
Kohanaiki
Kohanaiki is the newest of the Kona-Kohala resorts, a private club community where most homes are recent, building is still going on and the club is the center of daily life.
Kūkiʻo
Kūkiʻo is a private club community next to Hualālai on the Kona coast, where the club vets every member and short-term rentals aren't allowed.
Hualālai, Kūkiʻo and Kohanaiki compared
How three of the Kona coast's top communities differ for owners and sellers.