Should I buy a Big Island investment property in an LLC or a trust, and does it matter for an out-of-state owner?

Whether you should buy a Big Island investment property in an LLC or a trust is a call for your attorney and CPA, and it does matter for an out-of-state owner. Hawaiʻi treats an out-of-state LLC owning rental property here as doing business. A home in your own name can need a Hawaiʻi court step after your death.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • An out-of-state LLC registers here: Hawaiʻi law counts owning income-producing real estate as doing business in the state.
  • Your own name can mean a court filing: heirs may need a Hawaiʻi court step to transfer the home, even if your estate is settled elsewhere.
  • Standard loans favor people and trusts: Fannie Mae buys loans made to individuals and revocable trusts, and LLCs aren't on its list.
  • The transfer tax treats them differently: a move into your own revocable living trust is exempt, and a move into an LLC may not be.
  • A federal cash-purchase report is on hold: as of October 31, 2026, a court has vacated FinCEN's rule, and the government has appealed.

What does an LLC do for an out-of-state owner of a Big Island property?

An LLC can keep the company’s debts apart from an out-of-state owner’s own, and one formed outside Hawaiʻi needs the state’s certificate of authority once it owns a Big Island rental. Under Hawaiʻi’s LLC law, a company’s debts are its own. A member isn’t liable just for being a member. For an LLC formed elsewhere, that state’s law decides it (HRS chapter 428).

  • Owning income-producing real estate here counts as doing business in Hawaiʻi (§428-1003)
  • To get the state’s certificate of authority, the LLC applies with proof from its home state that it exists, dated within 60 days (§428-1002)
  • Once it’s registered, it keeps an agent with a Hawaiʻi business address and files a report each year (§428-107 and §428-210)

Your attorney can tell you what an LLC would and wouldn’t protect you from. If you’re investing from outside the US, read what’s different for a foreign investor as well.

Does Big Island real estate in an out-of-state owner’s own name need a Hawaiʻi probate?

Big Island real estate in an out-of-state owner’s own name can need a Hawaiʻi probate, or at least a filing with a Hawaiʻi court, before it passes to heirs. Here’s what Hawaiʻi’s probate code says (HRS chapter 560):

  • A probate here: if the owner didn’t live in Hawaiʻi, it can be opened in any court circuit where the owner had property (§560:3-201)
  • Your home state’s representative: the person named to settle your estate where you lived can file official copies of that appointment with a court in the circuit where the home is. Then they can act for the estate here (§560:4-204 and §560:4-205)
  • The small-estate affidavit: it’s for personal property only, and only when the estate in Hawaiʻi is worth $100,000 or less (§560:3-1201)

A revocable living trust and a transfer on death deed under HRS chapter 527 are two other ways to hold or pass title. Ask your attorney whether either one would spare your heirs the Hawaiʻi court step.

How do an LLC and a trust compare for a Big Island loan, title insurance and the transfer tax?

For a Big Island loan, a revocable trust qualifies with Fannie Mae and an LLC doesn’t, and for the transfer tax, a move into your own revocable living trust is exempt. Title insurance after a transfer depends on your policy.

Question LLC Revocable trust
A loan Fannie Mae will buy It isn’t on the list of borrowers Fannie Mae accepts It’s allowed, as an exception to the rule that borrowers be people (Fannie Mae)
Moving the home in after you buy The state’s exemption form counts an LLC interest and debt relief as payment, so the tax can apply (Form P-64B) It’s exempt when you move the home into your own revocable living trust (HRS §247-3)
Title insurance after a later move The 2021 standard owner’s policy keeps covering a company you wholly own The same policy keeps covering a trust you create for estate planning

That’s the American Land Title Association’s 2021 standard form, and your title company may use another, so ask before you transfer. Hawaiʻi’s transfer tax is the conveyance tax, explained in the costs mainland sellers don’t expect. If you’ll pay cash in a trust or an LLC and want a loan later, see Fannie Mae’s delayed financing rule.

Does a federal report apply when an LLC or trust pays cash for a Big Island home?

FinCEN’s federal report for an LLC or trust that pays cash for a Big Island home doesn’t apply right now, because a court vacated the rule that required it. The government has appealed. As of October 31, 2026, FinCEN’s page shows this (FinCEN):

  • The rule was written for homes for one to four families, condos and land the buyer plans to build one on. It covers purchases by an entity or a trust without a loan from a lender with anti-money-laundering duties
  • Reports were due on sales closing on or after March 1, 2026
  • On March 19, 2026, the US District Court for the Eastern District of Texas vacated it
  • FinCEN and the Department of Justice have appealed, and while the order stands, no report is required

It’s still on appeal, so ask your attorney or escrow company to check the rule before you close.

How should an out-of-state owner choose between an LLC and a trust for a Big Island property?

An out-of-state owner should choose between an LLC and a trust for a Big Island property with an attorney and a CPA, and before signing a purchase contract.

  1. Ask your attorney what an LLC would protect you from, under the law of the state where it’s formed
  2. Check which way of holding title your lender will lend to, before you write an offer
  3. Find out from your attorney how the home would pass to your heirs each way
  4. Have your CPA compare how each choice would be taxed wherever you’ll file
  5. Decide before you sign, so you won’t have to move the home later

Sources

  1. Hawaiʻi Revised Statutes chapter 428, Uniform Limited Liability Company Act (sections 428-107, 428-210, 428-303 and 428-1001 to 428-1008)
  2. Hawaiʻi Revised Statutes chapter 560, Uniform Probate Code (sections 560:3-201, 560:3-1201, 560:4-204 and 560:4-205)
  3. Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), Residential Real Estate Rule (status alert and FAQs)

Frequently asked questions

What happens if an out-of-state LLC owns Big Island rental property without registering?

An out-of-state LLC that owns Big Island rental property without registering can't bring a lawsuit in a Hawaiʻi court until it's registered, under Hawaiʻi's LLC law. It'll owe the fees and penalties it would have paid. Its contracts stay valid, and it can still defend itself in court.

How does the IRS tax a one-owner LLC that holds a Big Island property?

The IRS taxes a one-owner LLC that holds a Big Island property as part of its owner's return, unless the LLC files Form 8832 to be taxed as a corporation. If you're the owner, its activity generally goes on your own return. It's still treated as separate for employment taxes and certain excise taxes.

Can a transfer on death deed pass a Big Island home to my heirs?

A transfer on death deed can pass a Big Island home to the beneficiaries you name, under Hawaiʻi's transfer on death law, HRS chapter 527. It has to be recorded before your death, and you can revoke it with another recorded document. It doesn't change your rights in the home while you're alive. Land court property needs an extra petition, so ask your attorney whether it fits your plan.

Is moving a Big Island home from my revocable trust back to me taxed?

Moving a Big Island home from your revocable living trust back to you, as the trust's beneficiary, isn't subject to Hawaiʻi's conveyance tax, under HRS §247-3. The move into the trust is exempt too. Either way, you'll claim the exemption on the state's Form P-64B, which goes with the deed for recording.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields