Is Big Island real estate a good investment?
Big Island luxury real estate works as an investment only when it earns more than your money would somewhere else, after every cost to buy, own and sell it. If it falls short, you’re paying for the lifestyle. That can still be a good reason to own here, if you decide it before you buy.
A luxury home here can work as an investment, but it’s got to pass the same test as anything else you own. The home has to beat what that money would earn elsewhere, once the costs come out. A 10-year Treasury note is one yardstick, and its rate moves, so check it the day you compare.
How prices here have done
Prices on the island have risen over the long run, with deep dips along the way. From 2000 to 2025, FHFA’s index for Hawaiʻi County rose 268%, against 197% for US home prices, though it trailed the US from 2005. Stocks did far better: the S&P 500 with dividends gained 712% from the end of 2000 to the end of 2025.
Over more than a century, research across 16 countries found housing and stocks each earned about 7% a year after inflation, with rent making up most of housing’s return.
Where a home’s value sits
Much of a home’s lasting value is in the lot. The county values the land and the building separately, and the building wears out while the land doesn’t. The view, the beach and the setting come with the land, so the lifestyle is part of what you can sell someday. Buyers from outside Hawaiʻi made 24.9% of the county’s single-family purchases in 2025. It’s smart to plan on some of your own future buyers coming from away.
The part only you can price
The weeks you spend in the home are part of what you’ll get back. No index or appraisal can put a number on them, so that value is yours to set. If that time matters a lot to you, a smaller return can still add up to the right buy.
Before you call it an investment, write down what your money earns today and the year you’ll want it back. Then run the numbers with real costs for the home you’re looking at.
Every question in this topic
Is Big Island luxury real estate actually a good investment, or just an expensive place to park money I enjoy?
A Big Island luxury home is an investment only if it beats what your money earns elsewhere, after the costs to buy, own and sell. Here's how to test it.
Do Big Island luxury homes appreciate, or is the value all in the lifestyle?
Big Island luxury homes tend to gain value through the land and the location. Here's how the county values land and buildings, and why the lifestyle counts.
How does Big Island real estate hold up as an investment compared to the stock market or mainland property?
Big Island home prices rose 268% from 2000 to 2025, against 197% for US homes, while stocks did far better. Here's how owning a home and a fund differ.