Timing, taxes & the seller’s transaction

You’ll owe federal and Hawaiʻi tax on your gain, and a main home, an exchange or good records can lower or put off part of it. Foreign owners usually have 15% withheld at closing for the IRS, and it counts toward their tax when they file. The best time to sell comes from your own plans first, then the season.

Three questions run through the money side of a sale: what you owe, what you can put off and when to sell. Your CPA answers the first two for your situation. It helps to know the rules well enough that you’ll bring the right records and ask the right questions early.

What you owe starts with your gain, which is the sale price less your selling costs and your adjusted basis. The IRS taxes long-term gains at 0%, 15% or 20%, and Hawaiʻi’s long-term rate goes up to 7.25%. If the home was your main home for two of the last five years, up to $250,000 of gain, or $500,000 for a married couple filing jointly, may be excluded. A second home usually won’t qualify.

What you can put off depends on how you’ve used the property. A 1031 exchange lets an investment owner buy other investment real estate and defer the tax. The owner names a replacement within 45 days and receives it within 180, or by the tax return’s due date if that comes first.

The replacement can be anywhere in the United States, so it doesn’t have to be in Hawaiʻi. Talk to your CPA and an exchange intermediary before you list, because both clocks start the day you close.

Foreign owners have the most to plan for at closing. Under FIRPTA, the buyer usually holds back 15% of the price for the IRS, and a seller who isn’t a Hawaiʻi resident has another 7.25% held for the state. On a $3 million home, that’s $667,500. You can apply ahead of time to lower it, and any extra comes back when you file.

When to sell? When to sell starts with your own reasons, then the calendar. The selling season runs from just before Thanksgiving through the end of April, when the most visitors and part-time residents are on the island. May through September is slower. Plan backward so you’re listed inside the busy months.

Rental rules are part of timing for some owners. Bill 47, the county’s vacation rental registration law, has applied since September 1, 2026. A registration expires 90 days after a sale, so a buyer who’d keep renting has to register in their own name. If part of your home’s value comes from renting it, get your paperwork in front of an attorney before you list.

Once you know your tax picture, put it next to everything else that comes out at closing.

Every question in this topic

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields