How does Big Island luxury real estate compare to mainland luxury markets like Aspen, Scottsdale, or Montecito?
Big Island luxury real estate compares only loosely to mainland luxury markets like Aspen, Scottsdale or Montecito, because the public numbers are medians for whole counties or ZIP codes. On county medians, the Big Island sits between Scottsdale's county and Montecito's, and far below Aspen's. The luxury towns themselves ask more than their counties.
Key takeaways
- County numbers are only a start: the public figures are medians for whole counties, so they cover every kind of home.
- Scottsdale's county asks less: Maricopa County's median asking price was $499,000 in September 2026.
- Montecito's county asks more: Santa Barbara County's median asking price was about $1.72 million that month.
- Aspen's county asks the most: Pitkin County's median asking price was about $3.37 million in September 2026.
- The luxury towns ask more: the Aspen, Montecito and Scottsdale ZIP codes in the table below asked more than their county medians.
How do Big Island home prices compare with Aspen’s, Scottsdale’s and Montecito’s counties?
On county-wide medians, Big Island home prices sit between Scottsdale’s and Montecito’s counties, and far below Aspen’s. Here are the median asking prices in September 2026 (Realtor.com data, published by the St. Louis Fed, with Pitkin County from Realtor.com’s own county file):
| County | Luxury town in the county | Median asking price |
|---|---|---|
| Hawaiʻi County | The Kona-Kohala Coast resorts | $599,000 |
| Maricopa County, Arizona | Scottsdale | $499,000 |
| Santa Barbara County, California | Montecito | $1,720,750 |
| Pitkin County, Colorado | Aspen | $3,372,500 |
All three mainland counties asked less than a year earlier. Pitkin’s median was $3,622,500 in September 2025. Maricopa’s was $525,000, and Santa Barbara’s was $1,888,750. For how the Big Island’s number has moved, see whether now is the right time to sell or hold.
Why can’t county medians tell me what a luxury home costs?
County medians can’t tell you what a luxury home costs, because each one is the middle price of every home listed in a whole county. The luxury towns ask more than their counties. Here are Realtor.com’s ZIP code medians for September 2026:
| Town | ZIP code median asking price | County median |
|---|---|---|
| Aspen (81611) | $3,599,750 | $3,372,500 |
| Montecito (93108, which also takes in nearby areas) | $6,105,000 | $1,720,750 |
| Scottsdale (4 ZIP codes) | $967,500 to $2,327,500 | $499,000 |
Realtor.com flags the other six Scottsdale ZIP codes’ figures for review, so they’re left out. Those are still medians of every listing in each ZIP code, so they aren’t luxury prices either. On the Big Island, luxury starts at about $2 million to $2.5 million, against about $1 million in the Denver suburbs where I used to work. For what that gap means when you sell, see what changes when a home sells for millions.
For the price ranges here, see what luxury actually costs on the Big Island. For how far apart asking and sale prices run, see asking price against sale price.
What’s different about owning a luxury home on the Big Island compared with the mainland?
Owning a luxury home on the Big Island is different from owning one on the mainland mostly in the upkeep and the local rules. Plan for these before you compare prices:
- There are fewer people to hire for upkeep and repairs, so you can’t always shop around for bids
- Hawaiʻi County runs its own property tax, with its own classes and rates (Hawaiʻi Constitution), so read how property taxes work for an out-of-state buyer
- The county has its own vacation rental rules, and Bill 47 is the one to know here
- Resort and club communities charge dues, so get each one in writing
Most of these add to what the home costs you every year.
How should I compare a Big Island luxury home with a mainland luxury home?
To compare a Big Island luxury home with a mainland luxury home, line up the actual sales and the yearly costs of the specific homes. Take them in this order:
- Pick the homes you’re really weighing, one in each market
- Get recent closed sales of similar homes in each home’s own community
- Compare those sales home by home, and set the county medians aside
- Add up a year of holding costs for each home, such as its property tax and its dues
- Line up the help you’ll need while you’re away, and price it
To see how the Big Island compares with the other islands first, read whether the Big Island is the undervalued island.
Sources
- Realtor.com, Housing Inventory Core Metrics: Median Listing Price, Counties (Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, FRED)
- Constitution of the State of Hawaiʻi, Article VIII, Section 3 (Legislative Reference Bureau)
- Realtor.com, Real Estate Data Library: Housing Inventory Core Metrics, county and ZIP code files, September 2026
Frequently asked questions
Is Big Island luxury real estate cheaper than Aspen?
Whether Big Island luxury real estate is cheaper than Aspen's depends on the homes you compare, but on county medians the Big Island asks far less. Pitkin County, where Aspen sits, had a median asking price of $3,372,500 in September 2026, more than five times Hawaiʻi County's. Neither figure is a luxury price, so compare closed sales of similar homes.
Do Big Island homes cost more than homes in Scottsdale?
Big Island homes asked less than homes in much of Scottsdale in September 2026, going by median asking prices. Every Scottsdale ZIP code whose figures Realtor.com doesn't flag for review had a higher median than Hawaiʻi County's. Maricopa County as a whole, which takes in Phoenix too, asked less, at $499,000.
Are ZIP code medians a good way to compare luxury towns?
ZIP code medians are a better way to compare luxury towns than county medians, because a ZIP code covers a smaller area. They still mix every kind of home listed there, from condos to estates. Treat them as a rough guide, and use closed sales of similar homes for the real comparison.
Should I compare a Big Island luxury home with a Montecito home by the square foot?
Comparing a Big Island luxury home with a Montecito home by the square foot helps only when the two homes are alike in setting and age. Use closed sales from each home's own community, and compare them line by line.