Can I do a 1031 exchange when I sell my Big Island investment property, and how does that work in Hawaii?
You can do a 1031 exchange when you sell a Big Island investment property, and in Hawaiʻi it works under the same federal rules. You buy other investment real estate, meet the 45-day and 180-day deadlines, and the tax is put off. The replacement doesn't have to be in Hawaiʻi.
Key takeaways
- Investment property can qualify: the exchange covers real estate held for business or investment.
- Your main home can't be exchanged: property you use for personal purposes is left out.
- Two deadlines run at once: name a replacement in 45 days and receive it within 180 days, or by your return's due date if sooner.
- The replacement can be anywhere in the US: it doesn't have to be in Hawaiʻi, but foreign property won't work.
- The tax is put off: any cash you take out of the exchange can be taxed in the year of the sale.
Which Big Island properties qualify for a 1031 exchange?
Big Island properties qualify for a 1031 exchange when they’re held for investment or for use in a business. Only real property can be exchanged this way, and both sides of the trade have to meet that test (IRS Publication 544):
- Rental homes and condos held for investment
- Land held for investment
- Buildings used in a business
Your own home doesn’t qualify, and neither does property held mainly to resell. A vacation home qualifies only if it meets certain IRS requirements, so ask your CPA how yours has been used. The replacement has to be in the United States, but it doesn’t have to be in Hawaiʻi (Tax Facts 2010-1). Without an exchange, you’d owe capital gains tax on the sale.
What are the deadlines for a 1031 exchange after a Big Island sale?
The deadlines for a 1031 exchange after a Big Island sale are 45 days to name the replacement and 180 days to receive it. If your tax return for that year, with extensions, is due before day 180, that date comes first (IRS Publication 544).
- Sign a written exchange agreement with a qualified intermediary before you close
- Close the sale, and both clocks start that day
- By day 45, identify the replacement property in a signed document
- By day 180, or the return’s due date if sooner, receive the replacement
Your own agent or a related person can’t serve as the intermediary. If you receive the sale money before you get the replacement, the IRS treats the deal as a sale. If you take some cash out, that part can be taxed. Miss a deadline and the exchange fails.
How does Hawaiʻi handle a 1031 exchange on a Big Island property?
Hawaiʻi handles a 1031 exchange on a Big Island property under the same federal rule, which the state follows (Tax Facts 2010-1). The difference shows up at closing, in the state’s 7.25% withholding on sellers who aren’t Hawaiʻi residents.
The state withholding in an exchange
- If no gain is recognized, you can give the buyer Form N-289, with a summary of the facts, and the buyer doesn’t withhold
- If any gain is recognized, such as from cash you take, the full 7.25% is withheld
- Anything withheld is credited when you file your Hawaiʻi return
A foreign owner has a federal step too. The IRS notice that skips FIRPTA withholding can’t be used for an exchange that isn’t finished when the buyer’s withholding return is due. That seller needs an IRS withholding certificate, one of the ways foreign sellers get less withheld.
Can a Big Island seller exchange into a Delaware statutory trust?
A Big Island seller can exchange into a Delaware statutory trust if the trust meets the conditions in an IRS ruling. In Revenue Ruling 2004-86, the IRS said an interest in that kind of trust counts as owning part of the real estate it holds (IRS). It can be replacement property if the other 1031 rules are met.
Before you pick one, ask your CPA or tax attorney:
- Does this trust stay within the ruling’s limits on what the trustee can do?
- How will I report my share of its income each year?
- What tax will be due when the trust sells, or when I want my money out?
Like any 1031, a trust exchange puts the tax off. Your old basis carries into the new property, so the gain shows up when you later sell in a taxable sale.
Sources
- Internal Revenue Service, Publication 544, Sales and Other Dispositions of Assets (for 2025 returns)
- Hawaii Department of Taxation, Tax Facts 2010-1: Understanding HARPTA (revised April 2025)
- Internal Revenue Service, Internal Revenue Bulletin 2004-33, Revenue Ruling 2004-86 (Delaware statutory trusts)
Frequently asked questions
Can I move into a Big Island home I got through a 1031 exchange?
You can move into a Big Island home you got through a 1031 exchange, but only after holding it for investment first. The IRS says you can't convert the replacement to your main home right after the exchange. If you sell it within five years of getting it, you can't use the home sale exclusion. Talk to your CPA before you change how you use it.
Do I have to buy another Big Island property to complete a 1031 exchange?
You don't have to buy another Big Island property to complete a 1031 exchange. Hawaiʻi's Department of Taxation says the replacement doesn't need to be in Hawaiʻi. It does need to be real property in the United States, held for investment or business.
What happens if I can't find a replacement property within 45 days?
If you can't identify a replacement property within 45 days, the exchange fails and the sale is treated as a taxable sale. You can name more than one property in writing to protect yourself. The IRS has rules for how many you can name, so ask your intermediary.
Does a 1031 exchange change how much the buyer withholds at closing?
A 1031 exchange can change how much the buyer withholds at closing. If no gain is recognized, a nonresident seller can give Form N-289 and skip Hawaiʻi's 7.25% withholding. If you take cash or other property that isn't like-kind, the full 7.25% is withheld. A foreign owner whose exchange isn't finished when the buyer's FIRPTA return is due needs an IRS withholding certificate.