How does a property’s short-term-rental eligibility affect its investment value on the Big Island?

A property's short-term-rental eligibility affects its investment value on the Big Island through income tax, Hawaiʻi's rental taxes, financing and the risk that rules change. Short average stays can change how the IRS treats a rental. And a condo building run like a hotel can't get loans Fannie Mae will buy.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • Short stays change the tax rules: if the average stay is seven days or less, the IRS doesn't treat it as a rental activity under its passive loss rules.
  • Short stays add rental taxes: rent from stays under 180 days owes the state's 11% transient accommodations tax and the county's 3%.
  • Hotel-style condos limit loans: Fannie Mae won't buy loans on units in buildings run like hotels or tied to rental pools, even voluntary ones.
  • A monthly rental still counts: the state and county taxes on short stays reach any stay under 180 days in a row, including a 30-day one.
  • Your own use matters too: stay in the home more than 14 days or 10% of the days it's rented at a fair price, whichever is greater, and other limits apply.

What does short-term rental eligibility change about a Big Island property as an investment?

Short-term rental eligibility changes a Big Island property as an investment through income tax, taxes on the rent, financing, the property tax class and the risk of rule changes.

What changes How
Income tax An average stay of seven days or less takes it out of the IRS’s rental activity rules
Taxes on the rent Rent from stays under 180 days adds the state’s 11% transient accommodations tax (Department of Taxation) and the county’s 3% (County of Hawaiʻi). Both come on top of the general excise tax all rent pays
Financing Condo buildings run like hotels can’t get loans Fannie Mae buys
Property tax class Short-term rental use rules out the homeowner class, under the county’s property tax rules
Rule changes State law lets counties phase out vacation rental uses, the risk weighed in a Big Island phase-out

Two questions come first. Is the rental use legal for that parcel? The rental eligibility checks settle that. What eligibility adds to the price is covered in the eligibility premium.

How does the IRS treat a Big Island rental with short average stays?

The IRS treats a Big Island rental with short average stays, seven days or less, as something other than a rental activity under the passive loss rules. The rule is Treasury Regulation §1.469-1T(e)(3)(ii)(A) (IRS Publication 925).

  • A rental activity: it’s passive even if you work at it, unless you qualify as a real estate professional
  • An average stay of seven days or less: it isn’t a rental activity. The IRS then asks if it’s a business and if you materially participate, with tests such as more than 500 hours a year
  • An average stay of 30 days or less, with significant personal services: it isn’t a rental activity either
  • A passive loss: it generally can’t offset income such as wages, apart from a $25,000 allowance for owners who actively take part in a rental activity, which a stay averaging seven days or less isn’t
  • A home you also use: if you use it more than the greater of 14 days or 10% of the days it’s rented at a fair price, other limits apply (IRS Publication 527)

These rules decide how the property’s losses and income land on your return. Ask your CPA to run them before you buy.

Can a Big Island condo in a building that rents short-term get a loan Fannie Mae will buy?

A Big Island condo in a building that rents short-term can’t get a loan Fannie Mae will buy if the building runs like a hotel. Under Fannie Mae’s rules, any one of these makes the project ineligible:

  • The association has a hotel, motel, resort or similar license
  • The building’s papers require owners to pool their rentals or share the profits
  • Owners can join a rental pool or profit-sharing deal with the association or a management company, even if it’s voluntary
  • A hotel or resort management company runs the project and also handles short-term rentals for owners
  • The papers limit when owners can use their own units
  • The project is mostly short stays, or offers hotel services such as check-in, short-term rentals and daily cleaning

The rule applies to every buyer who wants that kind of loan, including the one you’d sell to. Jumbo lenders set their own rules, so ask each one about the project. For a home you’ll also use, letting a management firm control who stays there rules out a second-home loan, under Fannie Mae’s second-home rules.

How do I count the tax and loan effects of rental eligibility when I value a Big Island property?

To count the tax and loan effects of rental eligibility when you value a Big Island property, confirm the use is legal, then price its taxes, loan limits and rule risk.

  1. Confirm the rental use is legal for the parcel, using the eligibility checks
  2. Ask your CPA how the passive loss rules and the home-use limits would apply to the way you plan to use it
  3. Put Hawaiʻi’s taxes on the rent into your numbers
  4. Have your lender confirm that the property, or its condo project, qualifies for the loan you plan to use
  5. Weigh what a change in the county’s rules would do to the price
  6. Then decide what the income potential is worth, using how rental income adds to value

How the property would actually perform as a rental is an operating question. Ask a property manager who manages rentals in that area.

Sources

  1. Internal Revenue Service, Publication 925, Passive Activity and At-Risk Rules (for 2025 returns)
  2. Internal Revenue Service, Publication 527, Residential Rental Property (for 2025 returns)
  3. Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-2.1-03, Ineligible Projects (topic dated August 5, 2026)

Frequently asked questions

Does Hawaiʻi's rental tax apply to a 30-day Big Island rental?

Hawaiʻi's transient accommodations tax applies to a 30-day Big Island rental, because it covers stays of less than 180 consecutive days. The state rate is 11% from January 1, 2026, and the County of Hawaiʻi adds its own 3%. Ask your CPA how to register and file.

Can I deduct Big Island vacation rental losses against my salary?

Whether you can deduct Big Island vacation rental losses against your salary depends on how the IRS classifies the rental. A rental is passive, but owners who actively take part may deduct up to $25,000 of loss, less at higher incomes. With an average stay of seven days or less, the loss is passive unless you materially participate. Ask your CPA.

Do I report rent from a Big Island home I rent out for less than 15 days a year?

You don't report rent from a Big Island home you also use if you rent it out for less than 15 days in a year, the IRS says. You also can't deduct costs for it as rental expenses. Hawaiʻi's taxes on the rent are a separate question, so ask your CPA about those.

How is the average stay figured for a Big Island rental under the passive loss rules?

The average stay for a Big Island rental is the total days of all rentals divided by the number of rentals that year, the IRS says. If you rent more than one class of property in the same activity, each class counts by its share of the rent.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields