How the Big Island compares
Big Island real estate is the least expensive of Hawaiʻi’s four main counties by the square foot, and far more houses sell here than on Maui. Against mainland luxury markets, its county median sits between Scottsdale’s county and Montecito’s, and far below Aspen’s. They’re broad county numbers, though, so the real test is one home against similar homes.
Start with the other islands. In September 2026, the Big Island’s typical listing asked $493 a square foot, the lowest of Hawaiʻi’s four main counties. The other three asked $705 to $1,019. Next to Maui County, the typical Big Island listing asked about $400,000 less. And about four of every five sales here over the past year were single-family homes, while in Maui County it was fewer than half.
A lower price per square foot doesn’t make a home a bargain by itself, though. To be undervalued, a home would have to sell for less than similar homes in similar places, and only a side-by-side look can show that. So treat the gap as a reason to look closely.
What the island does have is space, and two very different sides. Hawaiʻi County has more land than the state’s other four counties combined. Its dry, sunny west side holds the six major resorts, and its rainier east side around Hilo is more affordable.
Against the mainland, the comparison gets looser. On county medians, the Big Island sits between Maricopa County, where Scottsdale is, and Santa Barbara County, home to Montecito. It’s far below Pitkin County, where Aspen is.
Those medians cover every listing in a county, and the luxury towns ask more than their counties, so they can’t tell you what a luxury home costs. Owning here brings costs a mainland owner may not expect: fewer people to hire for upkeep, and the county’s own tax and rental rules.
Maui’s rules on renting to guests are changing, and the regulation and value topic covers what rental rules can do to a price. Whatever you’re comparing, use these broad numbers to pick where to look. Then visit the areas you’d live in. Go at the time of year you’d use the home most.
Every question in this topic
Why would I buy on the Big Island instead of Maui, where everyone seems to want to be?
Big Island listings asked about $400,000 less than Maui's in September 2026, and far more houses sell here. Here's how to choose between the two islands.
How does Big Island luxury real estate compare to mainland luxury markets like Aspen, Scottsdale, or Montecito?
How Big Island home prices compare with Aspen's, Scottsdale's and Montecito's counties, what those numbers miss, and what owning a home here takes.
Is the Big Island the ‘undervalued’ Hawaiian island, or is that just what people say to sell you on it?
Big Island homes ask less per square foot than homes in any other main Hawaiian county. Here's what that tells you and how to judge value yourself.
Oahu has the city, Maui has the cachet. What does the Big Island have that justifies buying here?
The Big Island has more land than the rest of Hawaiʻi combined, a sunny side lined with resorts and a rainier, more affordable side. Here's how to choose.