What’s different about buying in Hawaii that’s going to surprise a mainland buyer?

What surprises a mainland buyer most about buying in Hawaiʻi is what a home costs to keep up and what it takes to remodel one. Upkeep runs higher here, and a fixer-upper can turn into a long, costly project. Land leases and lava zones can surprise you too. So can the water supply and club dues.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • Upkeep costs more here: buyers tend to underestimate what yard care and repairs cost in Hawaiʻi.
  • Prices start higher: Hawaiʻi's overall price level was 10% above the national level in 2024, second only to California's.
  • Fixer-uppers cost more here: a remodel takes more money and time than most buyers expect.
  • Move-in ready is the safer buy: a home that's done lets you start enjoying it right away.
  • Check what comes with the land: ask about leasehold and lava zones before you make an offer.

“This is not the mainland and this is an entirely different animal.”

Dan Polimino

Why does a Big Island home cost more to keep up than mainland buyers expect?

A Big Island home costs more to keep up than mainland buyers expect because skilled help is in short supply here. Prices across Hawaiʻi run higher too: only California’s overall price level was higher in 2024 (BEA).

In my experience, these are the costs buyers underestimate:

  • Landscaping and yard care
  • Pool service
  • Repairs of every size

Price a year of upkeep before you make an offer, using the steps below. For how owning here compares with owning on the mainland, see the Big Island against mainland luxury markets.

Is a fixer-upper a smart buy on the Big Island?

A fixer-upper is rarely a smart buy on the Big Island, because remodeling here costs more and takes longer than most buyers plan for. The same labor shortage that makes big remodels so costly here hits a buyer’s project too.

What a remodel here can take

  • Any building permits the work needs, and the county’s review time
  • A licensed contractor with room in their schedule
  • Your own time and attention, which is hard to give from the mainland

What to look for instead

Look for a home that’s move-in ready and doesn’t need a lot of work. If the location is the reason you’re tempted, price the work before you fall for the house.

What else about buying a Big Island home surprises mainland buyers?

Land leases, lava zones, the water source, club memberships, association rules, property tax and rental rules are the other things about buying a Big Island home that surprise mainland buyers. Ask about each one before you make an offer:

Ask this Then read
Will I own the land, or lease it? Fee simple or leasehold
Which lava hazard zone is it in? What a lava zone means
Does the water come from the county? If not, where? Water on the Big Island
Is a club membership part of the deal? Equity club memberships
What do the association’s papers say about dues and rules? Reading the HOA papers
What will the property tax be once it’s mine? Property taxes for out-of-state buyers
Will I ever want to rent it to guests? Rental eligibility and price

If you’re not a Hawaiʻi resident when you sell, part of the price is usually held back at closing and credited against your Hawaiʻi tax. It’s one of the things mainland sellers don’t expect.

How do I check a Big Island home’s upkeep costs before I make an offer?

To check a Big Island home’s upkeep costs before you make an offer, start with the seller’s bills. Then get your own numbers, in this order:

  1. Ask the seller for last year’s bills for the yard and the pool
  2. Ask what repairs the home has needed lately
  3. Ask who does that work now, and whether they’d keep going for you
  4. Have your inspector point out repairs that are overdue
  5. Get quotes for anything you’d fix or change in the first year
  6. Add the dues and property tax to your insurance quote for a yearly total

Your inspector works for you and should tell you whether you’re buying a money pit of expensive repairs (CFPB).

Sources

  1. U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, Real Personal Consumption Expenditures by State and Real Personal Income by State, 2024 (news release, February 19, 2026)
  2. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Your Home Loan Toolkit (2026)

Frequently asked questions

What does move-in ready mean for a Big Island home?

Move-in ready, for a Big Island home, means it's pretty much done. It doesn't need a lot of work before you can live in it and enjoy it. Confirm that with your own inspection before you rely on it.

Should I buy a Big Island home that needs work if I love the location?

Buying a Big Island home that needs work can make sense if the location is rare and you have the time and budget for the project. Get a contractor's estimate and schedule for the work before your inspection period ends. If the plan only works with a quick, cheap remodel, keep looking.

Should I set money aside for repairs after buying a Big Island home?

Yes. Set money aside for repairs from your first year in a Big Island home. The CFPB's homebuyer guide says to budget and save for maintenance and repairs on top of your mortgage payment. Here, plan for that budget to run higher than you're used to.

Is Hawaiʻi more expensive than other states?

Hawaiʻi is more expensive than almost every other state. In 2024 its overall price level was 110.0, against 100 for the nation, and only California's was higher, at 110.7. Housing rents often drive those gaps, so get local quotes on the costs that matter to you.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields