Condo, single-family, or land: what’s the smartest Big Island investment buy right now?

Of a condo, a single-family home and land, the smartest Big Island investment buy right now for most investors is a single-family home, because more of its costs are yours to decide. Condo prices have risen faster since 2019, but condo sales have fallen by more than a third. A land lot needs a build first.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • Condo prices rose faster: the island's median condo sale went from $362,750 in 2019 to $640,000 in 2025.
  • Condo sales fell by more than a third: Title Guaranty counted 854 condo sales on the island in 2019, and 540 in 2025.
  • The medians aren't a fair match: most condo sales are on the west side, while the house median covers the whole island.
  • A board shares control of a condo: it sets the budget and dues, and it decides who pays an insurance deductible.
  • The association insures the shared parts: unless the declaration or bylaws say otherwise, it buys the property insurance on the common elements.

“They both have their pros and cons, but if I've got to answer the question straight up, it's definitely a single-family home.”

Dan Polimino

How do a condo, a single-family home and land compare as a Big Island investment?

Compared as a Big Island investment, a condo puts a board in charge of shared costs, a single-family home leaves most costs to you, and land needs a permit and a build. Under Hawaiʻi law, a condo owner owns a unit and shares the rest of the property with the other owners (HRS §514B-3).

What to compare Condo Single-family home Land
What you own A unit, plus a share of the common elements The house and its lot The lot
Who sets shared costs The association’s board You, plus any association dues You, plus any association dues
When you can use it At closing At closing After a county permit and a build

Before you price a lot, get a builder’s estimate for the home you’d put on it. Whichever you choose, check whether you’d own the land or lease it.

How have Big Island condo prices and sales moved since 2019?

Big Island condo prices have risen faster than single-family prices since 2019, from a median of $362,750 to $640,000, while condo sales fell from 854 to 540. Those are the island’s full-year figures from Title Guaranty’s year-end reports.

Year Condo sales Median condo sale Median single-family sale
2019 854 $362,750 $379,000
2020 744 $395,000 $411,000
2021 1,172 $480,500 $484,000
2022 784 $570,000 $500,000
2023 602 $580,404 $510,000
2024 574 $649,500 $545,000
2025 540 $640,000 $550,000

The single-family column is the same series behind Big Island appreciation since 2019. The two medians aren’t a like-for-like match. Most condo sales are on the west side, as sales by district show, while the single-family median covers the whole island. Compare condos and houses in the same district. For 2026 so far, see whether the Big Island is in a down market.

What does a Big Island condo owner share with the association that a house owner handles alone?

A Big Island condo owner shares the dues and special assessments with the association, along with the building’s insurance and the rental rules. A house owner handles most of that alone.

  • Dues and special assessments. The board sets the budget, and owners can be charged extra when the reserves run short.
  • The building’s insurance. Unless the declaration or bylaws say otherwise, the association insures the common elements, and in a building with attached units it insures the units too, where that’s reasonably available. After a claim, the board can pay the deductible from common funds, charge the owner who caused the damage, or charge the owners of the units affected (HRS §514B-143).
  • Rental rules. The declaration sets how units can be used, and owners can vote to change the rules on rentals.

Loans matter too. UHERO expects new Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac rules to leave units in buildings that don’t comply without federally backed loans, and that’s a loan your next buyer may need. A house owner pays for every repair and decides when it happens.

How do I choose between a Big Island condo and a single-family home as an investment?

To choose between a Big Island condo and a single-family home as an investment, weigh the costs you’d control against the costs a board would control. Then check how often each kind of home sells nearby. Take these steps:

  1. Decide how long you’ll hold, since a board’s decisions add up the longer you own
  2. For the condo, get the budget and the reserve study, and read the board’s recent minutes for planned assessments
  3. Ask the association what its insurance covers and how the board handles deductibles
  4. Ask a lender whether the condo’s building qualifies for the loans your next buyer will want
  5. For the house, price a year of upkeep and insurance, since you’re the one who’ll carry them
  6. Count how many condos and houses sold in that area in each of the last three years, to see which draws more buyers

Then put the two side by side, and add a full year of costs to each price before you compare them.

Sources

  1. Title Guaranty Hawaii, Residential Sales Reports: Hawaii Island, December editions 2019 to 2025 and September 2026 (Market Statistics page)
  2. Hawaii Revised Statutes §514B-3, Definitions (condominiums; Hawaii State Legislature)
  3. Hawaii Revised Statutes §514B-143, Insurance (condominiums; Hawaii State Legislature)

Frequently asked questions

Are Big Island condo prices falling?

Big Island condo prices have dipped since 2024. The island's median condo sale was $649,500 in 2024 and $640,000 in 2025, per Title Guaranty. Through September 2026 it was $625,000 on 378 sales, which Title Guaranty puts 2.3% below the same months of 2025. Watch the newest numbers for the kind of condo you want.

Why is the Big Island's median condo price higher than its median house price?

The Big Island's median condo price has been higher than its median house price since 2022, and where each sells is one reason. Nearly all condo sales are in North Kona and South Kohala. The house median also counts hundreds of lower-priced homes in Puna and Kaʻū. So compare the two within one district.

Can a Big Island condo association make me pay an insurance deductible?

A Big Island condo association can make you pay an insurance deductible in some cases. Under Hawaiʻi's condo law, the board decides who pays after a claim. It can pay from common funds, charge the owner who caused the damage after notice and a hearing, or have the owners of the affected units pay.

Is a Big Island condo with low dues a better investment?

A Big Island condo with low dues is a better investment only if its reserves are healthy. Dues kept low by saving too little for repairs can come back later as a special assessment. Compare the dues with the reserve study and the board's recent minutes before you treat them as a bargain.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields