Long read
Fee simple, leasehold, lava zones and equity clubs: the Big Island due diligence nobody explains
The land, the lava zone, the water and the club can change what a Big Island home costs you to own, and each one can be checked before your contract lets you walk away.
The short version
Four checks catch mainland buyers off guard here: whether you'll own the land, which lava zone the home sits in, where the water comes from, and what the club and association require. The listing photos won't show you any of them. Each one ends in a document you can get and read inside your contract's review periods. Do them before you fall in love with a house, or at least before your deposit is at risk.
Key takeaways
- Four checks: the land, the lava zone, the water and the club each end in a document you can get and read before you're committed.
- Leasehold isn't a deal breaker: judge the lease by its years left, its rent ahead and its surrender clause, with a Hawaiʻi attorney.
- Do the lease math: a loan Fannie Mae buys needs the lease to run at least five years past the loan, so a 30-year loan needs 35 years left.
- Read the lava map for what it is: USGS ranks relative hazard by neighborhood, from Zone 1 to Zone 9, and the map isn't drawn for single lots.
- Let the quote decide: in Zones 1 and 2, the state-created insurer may be the only source of a new policy, so get its price in writing.
- Ask who keeps the water safe: on catchment or a well, no agency checks it for you, and even county water can come with limits.
- Treat the club as its own purchase: its papers set the price to join, the dues and what happens to the membership when you sell.
In this guide
- Which four checks catch mainland buyers off guard on the Big Island?
- What do you actually own when a Big Island home is leasehold?
- How many years should be left on a Big Island lease before you buy?
- What does a Big Island lava zone tell you about a home, and what can’t the map show?
- Why can the insurance quote matter more than a Big Island home’s lava zone number?
- Where does a Big Island home’s water come from, and who keeps the water safe?
- What are you buying into when a Big Island home comes with a club and an association?
- When should you run the four checks on a Big Island home you love?
Which four checks catch mainland buyers off guard on the Big Island?
The four checks that catch mainland buyers off guard on the Big Island are the land, the lava zone, the water and the club. Each one is a question you’ll want answered before you’re committed. Will you own the land under the home, or lease it? What’s the home’s lava hazard zone, and what does that do to insurance? Who keeps the water safe? And if there’s a club, what’s in its papers?
The land
Fee simple means you own the land outright. Leasehold means the land stays with its owner, and you hold the home and the land under a lease that ends on a fixed date.
The lava zone
A USGS map ranks long-term lava hazard from Zone 1 to Zone 9. The zone shapes who will insure the home and at what price.
The water
Some homes are on county water. Others rely on a rain tank or a private well, and then keeping the water safe is up to you.
The club and the association
An association comes with owning the home. A club membership is its own agreement, and it’s priced and transferred by the club.
The listing photos won’t show you any of these. They can still show up in the price. Two Kohala Coast homes that look alike can sit millions apart. Whether you own the land is one reason, and the community the home is in is another, as why similar Kohala Coast homes differ in price lays out.
Each check ends in a document you can get and read. Here’s where each answer lives, and who can help you make sense of it.
| The check | Where the answer lives | Who helps you read it |
|---|---|---|
| The land | The recorded lease and the state’s standard lease summary | A Hawaiʻi real estate attorney. |
| The lava zone | The USGS hazard map, looked up by address, and a written insurance quote | An insurance agent. |
| The water | County notices, catchment test results or a well’s state permits | Your inspector and the water supplier. |
| The club and association | The club’s membership papers and the association’s governing and money papers | Your attorney. |
What do you actually own when a Big Island home is leasehold?
When a Big Island home is leasehold, you own the right to use the home and the land until the lease ends, and you pay lease rent to the landowner along the way. The landowner, who’s called the lessor, keeps the land. At closing you usually get an assignment of the lease, which works much like a deed but conveys only what the lease gives you.
Fee simple is simpler. You own the land and the home outright, and you don’t pay lease rent. Hawaiʻi’s rules require a leasehold property advertised for sale to say leasehold, so the listing is the first place to look.
For a leasehold house lot, Hawaiʻi law requires a standard summary of the lease. It covers how long the lease runs, the rent, when the rent reopens, how new rent is worked out and what you’d surrender at the end (HRS §516-71). What to look for in each line is on which Big Island leases to avoid. When the lease ends, the property can go back to the landowner without compensation, so read the surrender clause with your attorney.
Whether you could ever buy the land depends on what kind of leasehold it is:
- A leasehold condo: the state’s leasehold disclosure for condominiums says no law requires the landowner to sell.
- A leasehold house lot: Hawaiʻi’s land reform law is still on the books. It lets the state’s housing corporation acquire the landowner’s interest in residential house lots by eminent domain, after a public hearing, if the corporation finds it serves the law’s purpose. That can happen once 25 or more lessees in a tract, or the lessees of more than half its lots, apply, whichever is fewer (HRS §516-22).
The house-lot law has limits. It covers lots of two acres or less, zoned residential and used, or allowed to be used, as the main home of one or two families. The lots have to sit in a subdivided tract of at least five acres (HRS §516-1).
Neither rule’s a promise that you’ll get the land. Before you buy, find out if the landowner’s willing to sell and at what price, and ask your attorney whether the house-lot law could reach yours.
Leasehold isn’t a reason to walk away on its own. A lease with plenty of years left and rent you can plan for can be a reasonable buy, if you judge it as hard as you judge the house.
“So really check it out and talk with a professional who knows the business.”
Dan Polimino
How many years should be left on a Big Island lease before you buy?
A Big Island lease should have enough years left to cover how long you’ll own the home, what your lender requires, and what the next buyer’s lender will require. The lender’s rule is easy to miss, because it quietly sets how many years a lease needs.
Here’s how that rule plays out over the years you’ll own the home. Say you plan to keep it for 15 years, and you’ll take a 30-year loan. You need 35 years on the lease to get the loan at all. Fifteen years later, your buyer may want a 30-year loan too, and the lease will need 35 years left on that day. So a 15-year plan really needs about 50 years left today.
| Your plan | Years the lease needs today |
|---|---|
| A 15-year loan, under the five-year rule | 20. |
| A 30-year loan, under the same rule | 35. |
| Own 15 years on a 30-year loan, then sell to a buyer who also takes a 30-year loan | About 50. |
The rule doesn’t stop at the years. Lease rent that’s come due has to be paid, and the lease can’t be in default. You have to be able to sell, mortgage and sublease the lease freely, or for a reasonable fee and paperwork, with no credit check on whoever takes it over. Jumbo lenders write their own rules, so ask yours how it treats leasehold before you rely on a loan on a Big Island home.
If the home is a house lot of two acres or less, plan your 10 days before the lease arrives. Line up your attorney, ask the seller for every amendment along with the lease, and leave yourself time to cancel if the numbers don’t work.
What does a Big Island lava zone tell you about a home, and what can’t the map show?
A Big Island lava zone tells you the relative long-term lava hazard for a neighborhood, on a USGS scale from Zone 1, the most hazardous, to Zone 9, the least. It won’t tell you what the hazard is for one lot. USGS drew the zones from where past eruptions started and how often lava has covered the land. It says they show relative hazard, and they don’t measure it in numbers (USGS Hawaiian Volcano Observatory).
| Zone | Where it is |
|---|---|
| 1 | Kīlauea’s and Mauna Loa’s summits and rift zones. |
| 2 | Next to and downslope of Zone 1. |
| 3 | Farther from recent vents, or shielded by the land. |
| 4 | All of Hualālai, the volcano above Kailua-Kona. |
| 5 to 8 | Parts of Kīlauea and Mauna Loa protected by the land, and Mauna Kea. |
| 9 | Kohala Volcano, which last erupted more than 60,000 years ago. |
The map is from 1992, and USGS still calls it accurate, because a volcano’s basic behavior doesn’t change over a few decades. It also says what the map can’t do. It wasn’t drawn to identify single parcels. Its boundaries work at the neighborhood level, and the change from one zone to the next happens over about half a mile, or a quarter mile around Zone 1.
The 2018 eruption showed why the low numbers matter. Kīlauea’s lower East Rift Zone eruption began in Zone 1 and reached areas in both Zones 1 and 2. It destroyed more than 700 structures, USGS reported (USGS Volcano Watch). In Leilani Estates, an eruption started inside the subdivision and right next to it.
So look up the zone for the exact address, then check how close the home sits to a boundary. The steps, including the state’s digital map, are on what a lava zone means for a buyer.
Why can the insurance quote matter more than a Big Island home’s lava zone number?
The insurance quote can matter more than the lava zone number, because the quote turns the map’s long-term hazard into a yearly cost you can budget for. Two homes close together can sit on opposite sides of a zone line. What decides whether you can live with that is what it costs to cover the home, and whether you can get the coverage you’d want.
In the two riskiest zones, the choices narrow.
In 2023 the state’s Insurance Division said that once private insurers had pulled back, the Hawaii Property Insurance Association, or HPIA, was the one source of new coverage for homes in Zones 1 and 2. A state law created HPIA so that owners in areas private insurers avoid could still buy property coverage. The division also said HPIA’s rates rose after the 2014 and 2018 lava events, mostly because its own reinsurance cost more.
- Get the quote in writing: give an agent the exact address, and find out which zone that insurer will apply.
- Ask what’s covered: each policy treats lava differently, and the state has said heat from a flow that starts a fire may be covered as a fire peril.
- Price a full year: put the yearly premium next to the price, the dues and the property tax.
- Check before you commit: get the quote while your contract still lets you walk away.
- Ask about today: the 2023 statements describe that year’s market, so ask an agent what’s available for this address now.
A higher-numbered zone still deserves a quote. You’ll want a real number in front of you, even when you expect it to be ordinary. And if you’re buying land to build on, look up the zone before you price the build, since the insurance for the finished home follows the same map.
A Zone 1 or 2 home can still be the right buy for you. Make that call with a written quote in your hand, which is why the quote comes before the offer.
Where does a Big Island home’s water come from, and who keeps the water safe?
A Big Island home’s water comes from county service, a rainwater catchment tank or a private well, and the source decides who keeps it safe. On county water, the county runs the system. On catchment or a well, no government agency checks the water for you, so the job is yours or whoever you hire.
| Water source | Who keeps it safe | What to ask the seller for |
|---|---|---|
| County water | The County of Hawaiʻi’s Department of Water Supply, which runs 23 systems around the island | Who sends the bill, and any notices for the area. |
| Rainwater catchment | You. The state Department of Health doesn’t regulate catchment on individual homes | Cleaning records and a recent screening test. |
| Private well | You, under state permits from the Commission on Water Resource Management | The state well number, its permits and the completion report. |
County water can come with limits too.
On October 26, 2026, the Department of Water Supply issued a water restriction for Kawaihae, Hāpuna Beach Resort, Mauna Kea Resort, Puakō and Mauna Lani Resort, because of ongoing repairs to its wells. Customers there must cut their water use by at least a quarter, and irrigation customers by at least half. As of November 13, 2026, the department’s notice said the restriction stays in place until further notice (Department of Water Supply).
That’s worth knowing if you’re picturing big gardens on the Kohala Coast. Ask the seller how the yard has held up since the cutback started.
Catchment asks more of you. The Department of Health recommends a well-built system, regular cleaning of the roof, gutters, tank and filters, and a screening test taken after any treatment, such as at the kitchen tap. It also tells catchment users to take extra care when volcanic activity picks up. Moving a catchment home onto county water depends on whether the department can serve that address, and a new connection comes with fees.
The full checklist for each source is on water on the Big Island. Have the water setup looked at along with the rest of your inspections, and add its yearly upkeep to what the home will cost you to own.
What are you buying into when a Big Island home comes with a club and an association?
When a Big Island home comes with a club and an association, you’re buying into two separate sets of papers. One is the association you join by owning the home. The other is a club membership that the club prices and governs itself, at resorts with equity clubs such as Hualālai, Kūkiʻo and Kohanaiki.
The club’s a separate agreement even when it’s sold with the home, and its own papers decide who can join and on what terms. At Kūkiʻo, joining the club means a strict vetting process. The community doesn’t allow short-term rentals either, and that’s a reminder that a community’s own rules can be stricter than county law (how private communities work).
- The price to join: a club may call it a membership contribution, a deposit or an initiation fee. Get the current figure in writing, because the club sets it.
- Dues and assessments: ask how often the dues have gone up, and whether the club can assess members for a shortfall or major repairs.
- The transfer: ask whether the seller’s membership passes to you or goes back to the club, who keeps any refund, and how long approval takes.
- The papers: the state’s disclosure law names the association’s papers a seller must provide, and says nothing about a club. Ask for the club’s papers yourself.
One Mauna Lani club’s 2003 letter to the SEC shows how much the terms can matter. When a member resigned, the club repaid 80% of its current price, but only after the membership went to someone new, and buyers were told not to treat a membership as an investment. Those were one club’s terms more than 20 years ago. The current ones at your club are what count, and they’re covered in equity club memberships.
The association papers come on their own clock. Under a recorded declaration, they’re due within 10 calendar days after both sides receive a current title report. You then have 15 days to read them and decide.
That packet holds the governing papers, which means the declaration and bylaws plus any rules. Ask separately for the budget, the reserve study and the board’s minutes. Read the governing papers first and the money papers second. A condo association has to base its reserves on a study and collect at least half of what the study calls for. Planned communities have no such minimum, so read the reserve figures closely.
When should you run the four checks on a Big Island home you love?
Run the four checks on a Big Island home you love as early as each document allows. Look up the lava zone and the water source before you offer, and read the lease, the club and the association papers inside your review periods. Done in that order, you’ll know what you’re buying while you can still change your mind.
-
Before you offer
Look up the home’s lava zone, and don’t offer until you’ve got a written insurance quote. Ask the seller where the water comes from. Check the listing for the word leasehold, and ask whether a club comes with the home.
-
The day the offer is accepted
Ask for the recorded lease if there’s one, and the club’s membership papers. Book the inspectors, since a Big Island home usually needs more than one. Hawaiʻi wants every cesspool upgraded, converted or connected to a sewer by 2050, unless the state grants an exemption. So find out what handles the wastewater (inspections that matter here).
-
Inside the review periods
Read the lease within its 10 days, and the association papers within their 15. Have your attorney read the lease and the club papers with you.
-
Before the last period ends
Put the lease rent, the insurance premium, the dues and the water upkeep into one yearly number. Then decide whether the home still works at the price.
A low price on a home you love deserves a reason. It might be a short lease, an expensive insurance quote, a water source you’d rather not manage or club dues that just went up. Any of those can still be a fine buy. The point is to know which one it is before your deposit is at risk.
The rest of the purchase, from your money and your team to signing from home, is in the Big Island buyer’s guide.
The Bottom Line
Do the four checks really change what a Big Island home is worth to you?
The four checks can change what a Big Island home is worth to you, even when they don't change the asking price. A lease decides how long the home is yours and what the land costs you each year. A lava zone decides who will insure the home and at what premium. The water source decides who keeps the water safe, and a club decides what you pay to belong.
Every one of those answers is in a document you're able to get and read. Get them early, read them with the right person, and put the yearly costs next to the price before you commit.
Know who owns the land, what the lava zone costs to insure, who keeps the water safe and what the club's papers say before your deposit is at risk.
Sources
- Hawaii Revised Statutes §516-71, Residential lease; disclosure (Hawaii State Legislature)
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide B2-3-03, Special Property Eligibility and Underwriting Considerations: Leasehold Estates (August 5, 2026)
- USGS Hawaiian Volcano Observatory, Frequently Asked Questions and Answers about Lava-Flow Hazards
- USGS Hawaiian Volcano Observatory, Volcano Watch: The 2018 eruption of Kīlauea was big on a global scale (March 31, 2022)
- County of Hawaiʻi Department of Water Supply, South Kohala Essential Use Only Notice Cancelled, Water Restriction Notice Issued (October 26, 2026)
- Hawaii Revised Statutes §516-22, Designation of leased fee interest in all or part of development tract for acquisition (Hawaii State Legislature)
- Hawaii Revised Statutes §516-1, Definitions (Hawaii State Legislature)
Regulatory information changes. Hawaiʻi County rules, state tax law, and federal withholding requirements described here reflect the last-reviewed date above; confirm current requirements with the relevant agency or your advisor before acting.
This guide is general information, not legal, tax, or investment advice. Talk to your attorney, CPA, or advisor about your specific situation.
More questions about this
How can I tell whether a Big Island listing is leasehold?
You can tell whether a Big Island listing is leasehold from the listing itself, because Hawaiʻi's rules require a leasehold property advertised for sale to be identified with the word leasehold. Then ask for the recorded lease and the standard lease summary, and have a Hawaiʻi real estate attorney read them before your review period ends.
What happens to a Big Island leasehold home when the lease runs out?
When the lease on a Big Island leasehold home runs out, the property can go back to the landowner, and a surrender clause can mean you give it up without compensation. The state's standard lease summary marks the surrender clause yes or none. For condos, the state's disclosure says no law requires the landowner to sell. For house lots, HRS §516-22 can let the state acquire the land in some cases. Ask your attorney before you buy.
Is the 1992 Big Island lava zone map still accurate?
USGS's current Big Island lava zone map dates from 1992, and USGS says it's still accurate. The reason it gives is that a Hawaiian volcano's basic behavior doesn't change over short periods. The map describes hazard over decades to centuries, at the neighborhood level.
Does a home in lava Zone 9 on the Big Island have no lava hazard at all?
A home in lava Zone 9 on the Big Island has the lowest relative hazard on the USGS scale, which isn't the same as none. Zone 9 is Kohala Volcano, which last erupted more than 60,000 years ago. USGS says the zones rank hazard against each other and aren't meant to judge one site.
Who tests the water in a Big Island catchment tank?
You do, or whoever you hire, because no state agency regulates catchment systems on individual Big Island homes. The state Department of Health recommends regular cleaning and a screening test, and it runs a lead and copper testing program for catchment users at $25 plus shipping. Ask the seller for recent test results before you buy.
Can a Big Island resort club turn down a home buyer?
A Big Island resort club can set its own terms for who joins, because membership is a separate agreement from the home. At Kūkiʻo, joining the club means a strict vetting process. In one Mauna Lani club's 2003 terms, a seller's membership moved to the buyer only once the buyer was approved and paid the club's current price.
Do the four due diligence checks replace a home inspection on the Big Island?
The four due diligence checks don't replace a home inspection on the Big Island. You still need a general inspection by an inspector you hire, a termite inspection by a licensed pest control operator and a look at whatever handles the wastewater. Book those the day your offer is accepted, so the reports arrive while you can act on them.