Is everything negotiable on a Big Island luxury home, or are sellers here firm on price?
Almost everything is negotiable on a Big Island luxury home, including the furnishings, repairs, credits and dates, and how firm sellers here are on price depends on the home. A seller has the least reason to bend on price when the home is new to the market, priced in line with recent sales and drawing interest.
Key takeaways
- Price is one line of many: furnishings, repairs, credits and dates can all be part of the deal.
- Furniture needs a list: write every item that comes with the home into the contract.
- Credits have limits: loan rules can cap how much a seller pays toward your closing costs.
- Repairs can become credits: after the inspection, you can ask the seller to fix a problem or pay toward it.
- Write in the dates: the closing date and the day you get the keys both belong in the contract.
Do Big Island luxury home sellers negotiate on price?
Big Island luxury home sellers do negotiate on price, though how far they’ll move depends on the home and how long it’s been listed. Island-wide, with every price range mixed together, recent Big Island sales closed a few percent below asking, as Big Island sale-to-list figures show. The island’s report doesn’t split these figures by price, so ask for recent sales at your price in the community you want.
When a seller is likely to hold firm
- The seller isn’t in a hurry and can wait for the right buyer
- The home is new to the market, or its price has never been cut
- It’s priced in line with recent sales
Competition matters too, since a seller has less reason to bend when buyers compete for a home. A home that’s been on the market for months may leave more room, depending on why it sat. Ask the listing agent whether other offers are in, and how long the home has been at this price.
What can I negotiate on a Big Island luxury home besides the price?
You can negotiate furnishings, other items, repairs, credits and dates on a Big Island luxury home besides the price, and each one belongs in the written offer.
| What you can negotiate | What it covers | How to put it in the offer |
|---|---|---|
| Furnishings | Furniture and art | Attach a signed inventory list to the contract |
| Other items | Things like a golf cart | Name each item, since it isn’t part of the house itself |
| Repairs | Problems your inspection turns up | Ask the seller to fix them, or for a credit |
| Credits | Money toward your closing costs | State the dollar amount, and check your lender’s limit |
| Dates | When the sale closes and when you get the keys | Write both dates into the contract |
After the inspection, the seller may or may not agree to pay for repairs, depending on your contract and the market (CFPB). If the home comes with a club, check how the membership transfers before you count on it. In a softer market, a buyer can ask for more of these.
What limits apply to furniture and credits from a Big Island seller?
The limits that apply to furniture and credits from a Big Island seller come from your loan, if you’re financing. Under Fannie Mae’s rules, what a seller can put toward your costs is capped by how much you borrow against the home’s value (Fannie Mae Selling Guide):
| How you’ll use the home | Loan as a share of the home’s value | Most the seller can put toward your costs |
|---|---|---|
| Primary or second home | More than 90% | 3% |
| Primary or second home | 75.01% to 90% | 6% |
| Primary or second home | 75% or less | 9% |
| Investment property | Any | 2% |
The percentage is figured on the lower of the price or the appraised value, and the credit can’t be more than your closing costs. Furniture from the seller counts as a sales concession, and its value comes off the price used for your loan. These rules cover loans Fannie Mae can buy. If yours is a jumbo loan, ask your lender what it allows. If you’re paying cash, none of these loan limits apply.
How do I negotiate extras into a Big Island luxury home offer?
You negotiate extras into a Big Island luxury home offer by deciding what you want before you write it, then putting each item in the contract. Take these steps:
- Ask for the seller’s inventory of furnishings, or walk the home and make one
- Mark what you want to keep and what you’d rather the seller take
- Ask your lender how furniture and credits will affect your loan
- Write each item and credit into the offer, with a dollar amount beside it
- Return to repairs and credits once the inspection report is in
Your closing costs are part of the math too, and the list of what a buyer pays at closing here shows where a credit would go.
Sources
Frequently asked questions
Can I negotiate who pays the closing fees on a Big Island home?
You can negotiate who pays the closing fees on a Big Island home, though local custom sets the starting point. If your loan follows Fannie Mae's rules, fees a seller pays under local custom don't count against the limit on seller credits. Ask for a title company's fee schedule, which shows the split most sales start from, before you ask for more.
Can a Big Island seller pay my HOA dues as part of the deal?
A Big Island seller can pay part of your HOA dues as part of the deal, within your loan's rules. Under Fannie Mae's rules, a seller's contribution can cover up to 12 months of association dues after closing, inside the same overall limit as other credits. Ask your lender before you write it into the offer.
Should I ask for a lower price or a credit on a Big Island home?
Whether to ask for a lower price or a credit on a Big Island home depends on what you need. A lower price lowers what you borrow. A credit lowers the cash you bring to closing, within your loan's limits. Ask your lender which one helps you more.
Does asking for a lot of extras weaken an offer on a Big Island home?
Asking for a lot of extras can weaken an offer on a Big Island home, especially when other buyers are interested. Each request is one more thing the seller has to agree to. Ask for what matters most to you, and leave the rest out.