Hualālai vs. Kūkiʻo vs. Kohanaiki: Which Big Island Equity Community Should You Buy Into?
Three private club communities on one stretch of the Kona coast, compared on the club and its rules and on how homes rent and resell.
The Big Island equity community to buy into depends on how you’ll live, because Hualālai, Kūkiʻo and Kohanaiki suit different buyers. All three sit on the Kona coast north of Kailua-Kona. Hualālai has a Four Seasons hotel inside it. Kūkiʻo bars short-term rentals and vets every club member. Kohanaiki is the newest.
How do Hualālai, Kūkiʻo and Kohanaiki compare side by side?
Side by side, Hualālai, Kūkiʻo and Kohanaiki differ most in their clubs and access rules, and in whether a home can be rented. All three sit on the Kona coast north of Kailua-Kona. Here’s how they line up on what I could confirm from public sources:
| Hualālai | Kūkiʻo | Kohanaiki | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Where | At Kaʻūpūlehu, about 8 minutes north of the Kona airport (Hualālai Resort). | Near the Four Seasons at Hualālai (Star-Advertiser, 2016). | About four miles north of Kailua-Kona (Hawaii Tribune-Herald, 2013). |
| How long it’s been there | The hotel and first golf course opened in 1996, the year of the first home sale (Hualālai Resort). | Club open since 2003. | The newest of the three. |
| Golf | A Jack Nicklaus Signature course, plus Keʻolu, a members-only Tom Weiskopf design (Hualālai Club). | An 18-hole championship course designed by Tom Fazio. | A Rees Jones course with six holes on the ocean. |
| The club | A membership program since 2002. | A private club with a strict vetting process. | In 2016, only members and their guests were allowed inside. |
| Public beach access | The county lists a white sand beach at the Four Seasons, with limited parking passes at the resort gate (County of Hawaiʻi). | Kikaua Point Park, with limited parking passes at the Kūkiʻo entrance. | Kohanaiki Beach Park, a county park with camping and lifeguards (County Parks). |
| Short-term rentals | Some villas are rented to visitors through the resort. | Not allowed. | Set by its own declaration and club rules. |
| Home prices | About $5 million to $40 million on my rough price map. | The most expensive homes of the six resorts, in my view. | No current range I can confirm. Start from its own recorded sales. |
| Club price and dues | Set by each club in its own papers, and not published by any neutral source. Ask for current terms in writing. | ||
The detail that decides your purchase sits in each community’s papers, and it can change. Each community also has its own page: Hualālai, Kūkiʻo and Kohanaiki.
What are you actually buying when you buy at Hualālai, Kūkiʻo or Kohanaiki?
When you buy at Hualālai, Kūkiʻo or Kohanaiki, you’re buying a home and a place in its owners’ association. Most likely, you’re also buying a club membership on separate papers. How a club membership works covers the price to join and the dues, plus what to ask, and reading the association’s papers covers the rest.
I couldn’t find a current price to join or a dues figure for any of the three clubs from a neutral source. Treat those numbers as unknowns until the club gives them to you in writing.
How each community is set up also shapes your daily life. A hotel brings guests into Hualālai every day. Kūkiʻo and Kohanaiki keep most visitors out, though both still give the public a way to their beaches. Here’s what the county lists:
- Hualālai: public shoreline access at the Four Seasons, with limited parking passes at the resort’s gate. It’s open sunrise to sunset (County of Hawaiʻi).
- Kūkiʻo: Kikaua Point Park, a white sand beach, with limited parking passes at the Kūkiʻo entrance (County of Hawaiʻi).
- Kohanaiki: Kohanaiki Beach Park, a county beach park with camping and restrooms. Lifeguards staff it seven days a week (County Parks).
So in all three, you’ll share the shoreline with the public. A coastal trail also runs from Kona Village Resort to Kikaua Point Park, with parking along the way at the Four Seasons. If you’re picturing a beach of your own, walk it first on a weekend.
How do the clubs and access rules differ at Hualālai, Kūkiʻo and Kohanaiki?
The clubs and access rules differ at Hualālai, Kūkiʻo and Kohanaiki in who can come and go, and in how hard the club is to join. Here’s what each one shows publicly.
Hualālai
Hualālai’s homes sit around a hotel and a club. The Four Seasons opened there in 1996, along with the island’s first Jack Nicklaus Signature course and the first home sale. The Hualālai Club membership program began in 2002, and its members-only Keʻolu course was finished in 2004 (Hualālai Resort).
The club’s own page calls Keʻolu a private, members-only Tom Weiskopf design (Hualālai Club). Its site also points anyone booking a stay to the hotel or to villas the resort rents out. So you’ll share parts of the resort with hotel guests and renters. Other parts are kept for members.
Kūkiʻo
Kūkiʻo is the one of the three where I’ve said the club vets everyone who wants in. Its club has been open since 2003, and its clubhouse sits inside an 18-hole course designed by Tom Fazio (Star-Advertiser, 2016). It doesn’t allow short-term rentals. I’ve covered that, and the club’s vetting, on how private communities like Kūkiʻo sell.
In my videos, I’ve said the most expensive homes of the six resorts land in Kūkiʻo. I won’t print a number for them, because I can’t point you to a public source for one. If you’re shopping there, ask for the community’s own recent sales.
Kohanaiki
Kohanaiki’s golf course was designed by Rees Jones, with six holes on the ocean. In 2016, only members and their guests were allowed inside the community (Star-Advertiser, 2016).
The beach stays public. In 2013, the developer was handing the county a 38-acre coastal park with 121 parking spaces (Hawaii Tribune-Herald, 2013). The county now runs Kohanaiki Beach Park on this coast (County Parks).
Which buyer fits Hualālai, Kūkiʻo or Kohanaiki best?
The buyer who fits Hualālai, Kūkiʻo or Kohanaiki best is the one whose plans match that community’s rules. Start with how you’ll use the home, then check it against each one:
- Hualālai is right for you if: You want a full resort around you, with a hotel and a club, and two golf courses. It may also suit you if you’d like the option of renting a villa through the resort. Look elsewhere if you want the quietest gate on the coast, because a hotel brings guests.
- Kūkiʻo is right for you if: Privacy matters most, and you’ll never rent the home. Look elsewhere if you need rental income, or if a club approval would hold up your timeline.
- Kohanaiki is right for you if: You want a newer home and a club built to be the center of your week. Look elsewhere if you want many years of resale history to judge prices by, since it’s the newest of the three.
If renting is part of your plan, check the rules for that exact home first. A community’s rules sit on top of the county’s, and a home’s rental eligibility is worth checking before you pay for it. How a home would perform as a rental is a question for a property manager who works in that community.
And be honest about how often you’ll be here. A club with dues you’ll pay all year makes the most sense when you’ll use it.
How do Hualālai, Kūkiʻo and Kohanaiki compare on price and resale?
Hualālai, Kūkiʻo and Kohanaiki compare on price and resale only through each community’s own sales, because the public reports don’t break them out. Title Guaranty’s island report gives medians for whole districts, which mix resort homes with ordinary ones. So a district median won’t tell you what a home inside any of these gates is worth.
Here’s what does shape price and resale in these three:
- How long the community has been selling homes. Hualālai’s first home sale was in 1996, and by 2016 it had sold 193 villas and 181 lots or homes (Hualālai Resort). That’s a long record to compare against. Kohanaiki, the newest, has fewer years of sales behind it.
- How many buyers can buy there. At this level, a buyer there must want the club and its rules, along with the home. A stricter club means a smaller pool.
- What the club costs a buyer. A new owner’s price to join and dues are part of what they’ll pay, so they shape what they’ll offer for the home.
- Where the home sits. Whether it’s on the ocean, and whether there’s sand or rock at the water, moves price. So does the view. That’s why similar homes here can be priced millions apart.
To test whether a community holds its premium, compare several years of its sales with similar homes outside its gates. That method is laid out on whether an equity community makes sense as an investment. Run it for each community on your list before you decide.
How should you choose between Hualālai, Kūkiʻo and Kohanaiki?
To choose between Hualālai, Kūkiʻo and Kohanaiki, decide how you’ll use the home, then get each community’s papers and sales and compare them in writing. Work through it in this order:
- Write down how many weeks a year you’ll be here, and whether you’ll ever rent the home.
- Cross off any community whose rental rules don’t fit that plan.
- Ask each club for its current price to join and dues, plus any wait and its approval steps.
- Get each community’s declaration, plus its budget and reserve study, with any recent special assessments.
- Ask for several years of sales inside each community, in the price range you’re considering.
- Visit each one, and ask how guests get in, so you see the access rules for yourself.
- Have your attorney read the club papers and the association papers together.
Plan your visit for the time of year you’d actually use the home. Walk the beach, eat at the club if you’re allowed in as a guest, and drive to the airport and to town at the hours you’d make those trips. A community can feel very different on a busy holiday week than on a quiet weekday.
Then put the three side by side with your own numbers in them. The full buying process is in the Big Island luxury buyer’s guide, and the investment view is in the investment guide.
If you’d like to talk through which of the three fits you, call me on my cell at 808-987-3306. I’ll pick up.