Buying and Selling in Kohanaiki: The Market, Honestly

Kohanaiki is the newest of the Kona-Kohala resorts, a private club community where most homes are recent, building is still going on and the club is the center of daily life.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Buying and selling in Kohanaiki, honestly, means knowing a young private club market on 450 oceanfront acres of the Kona coast, developed by Kennedy Wilson. Sales opened in 2013 with 75 ocean and golf view lots, most homes are recent, and building is still going on. The club sits at the center of daily life.

What is the Kohanaiki real estate market, and how did it come to be?

The Kohanaiki real estate market is a young private club community on the Kona coast, and it came to be slowly, over almost 30 years. Its developer, Kennedy Wilson, describes 450 oceanfront acres with 1.5 miles of beachfront (Kennedy Wilson). The developer’s own timeline goes like this:

  • 1997: Kennedy Wilson first buys the land
  • 2004: the project gets its approvals
  • 2011: Kennedy Wilson rejoins the project, after earlier owners spent about $300 million on zoning, engineering, approvals and building
  • 2013: sales open on 75 lots with ocean and golf views
  • 2016: the $65 million, 67,000-square-foot clubhouse is finished
  • 2019: Kennedy Wilson becomes the sole developer

The plan calls for up to 400 homes, including 75 custom homesites from half an acre to more than an acre. In 2016, Bloomberg counted about 80 homeowners and reported a cap of 383 families (Star-Advertiser, 2016).

It’s still being built. The developer has announced a new neighborhood, Hale Ka Hala, Aloha State Daily reported in September 2026. It has 24 five-bedroom townhomes in a first phase and 12 more to follow (Aloha State Daily, 2026). So the mix runs from attached homes to custom homes on large homesites.

Kohanaiki sits in the North Kona district, south of Hualālai and Kūkiʻo. Kennedy Wilson has been the sole developer since 2019, so one company still decides what gets built next.

Next to its neighbors, Kohanaiki is young. It’s the newest of the six resorts, and most of its homes are relatively new. The club, built around a Rees Jones golf course, is the center of the place. It’s also one of my favorite places.

Who buys in Kohanaiki, and who should look elsewhere?

Who buys in Kohanaiki: people who want a newer home inside a club that’s built to fill their week, and you should look elsewhere if you want a finished, settled neighborhood.

This community is right for you if

  • You want a home built in the last decade or so, or a homesite to build on
  • You’ll use the club, from the golf course to the bowling alley
  • You like a private gate, since in 2016 only members and their guests were allowed inside

You should probably look elsewhere if

  • You don’t want building going on near you for the next few years
  • You want many years of resale history to judge prices by
  • You need rental income before you’ve read its own rental rules

If you’re buying from outside the US, you can own here, with some extra steps when you buy and sell (buying as a foreign buyer).

What do homes in Kohanaiki cost, and what does the money buy?

Homes in Kohanaiki ran from about $3 million to $22.5 million in 2016, the last price range I can source, and the money buys new construction inside a private club. Bloomberg put about $3 million on a three-bedroom attached home on the golf course and $22.5 million on a five-bedroom custom estate (Star-Advertiser, 2016). That range is ten years old, so use it for the shape of the market and get today’s prices from recorded sales.

For scale, the median single-family sale across North Kona in October 2026 was $1.0 million, on 32 sales (Title Guaranty). That district number mixes Kohanaiki with very different homes, so it won’t tell you a price here.

The 2016 range shows how the ladder works. You start with attached homes on the golf course and move up to custom homes on large homesites. At the top, you’re paying for the view and where the lot sits. Where that sits against the rest of the island is on my price map.

Recent top sales have made the press, but the figures came from the community’s own sales office, so I won’t print them. I won’t print a current entry price either, because I haven’t found one from a neutral source. Ask for these instead:

  • Recorded sales inside Kohanaiki for the last few years, split into townhomes, homes and homesites
  • The developer’s current prices on new homes, since a resale competes with them

What are you actually buying when you buy in Kohanaiki?

When you buy in Kohanaiki, you’re actually buying a home, a place in its owners’ association and a club membership, each on its own papers. Check each one before you write an offer:

  • The home and its land. Read the title report to see whether it’s fee simple or leasehold.
  • The club. In 2016, Bloomberg reported a club entrance fee and yearly dues on top of the home’s price (Star-Advertiser, 2016). Those were 2016 terms. Ask the club for today’s price, dues and transfer rules in writing.
  • The association. Its declaration, rules and budget set what you can build and what you’ll pay, so go through them with your attorney.
  • Rentals. Kohanaiki’s own declaration and club rules decide whether a home can rent, and I haven’t found them in public (rental rules here).
  • The seller’s papers. Hawaiʻi law has the seller hand you the association’s governing papers, then gives you a window to review them.
  • What’s next door. Since building isn’t finished, ask what’s planned on the lots around the one you like.

How has Kohanaiki performed as an investment, and what holds value there?

Kohanaiki has a short record as an investment, since sales opened in 2013 with 75 ocean and golf view lots, so what holds value there is still being proven. Even island-wide, there’s no public index for luxury homes alone. Here’s what the public record shows:

  • Price history. The 2016 range is the only dated price picture I can source, so on its own it can’t show appreciation. Ask for each home’s past recorded sales.
  • Supply. Up to 400 homes are planned, and the developer has announced more townhomes (Aloha State Daily, 2026). While the developer is still selling new homes, a resale competes with them. No new phase can copy your exact view and lot, though, and that’s the part of value I’d lean on.
  • The club. Count the price to join and the dues as costs against any gain.
  • A short record. About 13 years of sales is a short window, so hold any projection you’re shown to an investment’s test.

Whether a home can rent here is set by Kohanaiki’s own papers, on top of the county’s eligibility checks. Don’t pay extra for rental use until both say yes.

To see whether Kohanaiki holds a premium, line its resales up against similar North Kona homes outside it, using the equity community math. To weigh Kohanaiki against its neighbors, read Hualālai, Kūkiʻo and Kohanaiki compared.

How do you sell a home in Kohanaiki, and what should a seller expect?

You sell a home in Kohanaiki by pricing it from sales inside the community and reaching the buyers who want its club. Expect to compete with the developer’s own new homes. Here’s what shapes the sale:

  • Price. Start from recorded sales inside Kohanaiki. We follow resort closings month by month, and that’s where a fair price begins.
  • The competition. Know what new homes the developer is offering and at what price, since your buyer will see them too.
  • Reach. Your buyer has to want the club and its rules as well as the home, so plan the marketing around reaching private-community buyers.
  • Time. Nobody publishes how long Kohanaiki homes take to sell. The island’s pace and its season are on how long a luxury sale takes.
  • Papers. Pull the association’s governing papers together before you list. Your buyer gets a set window to review them once there’s a title report.
  • Costs. Budget for the conveyance tax, and HARPTA withholding if you’re a nonresident seller. Your membership follows the club’s rules, so ask before you list.

What is daily life like for owners in Kohanaiki?

Daily life for owners in Kohanaiki centers on the club. The developer lists a Rees Jones golf course, a restaurant, a spa, a beach club and a clubhouse with a four-lane bowling alley and a 21-seat movie theater (Kennedy Wilson). In 2016, Bloomberg also described a garden where residents pick fruit and a master brewer on staff. Its golf course has six holes on the ocean, weaving between cultural sites and lava flows (Star-Advertiser, 2016).

The shoreline along here is shared. Kohanaiki Beach Park, on the same stretch of coast, is a county beach park in North Kona, with camping, restrooms and county lifeguards seven days a week (County of Hawaiʻi).

The west side’s drier weather is part of why the resorts sit on this side. Lava zones are set by location, so look up the zone for your address.

Current listings in Buying and Selling in Kohanaiki: The Market, Honestly

Get notified when a Buying and Selling in Kohanaiki: The Market, Honestly property comes to market. Talk to Dan.

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields