If I’m buying purely as an investment, where on the Big Island should I be looking?

If you're buying purely as an investment, look where Big Island homes like yours sell most often: North Kona and South Kohala for condos, and Puna, North Kona and South Hilo for houses. North Kona had 314 condo sales and 364 house sales in 2025, per Title Guaranty. Then compare each area's zoning, shoreline and room to build.

Dan Polimino · Broker · About Dan

Key takeaways

  • Sales are uneven across the island: in 2025, single-family sales ran from 848 in Puna to 19 in North Hilo.
  • Condos sell mostly on the west side: Title Guaranty's sales report counted 486 of the island's 540 condo sales in North Kona and South Kohala in 2025.
  • Zoning can add to value: the county allows whole-home vacation rentals in certain districts and resort areas, and elsewhere only with a certificate.
  • Room to build matters: empty lots and planned projects nearby can add homes that compete with yours at resale.
  • Compare like with like: check sales of the same type of home, at your price, in each area you're weighing.

How many homes sell each year in each part of the Big Island?

The number of homes that sell each year in each part of the Big Island ran from 848 single-family homes in Puna to 19 in North Hilo in 2025. North Kona led the island in condo sales, with 314 (Title Guaranty’s September 2026 report).

District Single-family sales, 2025 Condo sales, 2025 Single-family sales, January to September 2026
Puna 848 0 652
North Kona 364 314 283
South Hilo 243 53 180
South Kohala 181 172 129
Kaʻū 162 1 98
South Kona 86 0 38
North Kohala 65 0 32
Hāmākua 46 0 38
North Hilo 19 0 16

More sales give you more recent prices to compare, and more buyers when you sell. A district count still mixes very different homes, so ask for counts inside the community you’re weighing.

What supports a property’s value in one part of the Big Island more than another?

What supports a property’s value in one part of the Big Island more than another is zoning that allows whole-home rentals, a place on the shoreline, and little room left to build nearby.

Zoning for rentals
The county allows whole-home vacation rentals in certain zoning districts and resort areas, and elsewhere only with a nonconforming use certificate (Hawaiʻi County zoning code). Check each parcel’s rental eligibility before you pay for it, and weigh what eligibility is worth if you won’t rent.
The shoreline
Few Kona-side homes sit right on a beach, and county rules limit building near the shore. That’s part of why similar Kohala Coast homes are priced millions apart.
Room to build
Empty lots and planned projects can add homes that compete with yours when you sell. Ask the county Planning Department what the zoning allows on the land around you.

Each side of the island is a different market, too. The resorts sit on the sunny west side, and the rainier east side costs less.

How do I compare two Big Island areas as an investment?

To compare two Big Island areas as an investment, line up how often homes like yours sell in each, what supports their value, and what an owner there has to carry each year. Work through these steps for each area:

  1. Pick the type of home and the price range first, since each area’s market differs by both
  2. Count how many homes like that sold in each of the last three years, and how long they took to sell
  3. Check the zoning and any association rules, so you know what an owner there can and can’t do
  4. Look at how many lots nearby are still empty, and ask the Planning Department what’s planned
  5. Price a full year of owning costs, starting with property taxes for an out-of-state owner
  6. Note how many homes like yours are listed in each area right now, since that’s a sign of how much competition you’d face at resale

If renting is part of your plan, how a home would perform as a rental is an operating question. Put it to a property manager who manages rentals in that area.

Sources

  1. Title Guaranty Hawaii, Residential Sales Report: Hawaii, September 2026
  2. County of Hawaiʻi, Hawaiʻi County Code Chapter 25, Zoning (section 25-4-16, short-term vacation rentals; advance sheet updated August 5, 2026)

Frequently asked questions

Which part of the Big Island has the most home sales?

Puna had the most single-family home sales on the Big Island in 2025, with 848, followed by North Kona with 364 and South Hilo with 243. For condos, North Kona led with 314 sales, followed by South Kohala with 172, according to Title Guaranty.

Can I buy an investment condo anywhere on the Big Island?

You won't find investment condos just anywhere on the Big Island, since nearly all of its condo sales are in two west side districts. In 2025, Title Guaranty's sales report counted 486 of the island's 540 condo sales in North Kona and South Kohala, and 53 in South Hilo. Several districts, including Puna, had none.

Does a district's sales count tell me how fast a Big Island home will sell?

A district's sales count tells you how active its market is, but it can't tell you how fast one Big Island home will sell. A busy district can still have homes that sit for months at the wrong price. For one home, look at how long similar homes nearby took to sell.

How many years of sales should I check before choosing a Big Island area?

Check at least three years of sales before choosing a Big Island area, because one year can mislead. North Kona's single-family sales, for example, were 356 in 2023, 411 in 2024 and 364 in 2025, per Title Guaranty. A single year could give you a different picture.

Dan Polimino · Broker

Dan Polimino has 19 years of real estate experience and over 1,300 completed transactions. He leads The Hawaii Team and operates Big Island Stays from Kailua-Kona.

About The Hawaii Team

Ready To Get Started?

Contact Us Today!

Please fill out the form and we'll get back to you shortly.

    Hidden form fields