What’s a lava zone, and should it actually stop me from buying a Big Island home I love?

A lava zone is the USGS rating of long-term lava hazard, and it should stop you from buying a Big Island home you love only if insuring that home doesn't fit your budget or plans. The zones run from 1, the most hazardous, to 9, the least. Zones 1 and 2 are the hardest to insure.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • Nine zones: the USGS map ranks the island from Zone 1, the most hazardous, to Zone 9, the least.
  • It's a long-term map: the zones describe lava hazard over the next decades to centuries and longer.
  • Hualālai is all Zone 4: lava has covered about 5 percent of the volcano near Kailua-Kona since 1800, and USGS still considers it likely to erupt again.
  • Check the exact address: USGS says the map works at the neighborhood level but not for a single property.
  • Zones 1 and 2 are the hard ones to insure: in 2023 the state's Insurance Division called the private market there not good.

What do the Big Island’s lava zones mean?

The Big Island’s lava zones mean how likely each area is to be covered by lava over the long term (USGS lava-flow hazard zone map). Zone 1 is the most hazardous and Zone 9 the least. The zones are based on where vents have erupted, how much land lava has covered, and the shape of the land.

Zone Where What the map says
1 The summits and rift zones of Kīlauea and Mauna Loa Vents there have erupted again and again in historical time
2 Next to and downslope of Zone 1 15 to 25 percent covered by lava since 1800
3 Farther from recent vents, or shielded by the land 1 to 5 percent covered since 1800
4 All of Hualālai, the volcano near Kailua-Kona About 5 percent covered since 1800
5 and 6 Parts of Kīlauea and Mauna Loa Protected by the shape of the land
7 and 8 Mauna Kea 20 percent of Zone 7 covered in the past 10,000 years, and a few percent of Zone 8
9 Kohala Volcano Last erupted over 60,000 years ago

A lower number means a higher hazard, so Zone 3 is more hazardous than Zone 4 (USGS Hawaiian Volcano Observatory). So look up the zone for the home’s exact address before you go any further.

How do I find the lava zone for a specific Big Island home?

To find the lava zone for a specific Big Island home, look up its address on a digital map of the zones, then see how close it sits to a zone boundary. USGS says the paper map was never meant to identify single parcels (USGS Hawaiian Volcano Observatory). Take these steps:

  1. Type the address into the Hawaiʻi Statewide GIS Program’s lava zone map, or open the observatory’s Google Earth file of the zones
  2. Note how close the home is to a boundary, since USGS says boundaries are about a half mile wide, or a quarter mile around Zone 1
  3. Send the address to an insurance agent, and ask which zone the insurer will use
  4. Get the quote in writing before you’re committed to the purchase

If you’re shopping for land rather than a finished home, look up the zone before you price the build.

Who insures homes in lava zones 1 and 2 on the Big Island?

Homes in lava zones 1 and 2 on the Big Island can get new insurance only from the Hawaii Property Insurance Association, or HPIA, once private insurers have left (Insurance Division, 2023). Here’s what the division told a town hall in August 2023:

  • HPIA was created by state law to keep property insurance available in hard-to-write areas
  • Insurers and HPIA rely on the USGS map to identify the riskiest areas, and the division accepts lava zones in setting rates
  • The private market in Zones 1 and 2 isn’t good, because insurers there believe premiums can’t cover the risk of loss
  • Across Hawaiʻi, the homeowners insurance market as a whole is good

Those are 2023 statements, so ask an agent what’s available for the address today.

When should a lava zone change my decision on a Big Island home?

A lava zone should change your decision on a Big Island home when the insurance the zone requires doesn’t fit your budget or your plans. Weigh these before you decide:

  • The home’s zone, and how close it is to a boundary
  • A full year of coverage, from a written quote
  • How long you plan to own it, since the map describes hazard over decades to centuries
  • Whether the coverage on offer is the kind you’d want if the worst happened

Then put the zone alongside the rest of your checks, including where the home’s water comes from and the inspections every purchase needs.

Sources

  1. U.S. Geological Survey, Map Showing Lava-Flow Hazard Zones, Island of Hawaii (Miscellaneous Field Studies Map MF-2193, 1992)
  2. USGS Hawaiian Volcano Observatory, Frequently Asked Questions and Answers about Lava-Flow Hazards
  3. Hawaiʻi Insurance Division (Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs), Homeowners Insurance town hall presentation, August 23, 2023

Frequently asked questions

Is the Big Island lava zone map out of date?

The Big Island lava zone map isn't out of date, according to USGS, even though it was published in 1992. USGS says the basic behavior of Hawaiian volcanoes doesn't change over short periods, and the map describes lava hazard over the next decades to centuries and longer.

Is a lava zone the same as the risk to my Big Island home?

A lava zone isn't the same as the risk to your Big Island home. USGS defines a hazard as something with the potential to cause harm, and risk as how likely the hazard is to happen and how bad the harm would be. The map shows relative hazard for general planning, and it isn't precise enough to judge the danger at a single site.

Does homeowners insurance cover lava damage on the Big Island?

Whether homeowners insurance covers lava damage on the Big Island depends on the policy. The state's Insurance Division said in a 2018 FAQ that each insurer's policy is different. It also said that if a lava flow's heat starts a fire that damages a home, that damage may be covered as a fire peril. Ask the agent to show you in writing how the policy treats lava.

Why has insurance gotten more expensive in Big Island lava zones?

Insurance has gotten more expensive in Big Island lava zones, at least from HPIA, mainly because reinsurance, the insurance an insurer buys for itself, cost it more after the 2014 and 2018 lava events. The state's Insurance Division gave that reason in 2023 for HPIA's increases, along with continued lava activity in Zones 1 and 2 and higher losses than HPIA expected.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields