What to buy as an investment
If you’re buying for return, a single-family home in an area where homes like it sell every year suits most investors, because more of its costs are yours to decide. Condos and land can work too, once you’ve priced what each one adds. Pay extra for a club or for rental eligibility only up to what your next buyer would pay.
Pick the kind of home before the area, because condos, houses and lots don’t sell in the same places here. In 2025, North Kona had 364 house sales and 314 condo sales, while North Hilo had 19 house sales all year. More sales give you more recent prices to go by now, and more buyers when it’s your turn to sell.
A house, a condo or a lot
For most investors, the single-family home is the simpler buy, since you decide when to spend and what to fix. With a condo, the board sets the budget and the dues, and it decides who pays an insurance deductible.
Island condo prices have risen faster than house prices since 2019, from a median of $362,750 to $640,000, while condo sales dropped from 854 to 540. The two medians aren’t a fair match, since most condo sales are on the west side.
Ask a lender whether a condo’s building qualifies for the loans your next buyer will need, since UHERO expects new rules to leave some condo buildings without federally backed loans. A lot needs a county permit and a build before you can use it, so get a builder’s estimate before you put a price on one.
When a premium is worth paying
Two features can carry a premium here, and each pays you back only if your buyer pays for it too. In an equity community like Kūkiʻo or Hualālai, the club’s price to join and its dues are costs you’ll carry, and fewer buyers shop at that level.
Rental eligibility works the same way when you’ll never rent. Eligibility that comes from zoning stays with the land. One that rests on a county certificate can be lost once the rental use stops for 12 months in a row.
For either one, you’ll want to compare several years of sales of similar homes with and without the feature. Then pay no more than the gap you find. When too few homes of each kind have sold to show a gap, don’t be quick to pay any premium at all.
Every question in this topic
If I’m buying purely as an investment, where on the Big Island should I be looking?
Where to look on the Big Island as an investor: how many homes sell in each district every year, and what supports value, from zoning to the shoreline.
Condo, single-family, or land: what’s the smartest Big Island investment buy right now?
Condo, single-family home or land on the Big Island? How condo prices and sales have moved since 2019, what a condo owner shares, and where land fits.
Does buying in an equity community like Kūkiʻo or Hualālai make sense as an investment, or am I paying for lifestyle?
An equity community like Kūkiʻo or Hualālai as an investment: the club as a cost, each community's rental rules, and how to test the premium at resale.
Is a short-term-rental-eligible property worth a premium even if I never plan to rent it?
Rental eligibility is worth a premium to a never-renter only up to what your buyer would pay. What passes with a Big Island property, and how to measure it.