The home I want has been sitting for months. Does that mean something’s wrong, or that I have leverage?
The home you want has been sitting for months, and that may mean something's wrong with it or nothing at all. Either way, a long wait can give you leverage, meaning room to negotiate. Check its listing and price history before you offer, then use the disclosures, your inspection and any association papers to decide before you're committed.
Key takeaways
- The reason beats the count: why a home sat tells you more than how many days it sat.
- Read the history: each price cut, and how long the home sat at each price, says something about the home or the seller.
- The papers come after: the seller's disclosures and the association's records are due once the seller accepts your offer.
- Ask about past contracts: a sale that fell through can point to a problem, or to nothing about the home at all.
- Match the offer to the reason: a pricing problem, a repair and a costly association each call for a different offer.
Does a Big Island home that’s been sitting for months have something wrong with it?
A Big Island home that’s been sitting for months may or may not have something wrong with it, because homes here sit for several reasons. Often it’s simply a price above what buyers will pay, which is the seller’s side of pricing. A few months also isn’t unusual here, since the typical Big Island home is taking about three months to sell.
Other reasons a home can sit:
- A problem with its condition, known or not yet found
- Association dues, or a coming assessment, that put buyers off
- A high-risk flood area, where a government-backed mortgage requires flood insurance, or a high-hazard lava zone
- A contract that fell through, which can leave buyers wondering why
Ask your agent which of these fits this home before you go further.
How can I find out why a Big Island home has been sitting?
You can find out why a Big Island home has been sitting by checking its history before you offer, then reading its paperwork before you’re committed.
Before you offer
- Ask your agent for the full listing history, with every price change and any time the home came off the market
- Ask the listing agent whether a contract fell through and why. Ask too whether any disclosures are already available
- Look up the home on FEMA’s flood maps. In communities that take part in the National Flood Insurance Program, flood insurance is mandatory in high-risk A and V zones if your mortgage is government-backed (FloodSmart). Ask your lender whether it requires flood insurance
- Check its lava hazard zone
After the seller accepts
- The seller’s disclosure statement and any association papers arrive on the schedule in how long a Big Island purchase takes
- Read the association’s budget, reserves and minutes with the guide to reading HOA documents
- Read the preliminary title report too, for anything recorded against the home
- Get your inspection done before you’re finally committed to buy the home, as the CFPB advises (CFPB)
What does a Big Island home’s long time on the market mean for my offer?
A Big Island home’s long time on the market means your offer should answer the reason it sat, and that reason decides how much room you have. Match your offer to what you found:
| What you found | What it can mean | How to shape your offer |
|---|---|---|
| Several price cuts and nothing else wrong | The price started too high | Show the seller the recent sales your offer is based on |
| A problem in the disclosures or the inspection | A repair the price doesn’t reflect | Get a contractor’s estimate, and use it in your offer or in a repair request during your inspection period |
| High dues or a coming assessment | A cost buyers have been pricing in | Add the cost to your budget before you set your number |
| A high-risk flood area | Flood insurance may be required, and FloodSmart strongly recommends it either way | Get an insurance quote before you offer |
| Nothing at all | The right buyer hasn’t come along yet | Offer what the home is worth to you, and don’t count on a big discount |
Sources
Frequently asked questions
Why would a Big Island home go back on the market after being under contract?
A Big Island home can go back on the market after being under contract for several reasons. The buyer's loan may have fallen through, the inspection may have turned up a problem, or the appraisal may have come in low. Sometimes the buyer's own plans changed, which says nothing about the home. Ask the listing agent which it was, then check it yourself.
Does a price cut mean a Big Island seller will take a lower offer?
A price cut shows a Big Island seller is listening to buyers, though it can't tell you how much lower they'll go. Some sellers cut once and then hold. Ask how long the home has been at its current price, and what the seller's timing is.
Is a vacant Big Island home that's been listed for months riskier to buy?
A vacant Big Island home that's been listed for months can carry a little more risk, because nobody's living there to notice a slow leak or pests. Ask who has been checking on it and how often. Then make sure your inspection looks closely for water damage and pests.
Will the listing agent tell me about past offers on a Big Island home?
The listing agent on a Big Island home may tell you a little about past offers, or nothing at all, since they work for the seller. It's still worth asking whether any offers came in and why they didn't work. Your own agent can ask in a way that doesn't tip your hand.