Fee simple vs. leasehold on the Big Island: what am I actually buying, and which should I avoid?

With fee simple on the Big Island, you're buying the land and the home outright. With leasehold, you're buying the right to use them until the lease ends, and you'll pay lease rent. Neither is one to avoid automatically. Judge a leasehold by the years left, the rent ahead, the surrender terms and whether a lender will finance it.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • Know the next rent reset: on a leasehold house lot, the state's lease summary lists each lease rent amount and the date it runs until.
  • The seller hands over the lease: for a leasehold house lot, it's due within 10 calendar days of the accepted contract.
  • The summary covers the key terms: it also lists the length, the renegotiation dates, how new rent is set and any surrender clause.
  • You can walk away: for a leasehold house lot, state law lets the buyer cancel within 10 calendar days of acknowledging receipt, with no loss of deposit.
  • Lenders count the years: Fannie Mae requires the lease to run at least five years past the loan's final payment.

Should I avoid buying a leasehold home on the Big Island?

You don’t have to avoid buying a leasehold home on the Big Island. Judge the lease as carefully as you judge the house. If the basics are new to you, start with how fee simple and leasehold differ. Then take a hard look at any lease that shows these signs:

  • The years left don’t cover how long you plan to own the home
  • A lease rent renegotiation is coming up, and you don’t know how the new rent will be set
  • The lease summary marks a surrender clause, and nobody has walked you through it
  • Too few years are left for a lender to finance it, for you or for a future buyer

A lease that clears all four can still be a reasonable buy. Whether it’s right for you comes down to your plans, your lender and your attorney.

What should I check in a Big Island lease before I buy?

Before you buy, check five lease terms: the lease length, the lease rent, the renegotiation dates, how new rent is set and any surrender clause. Hawaiʻi’s standard lease summary for house lots lists all five (HRS §516-71). Here’s what to look for in each:

What to check What to look for
Lease length The expiration date, and how many years that leaves you
Lease rent Each amount, and the date each one runs until
Renegotiation dates When the rent is next reopened
How new rent is set A formula or arbitration in the lease, a rule set by law, or an agreement between the two sides
Surrender clause Marked yes or none, and what you’d hand back at the end

Then read the full lease. The state’s own form says the summary is only a summary, and that a buyer should read the lease for the detail (HRS §516-73).

How long do I get to review the lease when I buy a leasehold house lot in Hawaiʻi?

When you buy a leasehold house lot in Hawaiʻi, you get 10 calendar days to review the lease once the seller delivers it (HRS §516-71). The seller has 10 calendar days from the accepted contract to deliver it. The law covers a residential lot of two acres or less, zoned for residential use. Use the time in this order:

  1. Get the recorded lease and every amendment from the seller
  2. Read the standardized summary, then the full lease
  3. Have a Hawaiʻi real estate attorney review both
  4. Accept the lease, or cancel within 10 days of acknowledging receipt, with no loss of deposit

The buyer and seller can agree on a standard form to shorten or extend these periods. If you’re buying any other kind of leasehold, such as a condo, ask your attorney what review period your contract gives you. If the home is in an association, its papers are a separate review, covered in how to read association documents.

Can I get a mortgage on a leasehold home on the Big Island?

You can get a mortgage on a leasehold home on the Big Island when the lease meets the lender’s rules, and the first rule is time. For a loan Fannie Mae buys, the lease has to run at least five years past the loan’s maturity date (Fannie Mae Selling Guide). Fannie Mae also requires that:

  • The lease can be sold, mortgaged and subleased an unlimited number of times, with no credit review of the new party
  • The lender is told of any default within 30 days, and has the right to step in
  • All lease rent that’s due has been paid

So a 30-year loan needs at least 35 years left on the lease. Ask your lender whether it follows these rules, especially on a larger loan, and read how out-of-state buyers finance here.

Sources

  1. Hawaiʻi Revised Statutes §516-71, Residential lease; disclosure
  2. Hawaiʻi Revised Statutes §516-73, Suggested form of standardized summary of lease provisions
  3. Fannie Mae Selling Guide B2-3-03, Special Property Eligibility and Underwriting Considerations: Leasehold Estates

Frequently asked questions

What do I get at closing when I buy a leasehold home in Hawaiʻi?

At closing on a leasehold home in Hawaiʻi, you normally get an assignment of lease. The state's standard lease summary says its purpose is similar to a deed's. The difference is that it conveys only the rights and obligations the lease creates, and not the property itself.

What does a surrender clause mean in a Hawaiʻi lease?

A surrender clause in a Hawaiʻi lease spells out what you hand back to the landowner when the lease ends. The state's standard summary has a line for it, marked yes or none. Where it's yes, the summary warns you may have to give up the property and the land without compensation, so read that clause with your attorney.

Should I hire an attorney to buy a leasehold home in Hawaiʻi?

Hiring an attorney to buy a leasehold home in Hawaiʻi is what the state's own lease summary points you to. It says a buyer with legal questions about leasehold property, the lease or its consequences should get an attorney's advice. Line up a Hawaiʻi real estate attorney before you make an offer.

Can a company buying a leasehold house lot in Hawaiʻi waive the lease review?

A company buying a leasehold house lot in Hawaiʻi can waive the state's lease disclosure and review requirements in writing, because the law lets any buyer that isn't a natural person do so. If you're buying through an entity, read anything you're asked to sign, and ask your attorney before you give up the review period.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields