Is a short-term-rental-eligible property worth a premium even if I never plan to rent it?

A short-term-rental-eligible property is worth a premium even if you never plan to rent it only up to what your eventual buyer would pay for it. On the Big Island, eligibility that comes from zoning stays with the land. Eligibility that rests on a county certificate can be lost if the rental use stops for 12 months in a row.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • You'd be buying it to sell: if you never rent, eligibility pays you back only when your buyer pays for it.
  • Zoning travels with the land: the county allows whole-home rentals by zoning district, whoever owns the home.
  • A certificate needs use: the county won't renew one once the rental use has stopped for 12 months in a row.
  • Measure it from sales: compare similar eligible and ineligible homes that sold in the same area.
  • A premium costs you every year: a higher price can mean a higher assessed value and a higher property tax bill.

Why would rental eligibility matter to a Big Island owner who never rents?

Rental eligibility matters to a Big Island owner who never rents only at resale, as a feature the next buyer may or may not pay extra for. Whether it pays you back depends on your buyers, the rules and what the eligibility rests on:

  • Your buyers: it’s worth something to you only if buyers in that area pay more for it
  • The rules: they can change before you sell, as Maui’s move to end some rentals shows
  • What it rests on: zoning and a county certificate pass to a buyer on different terms, covered below

If you might rent after all, ask a property manager who manages rentals in that area how the home would do. That’s an operating question, separate from what you pay.

Does short-term rental eligibility stay with a Big Island property when it sells?

Short-term rental eligibility that comes from the zoning stays with a Big Island property when it sells, since the county allows these rentals by zoning district, whoever owns the home. A nonconforming use certificate isn’t ended by a sale either, but it must be renewed every year (Hawaiʻi County zoning code).

What eligibility rests on At a sale What can end it
Zoning: V, CG and CV districts, residential and commercial zones in the General Plan’s Resort and Resort Node areas, and condos in RM zones Stays with the property A change to the zoning code, or private rules that ban rentals
A nonconforming use certificate Not ended by the sale; the new owner notifies the planning director A missed yearly renewal, or the rental use stopping for 12 months in a row
County registration (Ordinance 25-50) Expires 90 days after the sale The sale, unless the buyer registers

A nonconforming use that stops for 12 months in a row can’t resume, and once the county finds the use has stopped, it must deny the renewal. As of November 13, 2026, Bill 147, up for a final vote on November 18, would repeal and replace sections 25-4-16 and 25-4-16.1, but not the 12-month rule in section 25-4-62. Ask the seller for any certificate and its renewal receipts.

How do I measure the rental eligibility premium on a Big Island property?

To measure the rental eligibility premium on a Big Island property, compare recent sales of similar homes in the same area, some eligible and some not, and look at the gap in price. Go step by step:

  1. Find homes near yours that sold in the last few years, both with and without eligibility
  2. Confirm each one’s status with the county Planning Department, since a listing can be wrong
  3. Set aside any sale that differs from the rest in an obvious way, like a much bigger lot or a better view
  4. Compare what the eligible homes sold for with what the others sold for
  5. Have an appraiser review the gap before you lean on it
  6. Pay no more than that gap, and less if the rules could change before you sell

If you can’t find enough sales of both kinds, you can’t measure the premium. That’s a reason to be careful about paying one.

What does paying a rental eligibility premium cost a Big Island owner each year?

Paying a rental eligibility premium costs a Big Island owner each year in a higher property tax bill and in the money the extra price ties up.

  • Property tax. The county assesses all real property based on fair market value (Real Property Tax Division), so if eligible homes sell for more, your assessment can rise with them. For a second home in the residential class, each extra $100,000 of assessed value adds $1,110 to $1,700 a year for 2026 to 2027, depending on the home’s tier (Resolution 574-26).
  • Money tied up. Paid in cash, the premium is money you can’t invest elsewhere. Borrowed, it adds to your loan and to the interest you pay every year.

Your rate depends on the home’s tax class and tier. Over the years you own the home, those costs are the bar the eligibility has to clear when you sell.

Sources

  1. County of Hawaiʻi, Hawaiʻi County Code Chapter 25, Zoning (sections 25-4-16, 25-4-16.1 and 25-4-62; advance sheet updated August 5, 2026)
  2. Hawaiʻi County Council, Resolution No. 574-26, determining real property tax rates for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2027
  3. County of Hawaiʻi Department of Finance, Real Property Tax Division

Frequently asked questions

Does a nonconforming use certificate pass to me when I buy a Big Island home?

A nonconforming use certificate can stay with a Big Island home when you buy it, since the county zoning code doesn't end it at a sale. The code has the new owner notify the planning director (section 25-4-16(b)(6)). To keep it, the certificate has to be renewed every year, and the rental use can't stop for 12 months in a row. Have the Planning Department confirm it's current before you close.

What should I ask a seller about a Big Island home's nonconforming use certificate?

Ask the seller for a Big Island home's nonconforming use certificate, its expiration date and proof the yearly renewal was paid. Also ask for records showing the rental use hasn't stopped for 12 months in a row. The county code requires renewal on or before the date on the certificate, with a $250 fee. Then have the Planning Department confirm it's current.

Should I rent a Big Island home a little each year just to keep its certificate?

Renting a Big Island home a little each year could keep its certificate alive only if the rental use never stops for 12 months in a row. Whether a little counts is a question for your attorney. Renting also brings registration and tax duties, so weigh those against what the certificate adds when you sell.

Can I tell from a sale listing whether a Big Island home is rental-eligible?

You can't rely on a sale listing to show whether a Big Island home is rental-eligible, even when it says so. Eligibility rests on the parcel's zoning or a county certificate, and private rules can still ban rentals. Ask the county Planning Department to confirm it for that parcel before you pay anything extra.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields