Is the Big Island the ‘undervalued’ Hawaiian island, or is that just what people say to sell you on it?

The Big Island has the lowest asking price per square foot of the four main Hawaiian counties, and calling it 'undervalued' is mostly what people say to sell you on it. In September 2026, its typical listing asked $493 a square foot, against $705 to $1,019 in the other three. Real differences between homes explain some of that gap.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • The Big Island costs least per square foot: of the four main counties, its typical listing asked the least, $493 a square foot, in September 2026.
  • The other islands ask far more: Honolulu County was at $705, Maui County at $894 and Kauaʻi County at $1,019.
  • Sales show the same gap: Big Island houses sold for about half as much per square foot as Maui County houses that month.
  • Cheaper isn't the same as undervalued: that would mean selling for less than similar homes in similar places.
  • Judge it yourself: compare closed sales of homes like the one you want, on the same side of the island.

How do Big Island home prices compare with the other Hawaiian islands?

Big Island home prices are the lowest of the four main Hawaiian counties by the square foot. Here are the median asking prices per square foot in each of them in September 2026 (Realtor.com data, published by the St. Louis Fed):

County Median asking price per square foot Median listing size
Hawaiʻi County (the Big Island) $493 1,328 square feet
Honolulu County (Oʻahu) $705 912 square feet
Maui County $894 1,025 square feet
Kauaʻi County $1,019 1,429 square feet

So a typical Big Island listing asks less for each square foot than a typical listing in Honolulu, Maui or Kauaʻi County. Maui County’s figure also covers Molokaʻi and Lānaʻi. For the asking prices themselves next to Maui’s, see why you’d buy on the Big Island instead of Maui.

Do Big Island homes also sell for less per square foot than Maui homes?

Big Island homes also sell for less per square foot than Maui homes, so the gap shows up in closed sales, too. Title Guaranty’s reports for September 2026 show these averages for homes that sold that month. Its Maui report covers Lānaʻi and Molokaʻi too:

  • Houses sold for about $476 a square foot on the Big Island, against about $920 in Maui County (Big Island report, Maui report)
  • Condos sold for about $737 a square foot on the Big Island, against about $920 in Maui County
  • These are one month’s averages, so they can swing from month to month

For a house, a Big Island buyer paid about half as much per square foot as a buyer in Maui County that month.

Does a cheaper square foot mean a Big Island home is undervalued?

A cheaper square foot by itself doesn’t make a Big Island home undervalued. One island-wide figure blends the Hilo side and the Kona side, which are very different markets. For how they differ, see what luxury actually costs on the Big Island.

What undervalued would have to mean

For a home to be undervalued, it would have to sell for less than similar homes in similar places. Only a comparison of like homes can show that. View, lot, setting and community can move a price a long way, which is why two similar Kohala Coast homes can be priced millions apart.

So a lower average tells you where to look closely.

How can I tell if a Big Island home is a good value?

You can tell if a Big Island home is a good value by comparing it with recent sales of similar homes nearby, then with similar homes on the island you’re weighing it against. Here’s a simple way to do it:

  1. Pick the area and the kind of home you want, such as a resort condo or a house on the Kona side
  2. Pull a year of closed sales of similar homes in that area
  3. Compare cost per square foot only between homes that are alike in view, setting and condition
  4. Do the same for the area you’d buy in on the other island
  5. Add a year of holding costs to each, starting with property taxes

To see how prices here have moved over the years, read how much Big Island luxury homes have appreciated.

Sources

  1. Realtor.com, Housing Inventory Core Metrics: Inventory Metrics by Geography, Hawaii (Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, FRED)
  2. Title Guaranty Hawaii, Residential Sales Report: Hawaii, September 2026
  3. Title Guaranty Hawaii, Residential Sales Report: Maui Island, September 2026

Frequently asked questions

Which Hawaiian county has the cheapest homes by the square foot?

Hawaiʻi County, the Big Island, has the cheapest homes by the square foot of the state's four main counties. Its median listing asked $493 a square foot in September 2026, with Honolulu County next at $705. Maui County's figure includes Molokaʻi and Lānaʻi along with Maui.

Are Big Island homes cheaper because something is wrong with them?

Big Island homes being cheaper doesn't mean something is wrong with them. A county-wide number covers every kind of home in every area, cheap and expensive alike. Judge any one home against similar homes nearby, and have it inspected before you buy.

Is a Big Island condo a better value than a Big Island house?

Whether a Big Island condo is a better value than a Big Island house depends on the setting. In September 2026, Big Island condos sold for more per square foot than houses, on average. Weigh the dues and the building's rules along with the price.

Is the Big Island a good place to buy if I want the most home for my money?

The Big Island is a good place to buy if you want the most home for your money in Hawaiʻi, because its square foot costs the least of the state's four main counties. Make sure the area and the weather fit how you'll live, too.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields