Oahu has the city, Maui has the cachet. What does the Big Island have that justifies buying here?
Next to Oʻahu's city and Maui's cachet, the Big Island has more land and two very different sides to live on, and that's what justifies buying here. It has more land than Hawaiʻi's other four counties combined. Its sunny west side holds six major resorts, and its rainier east side is more affordable.
Key takeaways
- More room than the rest of the state: Hawaiʻi County has more land than Hawaiʻi's other four counties combined.
- A sunny west side: the Kona and Kohala side gets very little rain, which is why the major resorts are there.
- A rainier east side: the Hilo side gets far more rain, and it's more affordable to live there.
- Six major resorts: they run up the west coast from near the Kona airport to Mauna Kea.
- Start with the setting: decide where and how you want to live before you compare prices.
“To ask us to pick the favorite is like asking you to pick who's your favorite child, although I could do it.”
Dan Polimino
What does the Big Island offer buyers compared with Oʻahu and Maui?
The Big Island offers buyers more land than Oʻahu or Maui, and two very different sides to live on, from a sunny coast lined with resorts to a rainier, more affordable side around Hilo. For a buyer comparing the islands, that means:
- More land than the rest of the state put together
- A dry, sunny west side, where the major resorts are
- A wetter east side around Hilo, where homes cost less
- The lowest cost per square foot of the state’s four main counties
That last point has its own page: read whether the Big Island is the undervalued island. If you’re torn between here and Maui, see why you’d buy on the Big Island instead of Maui.
How big is the Big Island compared with the other Hawaiian islands?
The Big Island is bigger than all the other Hawaiian islands put together, measured by land area. Hawaiʻi County, which is the Big Island, has more land than the state’s other four counties combined (U.S. Census Bureau):
| County | Land area |
|---|---|
| Hawaiʻi County (the Big Island) | About 4,028 square miles |
| Maui County | About 1,162 square miles |
| Kauaʻi County | About 620 square miles |
| Honolulu County (Oʻahu) | About 601 square miles |
| Kalawao County | About 12 square miles |
Those four other counties add up to about 2,394 square miles. All that room is a big part of the island’s appeal.
How different are the west side and the east side of the Big Island?
The west side and the east side of the Big Island are very different in weather and in what you’ll find there. The state’s data book shows how far apart the rain is (State of Hawaiʻi Data Book):
| Side | Rain in 2024 | What’s there |
|---|---|---|
| West side (Kona and Kohala) | Under 7 inches at Kona Village | The major resorts and many second homes |
| East side (Hilo) | About 92 inches at Hilo Airport | More affordable homes and the county government |
Rain changes from year to year, but the gap is steady. In every year from 2009 through 2024, Hilo Airport got far more rain than Kona Village. For what homes cost on each side, see what luxury actually costs on the Big Island.
Where are the Big Island’s luxury resorts?
The Big Island’s luxury resorts are all on the west side, six of them running north from near the Kona airport to Mauna Kea. In that order:
| Resort | In one line |
|---|---|
| Kohanaiki | The newest of the six, with mostly newer homes |
| Kūkiʻo | A private club community |
| Hualālai | Home to a Four Seasons resort |
| Waikoloa Beach Resort | Mostly condos, with about two dozen single-family homes |
| Mauna Lani | Neighborhoods such as 49 Black Sand Beach and The Cape |
| Mauna Kea | The island’s first resort, built by Laurance Rockefeller |
Each one suits a different kind of buyer, depending on how you’ll use the home. For why homes there can be priced so far apart, read why similar Kohala Coast homes are priced millions apart.
How do I decide if the Big Island is the right island for me?
To decide if the Big Island is the right island for you, start with the life you want, then test it on the ground. Try it in this order:
- Decide how much sun you want, and how far you’re willing to drive for errands
- Choose between the sunny west side and the rainier, more affordable east side
- Visit the areas you like at the time of year you’d be here
- If Maui is the other island on your list, compare the two the way buying on the Big Island instead of Maui lays out
- Check the rules for the home you want, starting with what Bill 47 means for a home buyer
Sources
Frequently asked questions
Which side of the Big Island gets less rain?
The west side of the Big Island gets far less rain than the east side. In 2024, the gauge at Kona Village on the west side recorded under 7 inches, while Hilo Airport on the east side recorded about 92 inches, according to the State of Hawaiʻi Data Book.
Is it more affordable to live on the east side of the Big Island?
Living on the east side of the Big Island is more affordable than living on the west side. The trade-offs are more rain and, in some places, a longer drive to the grocery store and other errands.
Is the Big Island a good choice if I want room around my home?
The Big Island is a good choice if you want room around your home, because it has more land than the rest of the state combined. Lot sizes still vary a lot by neighborhood, so look at the lots in the areas you like.
Is Kona or Hilo the better side of the Big Island for a second home?
The Kona side is the better side of the Big Island for a second home if you want sun and the resorts, and the Hilo side if you'd trade more rain for a lower price. The west side is where the resorts are, and it's mostly sunny. Pick the side that fits how you'll use the home.
Communities where this comes up
Hualālai
Hualālai is the Four Seasons resort community at Kaʻūpūlehu on the Kona coast, where owners can join a private club that's open only to residents.
Kūkiʻo
Kūkiʻo is a private club community next to Hualālai on the Kona coast, where the club vets every member and short-term rentals aren't allowed.
Mauna Kea Resort
The Big Island's first resort, opened in 1965 on Kaunaʻoa Bay, with a historic hotel, two golf courses and a wide mix of condos, villas and homes.
Mauna Lani
An established Kohala Coast resort with two hotels, golf, condos and oceanfront neighborhoods such as Pauoa Beach and 49 Black Sand Beach.
Waikoloa Beach Resort
A 1,350-acre Kohala Coast resort known more for its condos than its houses, including some lower priced condos, with hotels, shopping and golf around ʻAnaehoʻomalu Bay.