Long read

Big Island real estate as an investment: appreciation, returns and what the asset really does

A Big Island luxury home works as an investment for a buyer who prices every cost, pays only for what the next buyer will want, and can hold through a slow decade.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Last reviewed November 16, 2026 · 15 minute read

The short version

A Big Island luxury home is a slow asset whose lasting value sits in its land and location. Over 25 years the county's home price index rose faster than the nation's, with a fall of about a third along the way, and it trailed stocks by a wide margin. It costs a lot to buy, own and sell. It pays off for a buyer who holds for years, pays a price backed by sales, and settles taxes and title first.

Key takeaways

  • Set the bar first: a home counts as an investment only if it beats what the same money earns elsewhere, after the costs to buy, own and sell.
  • The record is long, with a deep dip: FHFA's Hawaiʻi County index rose 268% from 2000 to 2025, and it lost about a third from 2006 to 2011.
  • Land is the lasting part: the county values land and buildings separately, and only the building wears out.
  • Stocks have done better on price: with dividends counted, the S&P 500 rose 712% between the ends of 2000 and 2025, and a home's use is a return only you can price.
  • A house is simplest to own: condo prices rose faster after 2019, while condo sales fell by more than a third and a board sets key costs.
  • A premium has to come back to you: pay extra for a club or rental eligibility only up to what your eventual buyer would pay.
  • Start with the flat case: a $2.5 million home held 10 years at flat prices loses about $309,500 to property tax and the conveyance tax alone.
  • Settle the structure before the offer: 1031 deadlines, a foreign owner's rent tax and LLC or trust rules all need a CPA and an attorney before you sign.
In this guide
  1. What would a Big Island luxury home have to earn before you could call it an investment?
  2. How have Big Island home prices moved over the long run, and what can the record not tell you?
  3. Where does a Big Island home’s value sit, and which part of it lasts?
  4. How has a Big Island home done against mainland homes and a stock index fund?
  5. Which kind of Big Island property, and which part of the island, works best for an investor?
  6. When is an equity club community or a rental-eligible Big Island home worth paying extra for?
  7. How do rental income and rental rules change what a Big Island home is worth to an investor?
  8. What return should an investor realistically plan on from a $2.5 million Big Island home?
  9. How should an investor test a specific Big Island property before making an offer?
  10. Which tax and title rules should a Big Island investor settle before signing a purchase contract?

What would a Big Island luxury home have to earn before you could call it an investment?

A Big Island luxury home would have to earn more than the same money could earn somewhere else, after every cost of buying, owning and selling it, before you could call it an investment. That’s the whole test, and it’s a hard one here. A home can rise in value and still lose to a plain Treasury note once its costs are counted.

For a safe yardstick, the 10-year US Treasury note yielded 4.98% on November 10, 2026 (FRED). That money needs no upkeep, and it doesn’t need a buyer when you want out. Check the rate on the day you compare, since it moves every trading day.

Costs to buy

Escrow, title insurance and any loan costs, paid once at closing.

Costs to own

Property tax and insurance every year, plus any dues and the upkeep.

Costs to sell

The commission, Hawaiʻi’s conveyance tax and closing fees, paid once when you sell.

You pay the buying and selling costs one time each, so a longer hold spreads them over more years. The owning costs show up every year whether prices go up or down. And if a home you’ve only used yourself sells at a loss, the IRS treats it as personal-use property, so you can’t deduct that loss. Your CPA can tell you how that fits the way you’ll use the home.

A home here can still be a fine buy, and a short self-test for calling a home an investment helps you tell. It asks what your money earns right now, the year you’ll want it back, and the yearly gain the home would need to keep up. Answer all three with real figures before you make an offer.

How have Big Island home prices moved over the long run, and what can the record not tell you?

Big Island home prices have moved up strongly over the long run, with one deep fall along the way, and the record can’t tell you what luxury homes did on their own.

268% rise in FHFA’s Hawaiʻi County home price index, 2000 to 2025.
197% rise in the US index over the same years.
About a third lost by the county index from 2006 to 2011.

Those figures come from the Federal Housing Finance Agency’s indexes, published by the St. Louis Fed (FRED). The county index didn’t pass its 2006 level again until 2021. A buyer at the 2006 peak waited about 15 years to get back to even on price, and that’s before any costs.

The start year you pick changes the story a lot, so it’s worth checking more than one. From 2005 to 2025 the county index rose 74%, while the US index rose 101%. From 2020 to 2025 the county came out ahead again, 58% against 53%.

Title Guaranty’s year-end reports tell a similar story in dollars: the island’s median single-family sale went from $379,000 in 2019 to $550,000 in 2025.

Here’s what that record leaves out.

  • Luxury homes on their own: the county index is calibrated on mortgages that Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac bought or guaranteed, so cash sales aren’t in it, and it can’t show luxury homes separately.
  • The mix of sales: a median is the middle sale of the year, so it moves when the kinds of homes that sold change.
  • The years ahead: UHERO’s September 25, 2026 forecast has Hawaiʻi home prices rising more slowly than inflation for now.

So when you run the numbers on a home here, run them with prices flat and falling as well as rising.

“It just depends on what you're going to use it for.”

Dan Polimino

Where does a Big Island home’s value sit, and which part of it lasts?

A Big Island home’s value sits partly in its land and partly in its building, and of the two, the land is what lasts.

The County of Hawaiʻi values the two separately for property tax. For a house, the county starts the building’s value from today’s cost to build it again, then takes off depreciation for its age. Land gets its value from what land has sold for lately, then the county checks it against the neighborhood, the zone and the size of the lot. The IRS draws the same line: it won’t let owners depreciate land, because land doesn’t wear out.

Part of the value What sets it Over a long hold
The land What buyers pay for that spot: the view, the shore, the neighborhood. Moves with land sales, up or down.
The building What it would cost to build again, less wear. Ages, and needs money to keep its value.

The beach, the view and the setting come with the lot, so the part of the price you pay for them is the part that doesn’t wear out.

Each parcel’s county record shows two figures, one for the land and one for the building. The county says its values are for property tax only. It’s a rough guide, so set your price from sales.

Who’s buying matters too. UHERO counted buyers who gave a home address outside Hawaiʻi on their 2025 deed papers, using Title Guaranty’s data:

  • Single-family homes: out-of-state buyers made 24.9% of the county’s 2,214 transactions.
  • Condos: 49.3% of 615 transactions did.
  • Kailua-Kona: in ZIP code 96740, the share was 34.4% of 401 single-family sales.

In Kailua-Kona that’s about one house buyer in three with an address outside Hawaiʻi, so a resale there depends partly on people from away still wanting to buy here the year you sell.

How has a Big Island home done against mainland homes and a stock index fund?

Since 2000, a Big Island home has kept pace with mainland homes and fallen far behind a stock index fund on price alone, though from 2005 it trailed mainland homes too.

Aswath Damodaran’s figures at NYU Stern put the S&P 500’s gain at 712% with dividends reinvested, from the end of 2000 to the end of 2025. Over 2000 to 2025 the county home index rose 268%. The home index uses yearly levels, so the dates aren’t an exact match, and the gap is still far too wide for that to change the answer.

The long-run research is kinder to housing. In The Rate of Return on Everything, published in 2019, Jordà and four coauthors studied 16 advanced economies from 1870 to 2015. Here’s what they found:

  • Over the whole span, housing and stocks each averaged about 7% a year after inflation.
  • Most of housing’s return came from rent, since price gains on their own came to around 1% a year after inflation.
  • Year to year, housing returns moved around much less than stocks did.
  • Spreading your money across many homes is far harder than spreading it across many stocks.

That second finding matters most if you won’t rent. Then the biggest piece of housing’s return comes to you as the weeks you spend in the home, and only you can put a number on those.

What’s different Owning a Big Island home Owning an S&P 500 index fund
Selling Months to find a buyer, then weeks to close. Any trading day, settled the next business day.
Costs to trade Large, on each purchase and each sale. Small, on each trade.
Yearly costs Property tax, insurance and upkeep. The fund’s yearly fee.
Spread of your money One home on one street. About 500 large US companies.
Use A place to stay. None, though it may pay dividends.

Before you move money out of a fund and into a home here, compare the two over the same years, with dividends counted and every cost of the home taken out. Then ask your financial advisor what share of everything you own belongs in a single property.

Which kind of Big Island property, and which part of the island, works best for an investor?

For most investors, the kind of Big Island property that works best is a single-family home, in a part of the island where homes like it sell often.

A single-family home leaves most decisions and most costs to you. A condo puts a board in charge of the budget, the dues, special assessments, the building’s insurance and the rental rules. UHERO also expects new Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac rules to leave some condo buildings without federally backed loans, and your next buyer may need one.

Land’s a third choice, though a lot won’t pay you back until there’s a county permit and a finished build.

Island-wide, Title Guaranty year-end reports 2019 2025
Condo sales 854 540
Median condo sale $362,750 $640,000
Median single-family sale $379,000 $550,000

Condo prices rose faster, while condo sales fell by more than a third. Most condo sales happen on the west side and the single-family median covers the whole island, so compare the two inside one district.

Where homes like yours sell often matters too. Title Guaranty’s September 2026 report counts 2025 sales by district:

  • Houses: Puna led with 848 single-family sales, then North Kona with 364, South Hilo with 243 and South Kohala with 181.
  • Condos: North Kona had 314 and South Kohala had 172, which is 486 of the island’s 540.
  • The quiet districts: North Hilo had 19 single-family sales all year, and Hāmākua had 46.

More sales mean more recent prices to check yours against, and more buyers when it’s your turn to sell. Where only a few dozen homes sell a year, both run thin. Zoning, the shoreline and how much nearby land can still be built on also shape where an investor should look on the Big Island.

When is an equity club community or a rental-eligible Big Island home worth paying extra for?

An equity club community or a rental-eligible Big Island home is worth paying extra for only up to what your eventual buyer will pay you back for it. You may enjoy the club or never use the eligibility. As an investment, though, the extra price only counts if the next owner’s willing to pay it too.

Equity club communities

At Kūkiʻo, Hualālai or Kohanaiki, the club’s price to join and its yearly dues are costs on top of the home, along with the association’s dues. A smaller pool of buyers shops at that level, and each one has to want the club and its rules as well as the house.

Rental rules differ by community. Kūkiʻo doesn’t allow short-term rentals, and at Kohanaiki the community’s own declaration and club rules decide. To see whether a community holds its premium, compare at least five years of its sales with similar homes outside its gates, slow years included.

Rental eligibility

Rental eligibility follows the same rule. Pay for it only up to the gap you can measure between eligible and ineligible homes that sold nearby. Check whether it comes from the zoning or from a county certificate too, since that decides how the eligibility passes to your buyer.

The rules can change, too. As of November 13, 2026, Bill 147 had passed first reading and was still before the County Council, which amended it on November 6 and set its final vote for November 18, 2026. It’s a separate county bill on where vacation rentals are allowed.

How do rental income and rental rules change what a Big Island home is worth to an investor?

Rental income and rental rules change what a Big Island home is worth to an investor only where buyers pay for the income, and they bring tax and loan rules of their own.

On paper, income turns into value through one division. Take a year’s net operating income, which is the gross income less operating costs and a reserve for big repairs. Then divide it by a capitalization rate, or cap rate.

A made-up example in round numbers: $60,000 of net operating income is worth $1.5 million at a 4% cap rate and $1.2 million at 5%. One point on the rate moves the value by $300,000, with the same income. It doesn’t describe any real Big Island home.

For houses, lenders mostly go by comparable sales, and that’s where the income math runs into trouble. Under Fannie Mae’s rules, an appraiser values a home mainly from similar sales, and an appraisal that rests on income alone isn’t acceptable. Fannie Mae’s June 2024 note to appraisers ruled out taking a nightly rate times 30 as the rent, and it kept a short-term rental’s furniture and business out of the value.

So rental income potential adds value only where buyers will pay for it, and only after you’ve checked the seller’s actual records.

Rental eligibility also brings rules that change your numbers.

  • Income tax: an average stay of seven days or less isn’t a rental activity under the IRS passive loss rules, which changes how losses and income land on your return.
  • Taxes on the rent: on the Big Island, every rent payment carries Hawaiʻi’s 4.5% general excise tax. A guest staying under 180 days adds 11% for the state and 3% for the county.
  • Loans: a condo building run like a hotel, with a rental pool or a hotel license, can’t get loans Fannie Mae will buy, for you or for your buyer.

Have your CPA and your lender look at the property before you price the tax and loan effects of eligibility into an offer. Whether the home would do well as a rental is a separate, operating question, so put it to a property manager who runs rentals in that area.

What return should an investor realistically plan on from a $2.5 million Big Island home?

An investor should realistically plan on a return from a $2.5 million Big Island home that could be small or below zero, since 10 flat years would cost about $309,500 in two taxes alone.

About $309,500 lost over 10 years if prices stay flat.
About $545,000 gained if prices rise 3% a year.
About $764,000 lost if prices fall 2% a year.

Those three results come from one worked example of the return on a Big Island luxury home. They count just two costs: 10 years of county property tax and the conveyance tax when you sell.

The property tax line is $29,450 a year, held at today’s value and rate in all three cases. In the rise and drop cases the real bill would move with the value. It assumes a $2.5 million assessment in the residential class with no home exemption, at the rates for the year ending June 30, 2027. The conveyance tax is 60 cents per $100 of the price, for a buyer who can’t claim the county’s homeowner exemption.

The rates of change are scenarios picked to show the math. They aren’t forecasts. Insurance, dues, upkeep, closing costs, the cost to sell and the tax on any gain all come off on top, and you fill those in for the home you’re weighing.

A loan widens every result. Put $1 million down on the same home with a $1.5 million loan, and a 10% drop in price takes 25% of your cash. A 10% rise gives you 25%, before interest. You get the principal you’ve paid off back as equity at the sale. The interest is gone, so count it as a cost.

Run the flat case on any home you’re weighing first, with its own price, tax class and the years you plan to hold it.

How should an investor test a specific Big Island property before making an offer?

An investor should test a specific Big Island property before making an offer by checking, in order, its purpose, price, cost to hold, legal use, condition, exit and return.

  1. Set your purpose and holding period

    Decide what the property has to do for you and how many years you’ll own it.

  2. Check the price

    Hold it up against what similar homes actually sold for lately.

  3. Add up the yearly cost to hold

    Property tax for your tax class, insurance, any association and club dues, and upkeep.

  4. Confirm the use is legal

    If you’d rent it, check the parcel’s eligibility with the county before you pay for it.

  5. Plan the physical checks

    Check the lava zone and where the water comes from right away, and schedule inspections inside your inspection period.

  6. Estimate the exit

    Work out what you’d net after the costs to sell.

  7. Run the return

    Run the flat case over your holding period, then try prices going up and going down.

Before you offer, gather the county tax record and the most recent assessment notice. Ask the seller for permits on every addition, and get an insurance quote too. If the place is rented today, ask for the owner’s real books, income and expenses both.

If a property fails an early step, you can skip the rest, so take the steps in this order. The title report and the association’s budget usually come after your offer is accepted, so read each one the day it arrives.

Which tax and title rules should a Big Island investor settle before signing a purchase contract?

A Big Island investor should settle the tax and title rules for a 1031 exchange, for a foreign owner’s rent and for holding title in an LLC or a trust before signing a purchase contract. Each one is a question for your CPA and your attorney. I’m explaining the rules here so you’ll know what to ask. It isn’t advice on what you should do.

A 1031 exchange into the island

In a 1031 exchange onto the Big Island, you name possible replacement homes in writing within 45 days. You can name up to three, or more under the 200% or 95% rules. You close by day 180, or by your tax return’s due date if that comes first. You can even buy here first, through a reverse exchange under Revenue Procedure 2000-37. If you sold in California, you’ll file Form FTB 3840 each year until that gain is taxed.

A foreign investor’s rent

For a foreign investor, the US takes 30% of gross rent, or a lower treaty rate, unless you elect to be taxed on net income. That election needs a US taxpayer number and Form W-8ECI. Hawaiʻi adds its own return and a general excise tax license.

An LLC or a trust

An out-of-state LLC that owns a rental here is doing business in Hawaiʻi and needs the state’s certificate of authority. Fannie Mae accepts a revocable trust as the borrower on a loan it buys, and it doesn’t accept an LLC. Moving the home into your own revocable living trust is exempt from the conveyance tax.

Two more rules round this out. If you sell later as a nonresident, the buyer withholds 7.25% of the amount realized, usually the price, for Hawaiʻi unless an exemption applies. If you’re a foreign seller, FIRPTA’s federal withholding generally applies as well.

FinCEN wrote a rule requiring a report when a company or a trust buys a home with cash. A federal court in Texas threw it out on March 19, 2026, and FinCEN and the Justice Department have appealed. Until that order changes, nobody has to file (FinCEN). Have your attorney or escrow company check it again before you close.

The Bottom Line

A Big Island home is a slow, land-backed asset that rewards a patient buyer who paid the right price

A Big Island luxury home is a slow asset. Its lasting value sits in its land and location, and it leans on buyers from away, who made about a quarter of the island's 2025 house purchases. Its county price index rose 268% from 2000 to 2025 and lost about a third from 2006 to 2011, and UHERO's September 2026 forecast for Hawaiʻi expects gains below inflation. It's costly to hold, and it takes months to sell.

So pay a price backed by real sales, run the flat case over the years you plan to hold, and settle your taxes and title with your CPA and attorney before you sign.

Pay a price backed by sales, and buy only if you can hold through a slow decade.

Sources

  1. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Market Yield on U.S. Treasury Securities at 10-Year Constant Maturity (DGS10), via FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis
  2. U.S. Federal Housing Finance Agency, All-Transactions House Price Index for Hawaii County, HI (ATNHPIUS15001A) and for the United States (USSTHPI), via FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis
  3. Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, Residential Real Estate Rule

Regulatory information changes. Hawaiʻi County rules, state tax law, and federal withholding requirements described here reflect the last-reviewed date above; confirm current requirements with the relevant agency or your advisor before acting.

This guide is general information, not legal, tax, or investment advice. Talk to your attorney, CPA, or advisor about your specific situation.

More questions about this

Is Big Island real estate a safe place to keep money I might need soon?

Big Island real estate is a poor place for money you might need soon. FHFA's index for Hawaiʻi County fell about a third from 2006 to 2011 and didn't pass its 2006 level again until 2021. A home here also takes months to sell and costs money every year you hold it. Keep money you may need in the next few years somewhere easier to reach.

Do Big Island luxury homes gain value faster than other homes on the island?

No public index tracks Big Island luxury homes on their own, so there's no neutral figure that settles it. FHFA's county index leaves out cash sales. To judge one community, compare several years of its sales with similar homes nearby, slow years included, and see whether its edge held.

How long should I plan to own a Big Island investment property?

Plan to own a Big Island investment property for years, long enough for any price change to outweigh the one-time costs to buy and sell. Those come once, so a longer hold spreads them out, while the yearly costs keep coming. Set your holding period before you offer, and run the flat case over it.

Can I rent out a Kūkiʻo home to visitors to help cover its costs?

No, you can't rent a Kūkiʻo home to visitors to help cover its costs: Kūkiʻo doesn't allow short-term rentals, so a home there has to make sense without visitor income. Any longer lease follows the community's declaration and club rules, so get those in writing before you count on rent. Other communities set their own rules, and those sit on top of the county's.

Should I count rental income when I decide what to pay for a Big Island home?

Count rental income only if it's proven, legal for that parcel and something buyers in the area pay for. Use the seller's actual records, never a projection. For a loan Fannie Mae can buy, the appraiser values the home mainly from comparable sales, so a price that only works with the rent deserves a second look.

Do I need a CPA and an attorney before buying a Big Island investment property?

A CPA and an attorney are worth bringing in before you sign for a Big Island investment property. A 1031 exchange runs on fixed deadlines. A foreign owner's rent is taxed at 30% of the gross unless an election is made. The way you hold title affects your loan and the conveyance tax. Settling these first keeps the contract and the deadlines right.

Can anyone say where Big Island home prices will go next?

No one can say where Big Island home prices will go next. UHERO's September 25, 2026 forecast has Hawaiʻi home prices rising more slowly than inflation for now. Prices here have risen over the long run, with a deep fall from 2006 to 2011. Plan around a flat case, a rise and a drop.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields