I’m doing a 1031 exchange into Hawaii. What should I know about landing it on the Big Island?
If you're doing a 1031 exchange into Hawaiʻi, landing it on the Big Island means meeting the replacement rules: naming homes on time, reinvesting the cash and replacing the debt. You name possible homes in writing within 45 days. Cash you keep, or debt that isn't replaced, can be taxed. Your home state may keep tracking the gain too.
Key takeaways
- Name your choices in writing: the IRS lets you name three homes, or more under its 200% or 95% rule.
- Keep the cash in the exchange: money you keep, and anything that isn't real estate, can be taxed up to your gain.
- Replace the debt: a mortgage paid off at your sale counts like cash you received unless new debt or your own cash offsets it.
- You can buy first: in a reverse exchange, a titleholder holds one of the properties while you finish the trade within 180 days.
- California keeps count: if you sold California property, you file Form FTB 3840 every year until that gain is taxed.
How many Big Island homes can I name as replacements in a 1031 exchange?
You can name up to three Big Island homes as replacements in a 1031 exchange, or more under the 200% or 95% rule. The limits come from Treasury Regulation §1.1031(k)-1(c)(4), which the IRS explains in Publication 544:
| Rule | How many homes you can name | The condition |
|---|---|---|
| Three-property rule | Up to three | None, whatever their value |
| 200% rule | Any number | Their total value can’t be more than twice the value of what you sold |
| 95% rule | More than the first two rules allow | By the deadline, you buy named property worth at least 95% of the total you named |
Name each home in a signed document, using its street address or legal description. Send it by day 45 to the intermediary or the seller, never to your own agent. You can cancel a name the same way before day 45. After that, you can only buy property on your list.
What do I need to reinvest in a Big Island home to defer all of the gain?
To defer all of the gain, you need to reinvest all the exchange cash in the Big Island home and replace any debt paid off on what you sold. Whatever comes back to you in another form can be taxed, up to your gain (Publication 544). Watch for these:
- Cash you keep: exchange money that’s paid to you instead of going into the home
- Debt relief: a mortgage paid off at your sale counts as cash you received, unless a mortgage on the new home or cash you add offsets it
- Anything that isn’t real estate: furniture that comes with a home isn’t like-kind property
If the home you’re buying comes furnished, ask your CPA how the furniture will be counted before you sign. Ask how your new loan will offset the old one, too.
How do I buy a Big Island home inside a 1031 exchange’s deadlines?
To buy a Big Island home inside a 1031 exchange’s deadlines, assign the purchase contract to your intermediary and close by day 180. If the due date of your tax return for the year you sold comes sooner, close by then. That due date counts any extension (Publication 544).
- Tell your intermediary you’re writing an offer, before you sign it
- Sign the purchase contract, then assign your rights in it to the intermediary
- Notify the seller and every other party to the contract of the assignment in writing, by closing day (Publication 544)
- Pick a closing date your lender and the seller can both meet inside your exchange deadline, using what sets a Big Island purchase timeline
- At closing, the intermediary pays with the exchange money, and the deed comes straight to you
The 45-day and 180-day clocks, the intermediary’s role and the rule for a vacation home you also use are covered in how a 1031 exchange works when you sell.
Can I buy the Big Island home before I sell my mainland property?
You can buy the Big Island home before you sell your mainland property through a reverse exchange, under the IRS safe harbor in Revenue Procedure 2000-37, as changed in 2004. An exchange accommodation titleholder, someone who isn’t you or a disqualified person such as your agent or a close family member, holds title to one of the properties while you finish the trade. If it holds the Big Island home, the safe harbor’s main conditions are:
- You and the titleholder sign a written agreement within five business days after it takes title
- You name the property you’ll sell within 45 days
- The titleholder’s part is done within 180 days, and it can’t hold the two properties more than 180 days in total
- You can’t have owned the Big Island home in the 180 days before the titleholder took it (Publication 544)
The titleholder can lease the home to you while it holds title.
Will my home state and Hawaiʻi tax the gain after a 1031 exchange into the Big Island?
Hawaiʻi taxes the gain when you later sell the Big Island home in a taxable sale after a 1031 exchange into the Big Island, and your home state may too. California tracks its share every year until then.
- California
- If you sold California property, you file Form FTB 3840 for the year of the exchange and each year after, until the California gain you deferred is finally taxed. When you sell the Big Island home, you report the California source gain (Franchise Tax Board).
- Other states
- Ask your CPA whether your state has its own rules for an exchange into property outside the state.
- Hawaiʻi
- A nonresident’s gain on a Big Island sale is Hawaiʻi income, covered in capital gains on a Big Island sale. How Hawaiʻi treats the part you deferred from the mainland is a question for your CPA. If you’re not a Hawaiʻi resident then, the buyer withholds 7.25% of the price unless an exemption applies, covered in withholding at a sale.
Ask your CPA how the two states’ returns will fit together before you sell.
Sources
- Internal Revenue Service, Publication 544, Sales and Other Dispositions of Assets (for 2025 returns)
- Internal Revenue Service, Internal Revenue Bulletin 2000-40, Revenue Procedure 2000-37 (qualified exchange accommodation arrangements)
- California Franchise Tax Board, Reporting like-kind exchanges (Form FTB 3840)
Frequently asked questions
Can a Big Island leasehold home be the replacement in a 1031 exchange?
A Big Island leasehold home can be the replacement in a 1031 exchange if the lease runs 30 years or longer, the IRS says. Real estate traded for a lease that long counts as like-kind. A shorter lease may not qualify. Ask your CPA how the years left on the lease are counted before you name it.
Can I build a new Big Island home as the replacement in a 1031 exchange?
You can name a Big Island home that's still being built as the replacement in a 1031 exchange, the IRS says. Only what's built when you receive it counts as like-kind. Building done after that is taxed as an exchange for services. And the land can't already be yours: the IRS says improvements on land you own don't qualify.
Can I add my own money to buy a more expensive Big Island home in a 1031 exchange?
You can add your own money to buy a more expensive Big Island home in a 1031 exchange. The money you add raises your basis in the new home, the IRS says. Basis is the starting point your future gain is measured from. Cash you add can also offset a mortgage that was paid off when you sold.
Can I exchange two mainland rentals into one Big Island home?
You can exchange two mainland rentals into one Big Island home as part of the same exchange. If the two sales close on different days, the IRS starts the 45-day and 180-day clocks on the earliest one. The three-property limit on what you name stays the same, however many properties you sell.