Do Big Island luxury homes appreciate, or is the value all in the lifestyle?

Big Island luxury homes sit in a market that has appreciated over the long run, with deep dips along the way. The lifestyle is part of the value because it comes with the land and location. The building wears out while the land doesn't, and the county values them separately. Buyers from away made 24.9% of single-family purchases in 2025.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • Two parts, two values: the county values each home's land and its building separately.
  • Buildings start from cost: the county values a building at what it would cost new, less depreciation for its age.
  • Land values follow land sales: the county sets them from what land sells for, so they can rise or fall.
  • The lifestyle comes with the lot: the view, the beach and the setting are tied to the land.
  • Buyers from away matter: 24.9% of Hawaiʻi County's single-family buyers in 2025 had a home address outside Hawaiʻi.

Where does a Big Island luxury home’s value sit, in the land or the building?

A Big Island luxury home’s value sits in both the land and the building, and the land is the part that doesn’t wear out. The county values the two separately, and in very different ways (County of Hawaiʻi Real Property Tax):

Part of the value How the county values it What happens to it over time
The land From land sales, per lot or per unit of land, then checked by neighborhood, zone and lot size It doesn’t wear out, so the IRS won’t let owners depreciate it (IRS Publication 946)
The building From what it would cost to build new, less depreciation for its age It wears out over the years and needs upkeep to hold its value
A condo unit From sales of similar condos, taken as a whole It follows sales of condos like it in the same complex and nearby

The county revalues both every year. The building starts from this year’s cost to build it new, less depreciation for its age. The land comes from recent land sales, so its value moves with what buyers will pay for that location. On any home you’re weighing, find what share of its county value is land.

Is the lifestyle part of a Big Island home’s value?

The lifestyle is part of a Big Island home’s value, because the view, the beach and the setting come with the land the home sits on. The county sets land values from land sales and checks them by neighborhood and zone, so a location buyers want shows up in what its land is worth. Three parts of the lifestyle are tied to the spot itself:

When two homes are close in price, compare their lots and settings first. For how far island prices have actually risen over the years, see how much Big Island luxury homes have appreciated.

How much of Big Island home buying comes from outside Hawaiʻi?

About a quarter of Big Island single-family home buying, and about half of condo buying, comes from outside Hawaiʻi. UHERO, the University of Hawaiʻi’s economic research group, used Title Guaranty’s data to count buyers who listed a home address outside the state on their deed papers in 2025 (UHERO Housing Factbook 2026):

Area Single-family sales to buyers from out of state Condo sales to buyers from out of state
Hawaiʻi County 24.9% of 2,214 transactions 49.3% of 615 transactions
Kailua-Kona (ZIP code 96740) 34.4% of 401 sales 49.1% of 318 sales
Hilo (ZIP code 96720) 12.7% of 283 sales 24.6% of 69 sales

UHERO counts transactions, and its 2025 counts don’t match the sales counts in Title Guaranty’s own reports.

The same factbook puts Kailua-Kona’s median single-family price at $1.2 million, against $550,000 in Hilo. So the ZIP code with more buyers from away also had the higher prices, though the factbook doesn’t say one causes the other.

When you sell in an area like Kailua-Kona, part of your pool of buyers will live somewhere else. Buyers from other states have also been spending more per home than buyers who live in Hawaiʻi. To see your own area, look for its ZIP code in UHERO’s data book.

How can I see the land and building values for a Big Island home?

You can see the land and building values for a Big Island home on the county’s property record, which lists a land value and a building value for each parcel. The county’s Real Property Tax Office links its property search from its own site. Here’s how to use it on the homes you’re weighing:

  1. Look up each home’s parcel on the county’s property search (how to find a property’s tax record)
  2. Note the land value and the building value for each home
  3. Compare land values between lots of about the same size, since lot size is one of the things the county checks its land values against
  4. Check the year each home was built, since the county takes more depreciation off an older building

The county sets these values for property tax and says no one should rely on them for any other purpose, which is part of what the county’s assessment tells an investor. So treat the split as a rough guide to where the value sits, and set your price from recent sales.

Sources

  1. County of Hawaiʻi Finance Department, Real Property Tax, Mass Appraisal Report (appraisal date January 1, 2025; report date June 2, 2025)
  2. IRS Publication 946 (2025), How To Depreciate Property
  3. UHERO, The Hawaiʻi Housing Factbook 2026, Data Book (May 7, 2026)

Frequently asked questions

Does a Big Island condo's value come mostly from the land?

A Big Island condo's value is hard to split into land and building, because the county values residential condos from sales of similar condos. So the split on a condo's record tells you less than it does for a house. Compare recent sales in the same complex, and in nearby ones, to judge what a unit is worth.

Why do two Big Island homes with similar houses have very different land values?

Two Big Island homes with similar houses can have very different land values because the county sets land values from land sales and checks them by neighborhood, zone and lot size. Land on a sought-after stretch of coast sells for more, and the county's land values follow those sales. So the two houses can match while the land under them doesn't.

Can a Big Island home's land value go down?

A Big Island home's land value can go down. The county sets land values from recent land sales, so when land sells for less, the county's land values follow. A good location doesn't promise a rising price, because the land's value still moves with what buyers will pay for that spot.

Why is the building value so low on an older Big Island home's county record?

The building value on an older Big Island home's county record is low because the county starts from what the building would cost to build new, then takes off depreciation as it ages. The land is valued separately, from land sales. A low building value doesn't tell you the home is in poor shape, so judge its condition with an inspection.

Communities where this comes up

Kailua-Kona

Kailua-Kona is the Kona side's town market and one of the busiest on the Big Island. Its condos and houses sell often, at prices between the Hilo side and the resorts, and many buyers come from out of state.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields