How does Big Island real estate hold up as an investment compared to the stock market or mainland property?

As an investment, Big Island real estate has kept pace with mainland property on price and fallen far behind the stock market. FHFA's Hawaiʻi County index rose 268% from 2000 to 2025, against 197% for the US, though it trailed from 2005. The S&P 500 with dividends gained 712% from the end of 2000 to the end of 2025.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • Ahead of the US since 2000: Hawaiʻi County's home price index rose 268% from 2000 to 2025, against 197% for the US.
  • Behind the US from 2005: a 2005 buyer saw a 74% rise through 2025, against 101% nationally.
  • Far behind stocks: the S&P 500 gained 712% with dividends from the end of 2000 to the end of 2025.
  • Similar over the very long run: research across 16 countries found housing and stocks each earned about 7% a year after inflation.
  • Built differently: a home is one property that's slow to sell, while a fund holds hundreds of companies.

How have Big Island home prices done against mainland home prices and stocks?

Big Island home prices have kept pace with mainland home prices, and they’ve trailed stocks by a wide margin. From 2000 to 2025 they rose 268%, against 197% for US home prices, while the S&P 500 with dividends gained 712% from the end of 2000 to the end of 2025. Here are three stretches, from one year’s home price index level to another’s (FHFA’s indexes, published by the St. Louis Fed):

Years Hawaiʻi County home prices US home prices
2000 to 2025 Up 268% Up 197%
2005 to 2025 Up 74% Up 101%
2020 to 2025 Up 58% Up 53%

The US figure for each year averages its four quarters. Aswath Damodaran’s yearly S&P 500 returns at NYU Stern run from one year-end to the next, so the stock windows can’t match those years exactly (NYU Stern). With dividends reinvested, the S&P 500 gained 712% from the end of 2000 to the end of 2025, and 692% from the end of 2005.

Moving those stock dates a year earlier still leaves stocks far ahead. The county index is built only from homes with Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac loans, so it doesn’t count cash sales and can’t tell you what luxury homes did on their own. For mainland luxury markets, see how the Big Island compares with Aspen, Scottsdale and Montecito.

What does long-run research say about housing against stocks?

Long-run research says housing and stocks have earned about the same over time, about 7% a year after inflation, across 16 advanced economies from 1870 to 2015. That’s what Jordà and four coauthors found in “The Rate of Return on Everything,” published in 2019 (the study). Here’s what else they found that matters if you’re buying here:

  • Price gains on housing were low on their own, around 1% a year after inflation, and rent made up most of the rest
  • Housing returns swung far less from one year to the next than stock returns did, across the countries in the study
  • In the study’s US figures, stocks earned more than housing on average, over the whole period and since 1950, with much bigger swings
  • Owning a spread of homes is much harder than owning a spread of stocks

The price indexes above leave the rent out. If you won’t rent the home, you won’t collect that part of the return in cash. You’ll get it as the use of the home instead, and only you can say what that use is worth to you. Count it in your own comparison, using the steps below.

How is owning a Big Island home different from owning stocks?

Owning a Big Island home is different from owning stocks in six ways: borrowing, selling time, the costs to buy and sell, yearly costs, how spread out your money is, and use. Here’s how the two compare, side by side:

What differs A Big Island home An S&P 500 index fund
Borrowing A mortgage can pay for much of the price (loans for out-of-state buyers) A margin loan can cover up to half the price at the start
Selling Months to find a buyer, then weeks to close (how long homes take) Any trading day, with the trade settled one business day later
Costs to buy and sell Much higher for each sale (what a seller nets) Much lower for each trade (the study)
Yearly costs Taxes and insurance every year, with upkeep on top The fund’s yearly fee
Spread of your money One home, in one neighborhood About 500 large US companies at once
Use A place you can stay Nothing you can use, though it may pay dividends

Before you move money from a fund into a home, pick the row that matters most to you and check the home against it.

How do I compare a Big Island home with my other investments?

To compare a Big Island home with your other investments, line them up over the same years and count what each one costs you along the way. Work through it in this order:

  1. Use the same start and end years for every investment you’re comparing
  2. For stocks, use a return that includes dividends, since a price chart doesn’t show them
  3. For the home, take what it costs you to buy, hold and sell out of the price gain
  4. Put your own value on the time you’ll spend in the home (what that time is worth), and add it to the home’s side
  5. Ask a financial advisor how much of your money should sit in one property, given everything else you own

For the return math on a single home, with and without a loan, read what return to expect on a Big Island luxury property.

Sources

  1. U.S. Federal Housing Finance Agency, All-Transactions House Price Index for Hawaii County, HI (ATNHPIUS15001A) and for the United States (USSTHPI) (Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, FRED)
  2. Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern School of Business, Historical Returns on Stocks, Bonds and Bills (updated January 5, 2026)
  3. Jordà, Knoll, Kuvshinov, Schularick and Taylor, The Rate of Return on Everything, 1870 to 2015 (Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2019; NBER Working Paper 24112, revised May 2019)

Frequently asked questions

Is real estate less risky than stocks?

Real estate has been steadier than stocks across whole countries, but a single home carries more risk than a whole housing market. Long-run research found housing returns swung far less than stock returns. Its authors note that one house, tied to one neighborhood, comes somewhat closer to stocks in risk, though the gap stays large.

Does a Big Island home pay me anything while I own it, the way stocks pay dividends?

A Big Island home won't pay you anything in cash while you own it, unless you rent it. Your return is the change in its price when you sell, plus the use you get from it along the way. Whether rent would cover a home's costs is an operating question for a property manager who manages rentals in that area.

Should I sell stocks to buy a Big Island home?

Whether to sell stocks to buy a Big Island home is a question for your financial advisor and your CPA. Selling stocks can bring a capital gains tax bill, and it moves your money from many companies into a single home. Have both of them run your numbers before you make an offer.

Do mainland homes appreciate faster than Big Island homes?

Mainland homes haven't always appreciated faster than Big Island homes. FHFA's indexes show Hawaiʻi County ahead of the US from 2000 to 2025 and from 2020 to 2025, and behind it from 2005 to 2025. The answer turns on the years you pick, and on which mainland market you mean.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields